Casualty recording
Casualty recording is the systematic and continuous process of documenting individual direct deaths from armed conflict or violence. It aims to create a comprehensive account of all deaths within a determined scope, usually bound by time and location. At minimum, casualty recording typically involves documenting the date and location of a violent incident; the number of people killed; the means of violence or category of weapon used; and the party responsible. Casualty recording differs from casualty tracking, which is conducted exclusively by military actors to track the effects of their operations on the civilian population for the purpose of improving their procedures and mitigating their effects.
A defining feature of casualty recording is that it is victim-centric and seeks to establish the identity of every fatality including name, age, sex, and other relevant demographic details. Where relevant to the conflict context, this may also include ethnicity and religious or political affiliation. However, depending on the aims and resources of the organisation conducting the recording, a particular initiative may record only a specific subset of deaths. Subsets may include, for example, deaths caused by a specific belligerent or weapons type, or deaths of a particular segment of the population, such as children.
Casualty recording focuses on documenting direct deaths from armed violence. It does not normally include deaths caused by the indirect or reverberating effects of conflict. Some casualty recording initiatives document injuries as well as deaths. Casualty records may overlap with, or operate in conjunction with, records of persons who have gone missing during a conflict or period of violence.
Aims and uses
Practitioners have different aims and motivations for conducting casualty recording. Typically these are grounded in considerations relating to international humanitarian law or human rights law. Casualty records have also been used to support some humanitarian disarmament initiatives.The purported aims of casualty records include:
- Recognising the dignity and rights of victims and their families, including the right to life and the right to the truth. This work often overlaps with efforts to trace missing people in situations of armed conflict.
- Supporting accountability and peace building processes including memorialisation, transitional justice and criminal prosecutions for war crimes or crimes against humanity. These activities can play an important role in reducing cycles of violence and promoting community reconciliation.
- Supporting the protection of civilians by providing information to reduce unintended consequences of military activities and improve humanitarian response planning.
- Informing media reporting and policy makers on conflict dynamics.
- Informing, monitoring and improving protection measures aimed at specific populations affected by armed violence including children, women, persons with disabilities, journalists, health workers and older persons.
- Enabling victims' families to receive reparation, compensation and access to services, as well as inheritance rights.
- Identifying the unintended and unacceptable harm to civilians caused by the use of certain weapons. Casualty data on anti-personnel landmines and cluster munitions helped drive international efforts to ban these weapons, and information on the effects of explosive weapons in populated areas is informing efforts to curb their use.
History
The twenty-first century practice of monitoring and publishing detailed online information on the human casualties of armed conflicts is sometimes associated with the Iraq Body Count project that started monitoring Iraqi deaths in the 2003 invasion of Iraq. The Iraq Body Count estimates, the 2004 and 2006 Lancet surveys of Iraq War casualties and the ORB survey of Iraq War casualties led to several years of academic debate over the accuracy of the various surveys of the total casualties of the Iraq War.Methodology and standards
Approaches to casualty recording vary depending on the context, purpose and resources of the organisation responsible. In 2016, were published by the UK-based NGO , in an effort to harmonise approaches across the field and promote best practice.The data gathered by a casualty recording project will generally be stored in an electronic or paper-based database, but there is no standard format for sharing or publishing the final results. Some casualty recorders, such as Iraq Body Count project and , make their records publicly available online and searchable. Casualty recorders have also published books of their records, such as the and . Lost Lives was subsequently reproduced as a documentary film in 2019. Casualty data may also be used to produce digital or physical memorials of those who died, as in the case of , which memorialises individuals who were killed or went missing during the conflict in South Sudan.
Practitioners
Casualty recording is frequently conducted by civil society organisations in the absence of official recording processes led by state entities. In some armed conflict situations, public services normally involved in recording deaths are no longer functioning effectively. There may also be political reasons why state authorities do not publish or share information on conflict related deaths. Some internationally mandated entities, including UN peacekeeping missions or commissions of inquiry, conduct casualty recording as part of their broader work.Examples of organisations which conduct, or have conducted, casualty recording include:
- Airwars
- Al Mezan Center for Human Rights
- B'Tselem for Israel and the Israeli-occupied territories
- , India
- Colombian Campaign Against Landmines
- Conflict Archive on the Internet, Northern Ireland
- , Somalia
- INSEC in Nepal
- Iraq Body Count project, ORB survey of Iraq War casualties, Lancet surveys of Iraq War casualties
- , Northern Ireland
- Omeria Organisation
- , World Health Organisation
- Syrian Network for Human Rights
- The Bureau of Investigative Journalism
- United Nations Assistance Mission in Afghanistan
- United Nations Assistance Mission for Iraq
- Violations Documentation Center in Syria
-
Non-conflict casualty recording
- , recording deaths of journalists worldwide
- , recording deaths of homeless people in the UK, by the Bureau of Investigative Journalism
- , recording all gun violence incidents, including deaths, in the USA.
- , tracking deaths along international migratory routes, by the International Organisation of Migration
- , recording deaths from gender based violence in Mexico