After graduating from high school, Anders was recruited by Louisiana State University. During his visit, he was asked by the LSU coach, Dale Brown, why he was wearing a T-shirt that said "OUTLAW." Anders replied that it was his nickname which was given to him because he was always creating disturbances, a response that effectively ended the recruiting visit. Subsequently, Anders accepted an offer to play for the University of Houston Cougars. Anders achieved his fame while playing for the Cougars. Despite the fact that he was mostly a role player who came off the bench, Anders had a significant impact on some of the Cougar's biggest victories, mainly due to his style of play that featured some of the NCAA's most memorable dunks. During the 1983 Final Four between Houston and Louisville, Anders executed two violent dunks, one of which occurred with Houston holding an eight-point lead with less than thirty seconds to play. The reverse dunk was characterized by his teammate Reid Gettys as one of the most "selfish plays" he had ever seen. In the championship game against North Carolina State University's "Wolfpack", Anders nearly stole the ball with seconds left in the game, but North Carolina State's Derek Whittenburg gained possession and his air ball miss was caught by teammate Lorenzo Charles who scored as time ran out, securing the victory for the Wolfpack. Anders clashed with Cougars coach Guy Lewis during the 1984 season and quit the team for several weeks before deciding to return. After his return, he was relegated to the bench but once again made the trip to the Final Four where the Cougars appeared in the semi-finals against the University of Virginia and in the finals against Georgetown University. Anders played sparingly in both games and is best remembered showing up to the tournament wearing a tuxedo with a pinkbow tie, pink cummerbund, and sunglasses. His appearance caught the attention of fans, and after Kentucky's elimination, many of that team's fans showed up to the final wearing sunglasses. One of the fans held a sign that read "Benny Anders for President." After the Cougars' loss, Anders spent the night drinking with John Gambill, the Kentucky fan who had held the sign. The following week, Gambill received a package from Anders in the mail containing his uniform. The 1984 NCAA tournament marked the end of Anders's college career as a knee injury kept him from playing in the 1985 season. A subsequent on-campus weapons charge earned him three years' probation and eventual dismissal from the Cougars.
Anders was known for his stylish play and eccentric approach to both the game of basketball and life. His quote about teammate Hakeem Olajuwon remains famous to this day and is found on a number of basketball related web sites. Anders is frequently cited as an example of an athlete who failed to live up to his potential, but while in his prime left a memorable mark on the game he played.
Ask any basketball fan who remembers who Benny Anders was, and he will almost certainly say great things about his ability. He is retrospectively beloved, expressly because he failed in totality... he's an example of blown potential who makes average people feel better about themselves.
Adding to Anders's legacy was his longtime complete disappearance, from both the public and his former teammates. Anders was not in contact with the media in over 15+ years and attempts to contact him through family and friends failed. In 2016, Anders was located in Michigan and appeared in a 30 for 30 documentary about "Phi Slama Jama", Anders claimed to be enjoying his retirement.
