| 2017 Award Winners | - | - |
| Football Awards | Baseball Awards | Other Awards |
| Writer of the Year - Gary Davenport, Fantasy Sharks | Writer of the Year - Todd Zola, Mastersball | Humor Article of the Year - Sammie Reid, Rotogrinders |
| Best Article on the Web - Jeff Ratcliffe, Pro Football Focus | Best Article on the Net - Jim Sannes, numberFire | Racing Writer of the Year - Mark Taylor, Rotowire |
| Best Article in Print - Jamey Eisenberg, CBS | Best Article in Print - Tim McCullough, FantasyPros | Golf Writer of the Year - Adam Daly-Frey, Fantasy Golf Insider |
| Best On-Going Series - Tyler Loechner, Pro Football Focus | Best On-Going Series - Scott Engel, RotoExperts | Basketball Writer of the Year - Benny Ricciardi, GuruElite |
| Best Publication - Football Diehards | Best Publication - RotoWire | College Writer of the Year - Brad Evans, Yahoo |
| Podcast of the Year - The Fantasy Footballers | Podcast of the Year - USA Today | Podcast of the Year - Rotowire |
| | Hockey Writer of the Year - Doug Shain, Bankster DFS |
| | Soccer Writer of the Year - Andrew Laird, RotoWire |
| | Newcomer of the Year - James McCool, DraftKings |
| | Video of the Year - Yahoo Fantasy Football Live |
| | Radio Show of the Year - Pro Football Focus - Jeff Ratcliffe |
| 2016 Award Winners | - | - |
| Football Awards | Baseball Awards | Other Awards |
| Writer of the Year - Jeff Zimmerman, Rotowire | Writer of the Year - Ray Murphy, Baseball HQ | Humor Article of the Year - Chris Mitchell, RotoExperts |
| Best Article on the Net - Drew Loftis, New York Post | Best Article on the Net - Michael Rathburn, Rotowire | Racing Writer of the Year - Mark Taylor, Rotowire |
| Best Article in Print - Jeff Zimmerman, Rotowire | Best Article in Print - Rob Leibowitz, RotoHeaven | Golf Writer of the Year - Michael Riek, Rotowire |
| Best Series - Brandon Murchison, RotoExperts | Best Series - Ray Flowers, Fantasy Alarm | Basketball Writer of the Year - Ryan Knaus, Rotoworld |
| Best Publication - Football Diehards | Best Publication - Rotoworld | College Writer of the Year - John McKechnie, Rotowire |
| Podcast of the Year - Draft Sharks | Podcast of the Year - USA Today | Podcast of the Year - Rotowire |
| | Hockey Writer of the Year - James Capone, Scout |
| | Newcomer of the Year - Juan Carlos Blanco, Rotowire |
| | Video of the Year - Yahoo Fantasy Football Live |
| | Radio Show of the Year - Pro Football Focus - Jeff Ratcliffe |
| 2015 Award Winners | - | - |
| Football Awards | Baseball Awards | Other Awards |
| Writer of the Year - Brad Evans, Yahoo | Writer of the Year - Mike Podhorzer, Fangraphs | Humor Article of the Year - Chris Liss, Rotowire |
| Best Article on the Net - JJ Zachariason, Numberfire | Best Article on the Net - Ryan Bloomfield, Baseball HQ | Racing Writer of the Year - CJ Radune, Rotowire |
| Best Article in Print - Gary Davenport, Fantasy Sharks | Best Article in Print - Dave Regan, Rotowire | Golf Writer of the Year - Jeff Bergerson, Fantasy Golf Insider |
| Best Series - Robert McMann, RotoExperts | Best Series - Logan Hitchcock, Daily Roto | Basketball Writer of the Year - Ryan Knaus, Rotoworld |
| Best Publication - USA Today Sports: Fantasy Football | Best Publication - Ron Shandler's Baseball Forecaster | College Writer of the Year - Christopher Feery, Footballguys |
| | Hockey Writer of the Year - Andrew Fiorentino, Rotowire |
| | Newcomer of the Year - Alex Chamberlain, Fangraphs |
| | Video of the Year - Pat Mayo, FNTSY |
| | Podcast of the Year - Christopher Harris, HarrisFootball |
| | Radio Show of the Year - Jeff Mans and Tommy G on SiriusXM |
| 2014 Award Winners | - | - |
| Football Awards | Baseball Awards | Other Awards |
| Writer of the Year - Steve Schwarz, The Sports Network | Writer of the Year - Michael Rathburn, Rotowire | Humor Article of the Year - Ken Crites, Rotowire |
| Best Article on the Net - Walter Collazo, Fantasy Sharks | Best Article on the Net - Benny Ricciardi, DFS Report | Racing Writer of the Year - Eric McClung, FF Toolbox |
| Best Article in Print - Matt Lutovsky, Sporting News | Best Article in Print - Steve Gardner, USA Today | Golf Writer of the Year - Gibb Pollard, RotoGrinders |
| Best Series - Evan Silva, Rotoworld | Best Series - Jeff Zimmerman, FanGraphs | Basketball Writer of the Year - Aaron Bruski, Rotoworld |
