Formation and ''This Town's Disaster'' (2004–2006)
The band was originally formed in 2004, soon after Jim Suptic had finished recording Guilt Show with The Get Up Kids. There was a good deal of tension within the band, and Jim had written several songs that he felt didn't fit The Get Up Kids. After the band decided to break up in 2005, Blackpool Lights became his primary focus. The band released a self-titled, self-published five-song EP in 2005. Suptic soon co-founded Curb Appeal Records in early 2006 with other local entrepreneurs and musicians including Alex Brahl. Alex had produced Something to Write Home About, the album that gave The Get Up Kids much of their success. On June 20, 2006 Blackpool Lights' debut album This Town's Disaster was released, becoming the first release for the label. The day of the release, Spin Magazine named the band the "Artist of the Day". The band went on to support Social Distortion and Supersuckers on various tours in fall 2006.
Breakup (2007–2010)
In September 2007, the band announced that Chris Clark had been added as lead guitarist and that drummer Billy Brimblecom had decided to leave the band. Both Billy and Brian are former members of the Kansas City band The Creature Comforts. Billy left the band on good terms, though no explanation for his departure was given. Jerad Meadows filled in on the drums for the band's tour with The Forecast. In 2007, their song "Ain't Nobody Gonna Stop Us Now" was chosen as the official anthem for the Kansas City Wizards of Major League Soccer. Sometime in 2008 the band quietly disbanded. The last update on their MySpace was in late 2007 and their official website domain expired on December 21, 2008. Around the same time, Curb Appeal Records was also shut down, although the exact reasons are unknown. In 2009, Suptic's priorities turned to the re-united Get Up Kids, who recorded an EP entitled Simple Science before embarking on a world tour in 2010.
In May 2010, the band announced via Twitter that they had re-united, and are currently in the studio recording their second album. On November 30, 2010 they released Okie Baroque on Legion of Boom records. The song "The truth about love" was featured on the episode "The Trip" from the first season of the Netflix original show Girlboss.