Barney Pelty, was a major league baseball pitcher known as "the Yiddish Curver" because he was one of the first Jewish baseball players in the American League. His career ERA is 2.63, 64th-best through 2017 of all pitchers in major league baseball. Through 2017 he ranked 82nd in hits per 9 innings, and 78th in batters plunked. He was as of 2017 in the top-10 for his career of all pitchers in the St. Louis Browns/Baltimore Orioles franchise in hit by pitch, complete games, ERA, and innings pitched and shutouts. He was one of the bestJewish pitchers in major league history, ranking 1st in career ERA, 6th in wins, and 7th in strikeouts.
Pelty was born in Farmington, Missouri, where his family was the only Jewish family at the time. His parents were Samuel and Helena Pelty, who were both Jewish, and he was the youngest of six children. His father was a cigar maker, and opened up a cigar store. He and his wife had a son, who became the city engineer of Farmington.
College
Pelty was offered free tuition at the now-defunct Carleton College in Farmington, Missouri to pitch for them. While attending Carleton, he met Eva Warsing, whom he married. After two years at Carleton, Pelty transferred to Blees Military Academy in Macon, Missouri, and pitched for the Academy team in the 1899 and 1900 spring seasons.
The Boston Red Sox and the St. Louis Browns got into a bidding war for him in 1903, and the Browns won with an offer of $850. Pelty was 22 years old when he made his Major League debut that year. He became a coach when not pitching. Pelty was a workhorse for the Browns, a member of their starting rotation from 1904, when he pitched 31 complete games and 301 innings, through 1911. In 1904 Pelty led the league in hit batsmen, and was 6th in wild pitches, while pitching 31 complete games. In 1905 he was 14–14 with a 2.75 ERA, while the team's other pitchers were a combined 40–85. His peak year was 1906, when Pelty went 16–11 with a 1.59 ERA. He also led the league in fewest hits allowed per 9 innings pitched and lowest batting average against, and was 2nd in hit batsmen. He especially was dominant against the World Series champion 1906 White Sox, allowing one run in 32 innings. In one three-game series against Chicago, Pelty pitched every game, including a 0–0 tie in 10 innings. His 1.59 ERA is the lowest in the history of the Browns/Baltimore Orioles franchise, and his Walks & Hits per IP of 0.951 is the 2nd-lowest. In 1907 he lost a league-high 21 games and hit a league-high 19 batters, while pitching 5 shutouts and 29 complete games. In 1908, the right-hander improved to 7–4, 1.99 ERA in a reduced role. In 1909 Pelty pitched 5 shutouts, 5th-best in the AL. He also was 10th-best in the league in fewest hits allowed per 9 innings pitched. On June 11, 1912, he was purchased for $2,500 by the Washington Senators from the St. Louis Browns. Pelty finished his career with the Senators that year. He gave up 22 home runs in 1,908 innings in his career. Pelty did not mind pitching inside, leading the league in hit batsmen in 1904 and 1907. While he gave up only 558 earned runs lifetime, errors by his teammates let in nearly another 200 unearned runs lifetime. Pelty pitched 22 career shutouts, but was shut out 32 times, including nine 1–0 defeats due to poor offensive support. Pelty's career ERA is 2.63, 64th-best through 2017 of all pitchers in major league baseball. Through 2017 he ranked 82nd in hits per 9 innings, and 78th in batters plunked. He was as of 2017 in the top-10 for his career of all pitchers in the St. Louis Browns/Baltimore Orioles franchise in hit by pitch, complete games, ERA, and innings pitched and shutouts. In his career, through 2010 Pelty was one of the all-time best Jewish pitchers in major league history, ranking first in career ERA, 6th in wins, and 7th in strikeouts.
Later years
In 2010, Farmington City Council voted to name an access road leading to a Sports Complex "Barney Pelty Drive" in his honor. In 2016, Pelty was inducted into the first class of the Farmington Hall of Fame.
Miscellaneous
It was often erroneously reported that he had changed his name from Peltheimer.
Pelty was proud of his Jewish heritage, as indicated by his nickname, and did not change his name or hide his identity like some other Jewish players of the era.
During his career, Pelty ran a bookstore in his Farmington hometown in the off-seasons. He worked as an inspector for the Missouri State Pure Food and Drug Department, and was an alderman for several terms in Farmington.
Pelty pitched one last game in 1937 in an exhibition against Grover Cleveland Alexander, dropping the decision.
