Five Centre regulars were natives of Fort Worth, Texas, namely quarterback Bo McMillin, Bill James, Sully Montgomery, Matty Bell, and Red Weaver. They were accused of being professionals, but the charges were rebuked by season's end. "Without Bo it would not be a Centre team." Former Centre player and North Side High Schoolhead coach Robert L. Myers was to bring McMillin, Weaver, and the above teammates to Centre. However, McMillin and Weaver did not have sufficient credits to enter college, and thus entered Somerset High School for the 1916-17 year, playing with Red Roberts. Centre's linemen were known as the "Seven Mustangs".
Schedule
A game with Maryville College was scheduled but never played due to Maryville injuries.
Season summary
Week 1: Hanover
Sources:
On opening day, Centre swamped Hanover 95–0. Eight different players scored. Roberts was shifted from fullback to tackle, and played well. The starting lineup was King, Roberts, Montgomery, Bell, Van Antwerp, Coleman, Whitnell, McMillin, Murphy, Davis, Diddle.
Centre beat Indiana 12–3. Indiana was up 3–0 with 2:20 left in the game, when Centre started its comeback victory. McMillin and Roberts worked it towards the goal, Roberts going over. Indiana was then desperate to even the score, and McMillin intercepted a pass, and returned it for a touchdown, dodging and straight arming the entire Indiana eleven. Indiana's three points came early in the first period, when its quarterback, Mathys, made a 35-yard drop kick. The starting lineup was Whitnell, Montgomery, Van Antwerp, Garrett, Coleman, James, McCullom, McMillin, Bittle, Davis, Roberts.
In the fourth week of play, the Colonels beat the Transylvania Pioneers 69–0. Transylvania's Milton broken several bones in his foot the week previous.
Week 5: at Virginia
Sources:
Centre's backfield starred and smashed the Virginia Cavaliers 49–7 in the mud. Joe Murphy had a 75-yard touchdown run. Soon after, McMillin went 70 yards for a touchdown. Kuyk scored Virginia's points. The starting lineup was Bell, Montgomery, Van Antwerp, Weaver, Cregor, James, Snoddy, McMillin, Armstrong, Davis, Roberts.
Week 6: at West Virginia
Sources:
The sixth week of play brought the highlight of the season — a 14–6 comeback win over West Virginia and the nation's leading scorer Ira Rodgers. McMillin had the team pray before the game, forever giving the Centre College Colonels its alternate moniker of "Praying Colonels." Rodgers came out passing and West Virginia scores first early when he bucked it over. Later, a 25-yard pass from McMillin to Terry Snoddy brought the ball near the goal. Roberts eventually scored. Centre had another touchdown drive in the last quarter, ending in McMillin sidestepping for a touchdown. Murphy was in a flimsy track suit and track shoes. The starting lineup was Bell, Montgomery, Van Antwerp, Weaver, Cregor, Jones, Snoddy, McMillin, Davis, Armstrong, Roberts.
With a large crowd at home on Cheek Field, the Colonels beat rival Kentucky State 56–0, giving the Wildcats their worst loss on the season. Roberts had three touchdowns. The starting lineup was Bell, Montgomery, Van Antwerp, Weaver, Cregor, James, Snoddy, McMillin, Davis, Armstrong, Roberts.
Week 8: vs. DePauw
Sources:
The Colonels defeated the DePauw Tigers in Louisville 56–0. McMillin's passes "aroused the wonderment of the crowd." The first touchdown came on an 18-yard pass to Army Armstrong. The starting lineup was Bell, Montgomery, Van Antwerp, Weaver, Cregor, James, Snoddy, McMillin, Armstrong, Davis, Roberts.
Week 9: at Georgetown
Sources:
Centre rolled up a 77–7 score on the Georgetown Tigers. Georgetown's one score came off a 65-yard fumble return. Weaver made 11 straight extra points. The starting lineup was Bell, Montgomery, Van Antwerp, Weaver, Cregor, James, Snoddy, McMillin, Davis, Armstrong, Roberts.
Postseason
Legacy
made 47 out of 48 extra points with 46 in a row, and held the NCAA record with 99 consecutive points after touchdowns in the 1919 and 1920 seasons. Weaver was put at the placekicker position on an Associated Press Southeast Area All-Time football team 1869-1919 era. The season brought national attention to the small town of Danville.
Awards and honors
Due to the dispute over professionalism, most writers picked Auburn as SIAA champion. The team was retroactively selected by Jeff Sagarin as the national champion for the 1919 season. McMillin and Weaver were named to Walter Camp's first-team 1919 College Football All-America Team. Just the year before Bum Day was the first Southern player ever selected to Camp's first team – and Centre became the first school with two. Fullback and end Red Roberts was named to Camp's third team.
Players
Depth chart
The following chart provides a visual depiction of Centre's lineup during the 1919 season with games started at the position reflected in parenthesis. The chart mimics a single wing on offense.
Starters
Line
Backfield
Subs
Line
Backfield
Scoring leaders
The following is an incomplete list of statistics and scores, largely dependent on newspaper summaries.
