It was founded by Hugh de Ferrers before 1153. It was dedicated to St Mary the Virgin,. The house was built close to the River Gwash which gave the parish its name. It was only a small priory, and only intended to support three canons. The priory struggled financially, and had a rapid succession of priors who felt unable to deal with the priory's poverty. Many saw being sent to Brooke as something of a punishment. In 1298 the Bishop of Lincoln wrote to the Prior of Kenilworth urging him to take action about Brooke. The priory had become "so dilapidated and decayed that it was a scandal to the neighbourhood, and the revenues were so mismanaged that if something was not done soon the canons and their servants would have to beg their bread". The final prior, Roger Harwell, was in a dispute with his superiors at Kenilworth. He tried to get himself a large pension for his retirement but the Abbot of Kenilworth felt unable to provide it. When, in 1535, King Henry VIII began his Dissolution of the Monasteries, Prior Harwell lied to the royal commissioners and told them Brooke Priory was independent. He then surrendered the priory for dissolution of his own accord, securing himself in the process an annual pension of £10. At dissolution the priory was described as "for the most ruinous", and is recorded as having a small annual income of £46 18s. 9½d. Prior Harwell's actions caused problems for the Abbot of Kenilworth who, on receipt of a 1,000 mark bond, had promised to lease Brooke to a friend of Thomas Cromwell. The abbot wrote to Cromwell, begging him to either return Brooke or release him from the bond. Brooke was never returned, and the following year, it was granted to Anthony Cope. After the dissolution the name Brooke survived as a parish name. The priory's land was sold in 1549 to Andrew Noel who built Brooke House, of which only the dovecote and octagon lodge now survives. From a Derby merchant family, Noel used this estate to climb to power. Within 5 years he was sitting in Parliament. The family went on to become Earls of Gainsborough. No trace of the buildings survive, but there are earthworks and crop marks associated with fishpools or outbuildings. Some of these may date from the English Civil War or the formal gardens of the succeeding Brooke House, itself now gone. Some fragments of the original buildings are thought to have been used in the present sixteenth century house, called "Brooke Priory".
The Brooke Reliquary is a small casket that dates from the 13th Century. It originates from the workshops in Limoges, France and is believed to have held a saint's relics. The reliquary was discovered in c.1805, after years of being concealed on the site of Brooke Priory, when building work was carried out in the cellar of Priory House. The reliquary is decorated with Limoges enamelwork inshades of blue, red, yellow and green with images of Christ with two apostles or saints. The robes on the saints are engraved on copper plates which were originally gilded, but this has worn away. It is now on display in Rutland County Museum in Oakham.
Priors of Brooke
Ralf, occurs 1180
Richard of Lichfield, presented 1230, died 1243
John of Wotton, presented 1243
Robert of Ledbury, presented 1251, resigned 1285
Nicholas of Breedon, presented 1285, resigned 1294
Richard de Bremesgrave, presented 1294, resigned 1299
Richard of Ketton, presented 1299, resigned 1300
John de Flore, presented 1300, resigned 1302
Stephen of Ketton, presented 1302
Richard of Ketton, presented 1305
Robert of Pershore, presented 1310
Henry Waleys, presented 1346
Richard of Oxenden, presented 1362, resigned 1366
Ralf of Towcester, presented 1366, resigned 1375
Thomas de Farncote, presented 1375
Robert of Leicester, presented 1379, resigned 1385
Thomas Kidderminster, presented 1385, resigned 1388
James of Coleshill, presented 1388
Thomas Campden, presented 1400
Richard Charlton, presented 1400, died 1403
John Wyche, presented 1403, resigned 1407
John Streche, presented 1407, resigned 1425
William Shrewsbury, presented 1425
Thomas Blakewell, resigned 1433
Thomas Layton, presented 1433, died 1453
Thomas Brayles, presented 1453, resigned 1459
Richard Marston, presented 1459, died 1487
William Unwyn, presented 1487, resigned 1519
John Penketh, presented 1519, resigned 1525
Richard Rogers, presented 1525, resigned 1531
Robert Orwell, presented 1531, died 1534
Roger Harwell, last prior, presented 1534
The brevity of most of these appointments may be explained by remarks of John Streetche, who wrote that being sent to the small impoverished house was something of a punishment.