This species is relatively slender and stunted, growing to a maximum of in length. Its most distinctive feature is its lack of a rattle. The base of the tail, the "button", has degenerated to such an extent that the rattle immediately falls off with each shed instead of forming a new segment, as it does in other species of rattlesnakes. This is widely believed to be a localized adaptation for hunting birds. Of the two distinct color variations, the predominant variant has a light cream-colored base, with reddish-brown blotching down the back, and black and white banding around the tail. The other variant has a much lighter, ash gray color, with darker gray blotching. The banding around the tail is still present.
This species is classified as Critically Endangered on the IUCN Red List with the following criteria: B1ab. This means that the best available evidence indicates it is considered to be facing an extremely high risk of extinction in the wild because its geographic range is estimated to be less than 100 km2, it exists at only a single location, and a continuing decline has been observed, inferred, or projected in the number of mature individuals. It was assessed in 2007. It is threatened due to collecting and the introduction of alien predator species, such as feral cats.
While most members of this genus are almost entirely terrestrial due to their heavy body structure, this species' small size makes it a swift and skillful climber. Previous researchers hypothesized that the ability of C. catalinensis to climb, combined with its lack of a rattle allowed it to hunt roosting birds, but detailed research into the species’ diet has revealed C. catalinensis maintains a mammal-based diet like most rattlesnakes. Further inquiry into the arboreal behavior of this island species has shown individuals actually spend the majority of their time on the ground. Individuals were most likely to be found in low branches of bushes during July, the hottest month on the island. C. catalinensis is thought to climb off of the hot ground and into bushes to thermoregulate. Unlike most species of rattlesnakes, C. catalinensis is often observed exposed; it does not tend to hide. Currently, the greater evidence supports the theory that the Catalina rattleless rattlesnake has evolved away from having a rattle because it has no need for a warning mechanism against predators.
Feeding
Previous theories suggested the tendency for this rattlesnake to climb into low bushes was connected to a dietary shift toward consuming birds. However, studies conducted from 2002 to 2004 revealed that stomach and fecal contents were 70% mammal and 30% lizard species “We found no bird remains in scats or stomach contents of C. catalinensis in any year or season.”
Taxonomy
suggested this species is closely related to C. scutulatus. However, a later study by Murphy and Crabtree used allozyme data to conclude it shares its most recent ancestor with C. ruber. Most of the morphological, biogeographic, and biochemical data suggest the same.