APFC Somerset was the son of AWF Somerset, who had toured the West Indies with Lord Brackley's team six years earlier. DCF Burton and DSG Burton were cousins. AC Johnston, LHW Troughton and GJ Thompson all withdrew from the published side and only 11 players were eventually taken on the tour. The team was thought to be quite weak but performed better than expected. The three professionals were all good players although Brown and Hearne were inexperienced at this time. Sydney Smith, although a native of Trinidad, was playing county cricket and Tom Whittington was a regular for Glamorgan in the Minor Counties Championship. An inevitable constraint was that, with only 11 players touring, there were occasions when local players had to be used to complete the team.
The tour
The team left England on the RMSP Clyde on 18 January 1911. Matches played were:
Of the 11 first-class matches, 3 were won, 4 lost, 3 drawn and 1 tied. The minor match was won. Unlike previous tours there were no matches in any of the smaller islands. Starting in Barbados, the tourists lost the first two matches heavily but the match against a West Indies XI was won. The West Indies XI was without any Trinidad players because of quarantine restrictions. In British Guiana the tourists won well with some good batting by Whittington and Holloway and they then beat the West Indian side. A second match against the West Indies was organised but when Archer was dropped the two other Barbados players refused to play. The first match in Trinidad was played immediately after the tourists had got off the boat and they lost by an innings. The second match was closer although still won by Trinidad. After the long trip to Jamaica the tourists played four matches there. Rain ruined the first two matches and after a win against Port Antonio the final match ended in a tie. Sydney Smith was the leading player for the tourists being top of the bowling averages and second in the batting averages. Whittington and Holloway also batted well despite having only played one first class match between them before the tour started. Hearne was a success with the ball but Brown and Young were something of a disappointment. Despite being in his mid-50s the captain also turned out to be a useful bowler.
Averages
The following averages are in the 11 first class matches:
Batting
Player
P
I
NO
R
HS
Ave
100
50
C/S
TAL Whittington
11
20
2
678
154
37.66
2
2
8
SG Smith
11
21
3
547
81
30.38
–
5
7
L Heath
1
2
1
27
15
27.00
–
–
2
BH Holloway
10
17
0
416
100
24.47
1
2
9
ELGN Grell
1
2
0
42
25
21.00
–
–
1
DCF Burton
10
17
0
334
57
19.64
–
2
3
JW Hearne
11
21
2
344
56
18.10
–
2
13
AWF Somerset
11
17
5
214
60
17.83
–
1
10/2
G Brown
11
21
1
298
35
14.90
–
–
10/3
HPL Gaussen
10
18
0
260
77
14.44
–
1
–
CO Simpson
1
2
0
27
27
13.50
–
–
1
HI Young
11
19
2
225
73
13.23
–
1
5
DSG Burton
10
17
5
138
38*
11.50
–
–
2
GBM Liddlelow
1
2
0
18
13
9.00
–
–
–
APFC Somerset
11
19
5
120
33
8.57
–
–
6
Grell, Heath, Liddlelow and Simpson were local players.
