By 1867 there was a wide British community living in Buenos Aires. Most of them had established there coming from the United Kingdom as managers and workers of the British-owned railway lines that operated in Argentina. British citizens founded social and sports clubs where they could practise their sports, such as bowls, cricket, football, golf, horse riding, rugby union and tennis amongst others. The "Buenos Aires Football Club" was founded on Thursday 9 May 1867 in Temple street, known today as Viamonte, in the city of Buenos Aires. The founding members were railway workers who all came from northern England, specially brothers Thomas and James Hogg. The founding committee was formed by: Thomas Hogg, 24 years old, born in Skelton, York, Yorkshire; his brother James Hogg, 26 years old, born in Skelton, York, Yorkshire; Thomas Jackson, 29 years old, born in Cumberland; Thomas Barlow Smith, 21 years old, born in Stoney Middleton, Derbyshire; and Walter Heald, secretary, 29 years old, born in Pendle, Lancashire. Likewise, the rules of the club were as follows:
The club be called "The Buenos Aires Football Club".
The committee of four be elected to manage the affairs of the Club.
The subscription for the present season be $ 30 currency.
The first match had to take place on 25 May 1867 and was advertised in the English language daily newspaper The Standard, published in Argentina: Due to poor weather conditions, the game was cancelled, being postponed for June 20, when finally the first match in Argentine football history was contested. The venue was the Buenos Aires Cricket Club Ground. Both teams were formed by members of the BACC. Thomas Hogg and Walter Heald were the captains of the teams, named "Rojos" and "Blancos" respectively. Teams names referred to the color of the hats that both teams use to distinguish each other. Rojoes defeated Blancos by 4–0. On August 9, the Buenos Aires Football Club was officially established. It is recorded that in 1868 two matches were also played. In one of them, the Rojos defeated Whites by 2–1. In 1870 the club was dissolved due to the yellow fever epidemic that killed about 8% of the inhabitants of Buenos Aires. On April 25, 1873, the club was re-established under the same name and presided by Thomas Hogg as he had done with its predecessor. On June that year the BAFC played its first match since its second foundation. The game was held in the Buenos Aires Cricket Club Ground where "Banks" and "Town" played with a mix of football association and rugby union rules. Despite following the football association rules, most of the members preferred to follow the rugby union rules, using the hands instead of their feet. That was because those members came from different cities of England, where football in each was played in a different way, often using the hands instead feet, or both. Therefore the members of BAFC played the game as they did in the towns of their birth, being a mix of football and rugby with no defined rules. As a consequence, on 13 May 1874 the club called its members to discuss the point "4" of its rules. On Thursday, 14 May 1874, the members met to discuss which rules they should follow. After the debate they finally decided to adopt the laws of rugby union. That same day the first game under the rugby rules was played at David Mathven's country house, in Caballito, Buenos Aires. The teams were called "Equipo de Mr. Trench" and "Equipo de Mr. Hogg". This is considered the first rugby union match ever played in Argentina. Although some historians say the club was dissolved in 1875, the club continued its activities during that year, even adopting the football association rules again, because of the serious injuries caused during the matches previously contested. In 1876 the football association rules were kept but carrying the ball with hands was allowed. On May 7, 1876, the club returned to rugby union code. The last reported matches of the BAFC were in 1881, when the team played friendly rugby matches against Zingari Cricket Club and Montevideo Cricket Club.
