On September 21, in the season opener in Tempe, Arizona State suffered a 33–13 home loss to Wichita State. On September 28, the Sun Devils bounced back with a 14–13 home victory over New Mexico State. ASU delivered an impressive 50–7 road win against Colorado State on October 5. On October 12, the Devils prevailed for a 24–16 home victory over West Texas State. Arizona State recorded a 27–0 road shutout win against Texas-El Paso on October 19. Following a bye week, the Sun Devils defeated Utah 30–22 at Sun Devil Stadium on November 2. On November 9, ASU outlasted San Jose State for a 21–19 road win. The Devils beat Wyoming, 35–6, in Tempe on November 16. Arizona State's home game against Idaho, scheduled November 23, was cancelled out of respect for Pres. John F. Kennedy who was assassinated one day earlier. In the Arizona–Arizona State football rivalry game, the Sun Devils closed their season with a 35–6 home victory over Arizona on November 30.
Roster
Arizona State's usual offensive lineup included wide receiver Alonzo Hill, left tackle Frank Mitacek, left guard Bob Kec, center Chris Stetzar, right guard Joe Kush, right tackle/punter John Seedborg, tight end Herman Harrison, quarterback John Jacobs, halfback Gene Foster, fullback Tony Lorick, and wingback Charley Taylor. Rick Davis, John Folmer, Ben Hawkins, Darrell Hoover, Chuck Kolb, Bob Lueck, Jim Murphy, Joe Pico, Jerry Smith, and John Torok were also on the roster.
Rushing: Tony Lorick, 105 carries for 805 rushing yards and a 7.7 yard average;
Passing: John Torok, 41 of 79 passing for 600 yards, a 51.9% completion percentage, eight touchdowns and five interceptions;
Scoring: Tony Lorick, 54 points on nine touchdowns;
Receiving: Herman Harrison, 23 receptions for 371 yards and four touchdowns;
Interceptions: Tony Lorick, four interceptions and 107 return yards;
Punting: John Seedborg, 31 punts for 1,164 yards and an average punt of 37.5 yards;
Kickoff returns: Charley Taylor, six returns for 183 yards;
Punt returns: Charley Taylor, nine returns for 125 yards.
Tony Lorick tied a single season school record with two interceptions returned for touchdowns. Arizona State set a single-season school records for the fewest offensive plays and for the fewest fumbles recovered. Arizona State team statistics included the following:
Rushing: 226.4 yards per game on offense, 155.4 rushing yards allowed per game on defense;
Passing: 133.0 yards per game on offense, 122.3 yards allowed per game on defense;
Total offense: 359.4 yards per game on offense, 277.8 yards allowed per game on defense;
Scoring: 27.7 points per game on offense, 13.6 points allowed per game;
First downs: 162 first downs on offense, 126 first downs allowed on defense; and
Punts: 37 total punts for an average of 38.8 yards, opponents punted 55 times for an average of 35.8 yards.
Awards and honors
Fullback Tony Lorick and wingback Charley Taylor received first-team honors on the 1963 All-Western Athletic Conference team. Tight end Herman Harrison, right guard Joe Kush, and right tackle/punter John Seedborg received second-team honors. Team awards were presented as follows:
Fullback Tony Lorick won the Sun Angel Award;
Center Chris Stetzar won the Mike Bartholomew Award;
Joe Pico won the Cecil Abono Captains Award for the second consecutive season; and
Right tackle and punter John Seedborg won the Glen Hawkins Sportsmanship Award.
Fullback Tony Lorick and wingback Charley Taylor played in the 1964 Coaches All-America Game and the 1964 College All-Star Game. Taylor earned MVP honors for the college squad in the Chicago Tribune sponsored charity game with the NFL champions. Taylor also played in the 1964 East-West Shrine Game and the 1964 Hula Bowl.