Though Mets managerGil Hodges acquired Weis primarily for his glove, he earned the dubious distinction of being the player whose error ended the longest game by time in Major League Baseball history on April 15, in his Mets debut. In the bottom of the 24th inning against the Houston Astros in the Astrodome, Weis allowed Bob Aspromonte's bases-loaded ground ball to go through his legs, scoring Norm Miller with the lone run of the game. For the season, Weis batted.172 with one home run and twelve RBIs, backing up Bud Harrelson and Ken Boswell at the middle infield positions. Weis developed the flair for the dramatic home run during the season. On July 15, facing the first place Chicago Cubs at Wrigley Field, he hit a three run home run off former Met Dick Selma to lead the second place Mets to a 5-4 victory. Weis hit his second of two home runs for the season the following day, and the Mets won again to close the gap to just four games in the National League East. The Cubs widened that gap back up to ten games before the Mets began the improbable surge that saw them take first place on September 10, and win the division by eight games to face the Atlanta Braves in the first ever National League Championship Series. Ken Boswell was the star of the 1969 National League Championship Series, hitting two home runs, and leading his team with five RBIs. Weis, meanwhile, only logged one at bat, reaching first on a Clete Boyer error in the ninth inning of game two. However, he received far more playing time in the World Series. The National League and American League's Cy Young Award winners faced off in game one of the World Series. The Orioles scored four runs in five innings off Tom Seaver. Meanwhile, Mike Cuellar pitched a complete game, with Weis' sacrifice fly in the seventh inning accounting for the only Mets run. The Mets' slim chances of beating the heavily favored Orioles seemed even slimmer when Jerry Koosman and Dave McNally took the mound for game two of the series. Both pitchers were at their best, and the score was tied at one when Weis came to the plate with two outs in the ninth inning. With runners on first and third, Weis singled to left field to drive in the game winning run. Koosman and McNally faced each other again in game five, with the Mets holding a commanding three to one game lead. McNally got his team on the board first with a two run home run in the third. Three batters later, Frank Robinson hit a solo home run to bring the Orioles' lead to 3-0. Donn Clendenon's two run shot in the sixth brought the score to 3-2. Leading off the seventh, Weis took McNally deep to left field to tie the game. The Mets scored two runs in the bottom of the eighth to seal their improbable World Series win. For the series, the career.219 hitter batted.455 with three RBIs. Clendenon was named World Series MVP, while Weis received the Series' Babe Ruth Award. Weis' playing time in the second half of the season diminished substantially when former first overall draft pick Tim Foli was brought up to the majors. He was released by the Mets midway through the season, having appeared in just eleven games that year.
Career statistics
As the weather got hot, so did Weis. He batted.260 with two home runs and 25 RBIs in the month of July for his career, far better than any other month. Weis fared far better against lefties than righties, having hit five of his seven career home runs with a.235 average against southpaws. All seven of his regular season home runs were hit as a visiting player. The only home run he ever hit in a home stadium was the World Series home run off McNally at Shea Stadium. McNally is also the only pitcher Weis has hit two home runs against, serving up his second career home run on June 18, 1964.