A right back, Feeley joined hometown club Hereford United as an apprentice and made his first team debut in a Fourth Division match versus Bournemouth on 14 October 1978, at the age of just 17 years and 14 days. He became a regular pick throughout the rest of the 1978–79 season, making 25 appearances and even captaining the club, the youngest player ever to do so. After signing a professional contract, he was again a first team regular during the 1979–80 season, making 29 appearances and scoring three goals. He departed Edgar Street in 1980, after making 53 appearances and scoring three goals.
Feeley signed for Southern League Midland Division club Trowbridge Town in 1980. He enjoyed a good season with the club, which finished third and was the only club from the division to win promotion to the Alliance Premier League. Feeley averaged 28 games per season in the Alliance Premier League for struggling Trowbridge, before departing Frome Road in January 1984. He made 85 appearances and scored 12 clubs during his time with the club in the Alliance Premier League.
Leicester City
In a surprise move, Feeley signed for First Division club Leicester City in January 1984. He had to wait until 10 March to make his debut, which came with a baptism of fire against Manchester United at Old Trafford. Feeley started in the 2–0 defeat and was brought off for Tommy English. He made two further appearances during what remained of the 1983–84 season. He established himself in the first team in the 1984–85 season, making 41 appearances and winning the club's Player of the Year award. Knee injuries reduced his appearance-count over the next two seasons and he departed the club in June 1987, after refusing a new contract. Feeley made 86 appearances during three and a half years at Filbert Street.
Brentford
Feeley dropped down to the Third Division to sign on trial for Brentford in August 1987 and subsequently signed a permanent contract. Though never fully fit during his two years at Griffin Park, he managed 88 appearances and was a member of the team which reached the quarter finals of the FA Cup during the 1988–89 season, going out 4–0 to eventual winners Liverpool.
Bury
Feeley joined Third Division club Bury in July 1989. He made 57 league appearances and scored three goals in two seasons with the Shakers. While working in the youth system at Bury in 2002, Feeley turned out for a Bury Veterans XI in a benefit match against their Bolton Wanderers counterparts.
Feeley dropped back into Non-League football in 1991 to sign for Conference club Northwich Victoria. He made 13 appearances and scored one goal during his spell.
Feeley signed for Bolton Combination club Seedfield Sports in the summer of 1996. He scored with a 30-yard strike to send the club through to the last 16 of the Lancashire Amateur Shield.
Managerial and coaching career
Seedfield Sports
While with Seedfield Sports, Feeley served as the club's assistant manager.
Bury
In the late 1990s, Feeley returned to former club Bury, working in the commercial and community areas. He later returned to the football club, serving as Director of Youth, overseeing the club's Centre of Excellence and managing the club's youth and reserve teams. He oversaw the development of future international players David Nugent and Colin Kazim-Richards. He coached the U19 team to the semi-finals of the 1999–00 Youth Alliance Cup, losing 2–0 to Scunthorpe United to be denied a chance of a place in the final at Wembley Stadium. For a time Feeley served as first team coach, before being replaced by Billy Ayre in December 2000. While Ayre was receiving treatment for cancer in July 2001, Feeley again stepped into the role.
Ramsbottom United
Feeley was appointed manager of North West Counties League Premier Division club Ramsbottom United in June 2008. Despite having to virtually rebuild the playing squad from scratch, he led the Rams to the top of the table early in the 2008–09 season. Feeley departed the club in February 2009.
