The mall was in planning as early as 1972, when the Logan City Commission refused to rezone land for the mall, leading to the developers bringing a lawsuit against the commission. Plans re-emerged in 1974, with developers John Price Associates announcing it as a 300,000 square foot mall to include 3 department store anchors, a supermarket, a bank, and "dozens" of small businesses, with an opening date sometime in 1976. Construction had begun by 1975, with anchors JCPenney, ZCMI, and Ernst-Malmo announced at this time. An opening of late July 1976 was announced by February that year, with additional tenants including Logan Savings and Loan, Karmelkorn, Kinney Shoes, and J.B.'s Big Boy. A 14-year-old girl was shot in the chest on the mall property on July 19, 1976, before recovering. The Ernst Home Center opened for business before the mall on July 20, 1976. The mall proper opened on July 29, 1976, with anchors Ernst Home Center, ZCMI, and JCPenney along with a supermarket, a drug store, a First Security Bank, and an outparcel 3-screen Mann Theatre. In 1988, the Bon Marcheat the mall was bought by and converted to Lamonts. The Cache Valley 3 Theatre was converted to a Carmike Cinemas in 1995. ZCMI was sold to The May Department Stores Companyin 1999, with the store at the mall being sold to Dillard'sin 2001. Lamonts closed in 2000, and later became a Dillard's Home Store. The Cache Valley 3 Theatre was converted to its final operator, Westates Theatres, in February 2002, before closing on October 18th, 2007. In January 2013 it was announced that both Dillard's locations would close, citing under-performance. Herberger's opened at the mall in early 2014, their first location in Utah, in the former Dillard's space. C-A-L Ranch opened at the mall in the former Dillard's Home Store space in 2015. The mall was sold from Rouse Properties to Namdar Realty Group in December 2017. Herberger's closed at the mall in 2018, in a round of 42 store closures prior to bankruptcy later that year. In 2019, the former Cache Valley Mall 3 Theatres building underwent heavy renovations to become two restaurants and an event center, with a projected opening date of Spring 2020.. On June 4, 2020, JCPenney announced that it would be closing in October 2020 as part of a plan to close 154 stores nationwide which will leave C-A-L Ranch as the only anchor left.
