The 1925 Stanley Cup Finals saw the Western Canada Hockey League champion Victoria Cougars defeat the National Hockey League champion Montreal Canadiens three games to one in a best-of-five game series. The Canadiens were substitute NHL representatives, as the final series to decide the NHL champion was not played. The Cougars were the last non-NHL team to win the Cup as the WCHL folded after 1926, leaving the Stanley Cup to become the NHL's de facto championship trophy. The Cougars would also be the last team based west of Chicago to win the Cup until the Edmonton Oilers won the trophy in 1984. These were also the last Stanley Cup Finals games to be played in Western Canada until the Vancouver Canucks qualified for the 1982 Finals. Games one, three and four were held in Victoria. Game two, held in Vancouver, was the last neutral site game in Stanley Cup Finals history that did not involve the New York Rangers.
Path to the Finals
Prior to the season, the Pacific Coast Hockey Association folded and two of its teams, the Cougars and the Vancouver Maroons joined the WCHL. Victoria finished the 1924–25 WCHL regular season in third place, but eventually upset the Calgary Tigers in the two-game total goals WCHL championship series by a combined score of 3–1. Meanwhile, the Canadiens also finished the NHL regular season in third place. In the NHL playoffs, Montreal went on to beat the second place Toronto St. Patricks, 5–2, in a two-game total goals series. The winner of that series was to go on and play the first place Hamilton Tigers. However, the Tigers were suspended after Hamilton players staged a strike in an attempt to receive more compensation because the league extended the regular season from 24 to 30 games. As a result, the Canadiens were declared the 1924–25 NHL champions.
- NHL Championship Roster Montreal Canadiens - Louis Athanase David^, Jeosph Cattarinich^, Louis Letourneau^, Leo Dandurand^, Napolean “Nap” Dorval^, Cecil Hart^, Amerdee Monte Judge, Harry Elliot^, Fernand Rinfeet^, Edouard St. Pere^, #1 Georges Vezina^, Alphonse "Frenchy" LaCroix, #2 Spraque Cleghorn^, #10 Fern “Curly” Headley, #9 Sylvio Mantha^, #5 Billy Boucher^, #7 Howie Morenz^, #4 Aurel Joliat^, #6 Ogilvie “Odie” Cleghron^, #3 Wilfred "Billy" Coutu^, #9 Johnny Matz, #12 Rene "Bobby" Joliat, #11 Ronald “Rene” Lafleur, #11 David Ritchie, Ed Dufour^.
^-Name was engraved on the Stanley Cup with Montreal in 1924. The Montreal Canadiens are only NHL champion to lose the Stanley Cup Final.
Game summaries
With the demise of the PCHA, the Stanley Cup playoffs reverted to a single best-of-five series to determine the champion. However, the Cup Finals still annually rotated between the east and the west, and thus all of the games in the 1925 Finals were played on the West Coast. Games one, three and four were played at the 4,200 seat Patrick Arena in Victoria; Game two was played at the Denman Arena in Vancouver. The decision to use the larger Denman Arena for game two was based on the huge demand for tickets. The Cougars jumped to a two games to none series lead with 5–2 and 3–1 victories, but the Canadiens won game three, 4–2. In game four, Gizzy Hart scored the game-winning goal in Victoria's 6–1 win to clinch the Cup. Cougars goaltender Hap Holmes recorded a 2.00 goal-against average for the series. Jack Walker led Victoria in goals with four, while Frank Fredrickson scored three. Overall, eight different player combining for the Cougars' 16 goals.
