On Allmusic, Fred Thomas wrote, "These two-track soundboard recordings find Phish in one of their more playful and energetic times, rising to the height of their popularity and playing together with almost telepathic synchronicity. They were also at some of their most athletic levels of playing, with set lists full of their most frenetic tunes and most epic jams.... These shows are absolutely on fire, and a clear choice for the kind of expansive retroactive issue that warrants a six-disc box set.... he level of energy put forth over the course of Chicago '94 is undeniable, and the high points are some of the most brilliant in the band's catalog." On All About Jazz, Doug Collette said, "his six-CD set — like the similarly conceived Hampton/Winston-Salem '97 — makes its statement through the largely brilliant musicianship contained therein, with virtually no accompanying content to place it in a historical perspective. Chicago '94 evinces a continuity in the content with its sound check filler, thus fully presenting a broad view of this band's evolution at approximately ten years past its original formation." In The Maine Edge, Mike Dow wrote, "The stage offered complete freedom and an audience willing to go wherever the band felt like taking them. The two shows featured on Chicago '94, recorded on June 18 and November 25 of 1994 at the UIC Pavilion, reveal a band in peak form — completely in sync, in good humor and confident that, if one of them fell, the other three would be there to catch them. If the entire band fell, they knew the audience would forgive them.... Keith Richards once said, 'On any given night it's a different band that's the greatest rock and roll band in the world.' Chicago '94 is evidence that, for those two nights, Phish could have claimed the title."
Track listing
Disc one
"Wilson" – 5:11
"Rift" – 5:55
"AC/DC Bag" – 6:31
"Maze" – 11:22
"The Mango Song" – 7:26
"Down with Disease" – 7:15
"It's Ice" – 8:38
"Dog Faced Boy" – 2:18
"Divided Sky" – 14:34
"Sample in a Jar" – 5:13
Disc two
"Peaches en Regalia" – 4:05
"David Bowie" – 18:27
"Horn" – 4:07
"McGrupp and the Watchful Hosemasters" – 9:05
"Tweezer" – 14:15
"Lifeboy" – 8:23
Disc three
"You Enjoy Myself" – 20:58
"Chalk Dust Torture" – 7:21
"Bouncing Around the Room" – 3:39
"Tweezer Reprise" – 3:19
"All Things Reconsidered" – 3:34
"How Many More Times" – 3:51
"Poor Heart" – 2:22
Disc four
"Llama" – 5:35
"Guelah Papyrus" – 5:46
"Reba" – 14:08
"Bouncing Around the Room" – 3:40
"Split Open and Melt" – 11:15
"Esther" – 8:49
"Julius" – 7:27
"Golgi Apparatus" – 4:47
Disc five
"2001" – 4:51
"Mike's Song" – 7:23
"Simple" – 14:23
"Harpua" – 15:59
"Weekapaug Groove" – 10:31
"The Mango Song" – 7:23
"Purple Rain" – 5:43
"Hold Your Head Up" – 1:06
Disc six
"Run Like an Antelope" – 13:11
"Good Times Bad Times" – 5:55
"Chicago '94 Soundcheck Jam" – 8:23
"Dog Log" – 4:58
Personnel
Phish
Trey Anastasio – guitar, lead vocals, co-lead vocals on "Rift", narration on "Harpua", drums on "Purple Rain" and "Hold Your Head Up"