In 2007 Edelman loaned Courier 1, a painting by American painter Robert Ryman, to the Swiss-based Galerie Gmurzynska for exhibition at Art Basel Miami Beach. After its return, the painting was sent to a dealer in New York for consignment, but was found to be damaged. According to Edelman, the painting had a "big gouge", rendering the artwork "a total loss". The painting had been insured for $750,000 with Edelman’s insurer, XL Specialty Insurance. Edelman claimed that the Gmurzynska had disputed the case and had instructed its own insurer not to pay. XL Specialty Insurance made Edelman its assignee, and he then sued the gallery for $750,000 plus a further $250,000 for “willful conduct of defendant” and “reprehensible motives and such wanton dishonesty as to imply a criminal indifference to civil obligations.” In October 2009 a New York district court awarded a judgement of $767,438 against the gallery. Using a writ of execution for an unanswered lawsuit, Edelman arranged for the US Marshals Service to confiscate some of the gallery's works at the opening of the Art Basel Miami Beach fair. Marshals removed four paintings which Edelman valued at $6 million. The gallery denied instructing its insurer to withhold payment and claimed that they had no knowledge of the judgement; they paid up and the paintings were returned to the stand. In 2010 Edelman was sued by Emigrant Savings Bank over $3 million of loans. Collateral on the loans included a sculpture by Alberto Giacometti, Torse de Femme. Edelmann sold the sculpture and paid the debt plus $1.1 million in court judgements. He then sued Emigrant for fraud. In February 2014 Edelman's company ArtAssure sued the Swiss company Artmentum for breach of contract and allegedly fraudulent representations. ArtAssure were offered a collection of over 100 paintings from the 19th and 20th centuries, supposed to have been in the ownership of Hiroshima Bank of Japan, at a discounted price of €350 million. The sale was contingent on the purchase being made through Artmentum for confidentiality. After several months of negotiations, Artmentum failed to provide evidence that they were authorised to sell the collection. The claim for $204 million was brought before a judge in a New York court. The claim was dismissed on the grounds that Artmentum was a Swiss company, with few commercial activities in the US, and therefore the case was outside the jurisdiction of the court. In April 2011, Mr. Edelman was sued by a Limited Partner of his in an investment vehicle, Museum Partners LP, of which Edelman was the General Partner. This lawsuit was primarily for breach of fiduciary duty and called for very substantial reparations. This suit was ultimately dismissed by the court on the technicality that the plaintiff no longer had standing as a Limited Partner by reason of having agreed to an oral contract alleged by Mr. Edelman to purchase the interest of the Limited Partner in the Partnership. However, the decision of the court did result in a final judgment against Mr. Edelman of about $250,000 and accruing interest. There is no further record that this judgment has been paid by Mr. Edelman despite the long duration of this litigation.
Personal life
Edelman has been married four times. His first wife was England-born Antonia Patricia Simpson, the daughter of Gerald Gordon Simpson, British deputy consul general in New York. His second wife was Penelope Cox Edelman; they had three children: Danielle lisa and Alexandra before divorcing. His third wife was Brazilian-born Maria Regina Leal Costa Mayall Edelman. His fourth wife is Michelle Vrebalovic Edelman. His son Christopher is a music producer.
