During his tenure as Third Circuit Court, Kaufman was known for leniency towards first-time offenders. In 1977, when a 17-year-old African-American male, Greg Mathis, was arrested on a concealed-weapons charge, Kaufman handed a sentence of probation, provided that Mathis enrolled and passed a GED course in six months. Mathis turned away from gang behavior, and in 1994, he went on to become the youngest judge elected to the 36th District Court in Detroit, eventually becoming a popular television personality as Judge Mathis.
Vincent Chin ruling
Kaufman is the judge who sentenced former Chrysler plant superintendent Ronald Ebens and his stepson Michael Nitz on March 16, 1983 to three years' probation and $3,780 in fines and court costs after they were convicted of manslaughter for the killing of Vincent Chin. Asian-American advocacy groups were outraged. Ebens had gone with Nitz to hunt down Chin and the only other Asian in his group of four friends and had Nitz hold Chin down as Ebens used a baseball bat to viciously beat Chin in the head. Though Ebens was still employed by Chrysler at the time of the attack, the act was a hate crime of an American autoworker taking out his frustration about the Japanese automobile industry on an innocent person. Citing the judge's POW record as one of several reasons to invalidate the lenient sentence in favor of a more stringent punishment, advocacy groups unsuccessfully tried to vacate the original sentence. Kaufman cited the defendants' clean prior criminal records and that there was no minimum sentence for a manslaughter plea as he responded, "These weren't the kind of men you send to jail... You don't make the punishment fit the crime; you make the punishment fit the criminal." Kaufman's sentence was upheld as valid and final, due to the Fifth Amendment protection against double jeopardy, and the advocacy groups shifted their efforts toward a Federal prosecution for the violation of Vincent Chin's civil rights. This would also prove ultimately unsuccessful after an appeal and retrial of Ebens' original 1984 Federal conviction resulted in acquittal. Kaufman never showed remorse for the sentences he issued in the Vincent Chin case, stating that such sentencing was something that "happens regularly in Recorder's Court and here."
Other rulings
Judge Kaufman issued a number of notable decisions jailing other individuals for committing less heinous offenses. Kaufman jailed an entire town board for failing to approve a sewer line in December 1978 and again in March 1979. Members were eventually released in 1979 after two members finally agreed to approve the sewer line. In November 1974, Judge Kaufman sentenced eleven teachers to jail after they refused to return to work. Kaufman sentenced the chief negotiator in a strike to 30 days in jail and ten other teachers to 5 days in jail. Kaufman later retired from the Third Circuit Court, and died in 2004.