| Best Publication - USA Today Sports: Fantasy Football 2014 | Best Publication - USA Today Sports: Fantasy Baseball 2014 | College Writer of the Year - Brad Evans, Yahoo! |
| | Hockey Writer of the Year - Jesse Pantuosco, The Sports Network |
| | Newcomer of the Year - Dan Ciarrocchi, SB Nation |
| | Video of the Year - Yahoo Fantasy Football Live |
| | Podcast of the Year - Dan Back, RotoGrinders Daily Fantasy Fix |
| | Radio Show of the Year - RotoExperts on SiriusXM |
| 2013 Award Winners | - | - |
| Football Awards | Baseball Awards | Other Awards |
| Writer of the Year - Dave Richard, CBS | Writer of the Year - Jason Collette, Rotowire | Humor Article of the Year - Thomas McFeeley, RotoExperts |
| Best Article on the Net - Mike Clay, Pro Football Focus | Best Article on the Net - Todd Zola, ESPN | Racing Writer of the Year - Daniel Dobish, RotoExperts |
| Best Article in Print - Alessandro Miglio, Pro Football Focus | Best Article in Print - David Martin, Baseball HQ | Golf Writer of the Year - Greg Vara, Rotowire |
| Best Series - Salvatore Stefanile, XN Sports | Best Series - Erik Siegrist, Rotowire | Basketball Writer of the Year - Jesse Pantuosco, The Sports Network |
| Best Publication - Fantasy Football ProForecast | Best Publication - Rotoworld | College Writer of the Year - Brad Evans, Yahoo! |
| | Hockey Writer of the Year - Jesse Pantuosco, The Sports Network |
| | Newcomer of the Year - Pat Thorman, Pro Football Focus |
| | Video of the Year - CBS, Fantasy Baseball Today, Adam Aizer, Scott White, Nando Di Fino and Al Melchior |
| | Podcast of the Year - Patrick Davitt, Baseball HQ Radio |
| | Radio Show of the Year - Rotowire Fantasy Sports Today, Jeff Erickson, Chris Liss, Derek VanRiper, Andrew Martinez and Jason Thornbury |
| 2012 Award Winners | - | - |
| Football Awards | Baseball Awards | Other Awards |
| Writer of the Year - Brad Evans, Yahoo! Sports | Writer of the Year - Alex Beckey, Baseball HQ | Humor Article of the Year - Matt Lutovsky, The Sporting News |
| Best Article on the Net - Alessandro Miglio, Pro Football Focus | Best Article on the Net - Jack Moore, RotoWire | Racing Writer of the Year - C.J. Radune, RotoWire |
| Best Article in Print - Allie Fontana, Football Diehards | Best Article in Print - Matt Lutovsky | Golf Writer of the Year - Daniel Dobish, RotoExperts |
| Best Series - Patrick Mayo, RotoExperts | Best Series - Patrick DiCaprio, USA Today | Basketball Writer of the Year - Brian McKitish, ESPN |
| Best Publication - Sports Illustrated | Best Publication - The Sporting News | College Writer of the Year - Jesse Siegel, RotoWire |
| | Hockey Writer of the Year - Janet Eagleson, RotoWire |
| | Newcomer of the Year - Scott Spratt, Pro Football Focus |
| 2011 Award Winners | - | - |
| Football Awards | Baseball Awards | Other Awards |
| Writer of the Year - Ladd Biro | Writer of the Year - Chris Ryan, RotoExperts | Humor Article of the Year - Ladd Biro |
| Best Article on the Net - Jeff Paur, RealTime | Best Article on the Net - Tristan Cockcroft, ESPN | Racing Writer of the Year - Daniel Dobish, RotoExperts |
| Best Article in Print - Jeff Stotts, RotoWire | Best Article in Print - David Regan, RotoWire | Golf Writer of the Year - Daniel Dobish, RotoExperts |
| Best Series - Adam Levitan, Rotoworld | Best Series - Ray Flowers, Baseball Guys/RotoWire | Basketball Writer of the Year - Carson Cistulli, RotoWire |
| Best Publication - Sports Illustrated | Best Publication - The Sporting News | College Writer of the Year - Brad Evans, Yahoo! Sports |
| | Hockey Writer of the Year - Mark McLarney, RotoWire |
| | Newcomer of the Year - Mark Bloom, RotoExperts |
| 2010 Award Winners | - | - |
| Football Awards | Baseball Awards | Other Awards |
| Writer of the Year - Ladd Biro | Writer of the Year - David Regan, RotoWire | Humor Article of the Year - Chris Ryan, RotoExperts |
| Best Article on the Net - Tim McCullough | Best Article on the Net - Derek VanRiper, RotoWire | Racing Writer of the Year - Mark Taylor, RotoWire |
| Best Article in Print - Cory Bonini, KFFL | Best Article in Print - Chris Liss, RotoWire | Golf Writer of the Year - John McNamara, RotoWire |
| Best Series - Ryan Bonini, KFFL | Best Series - David Regan, RotoWire | Basketball Writer of the Year - Brian McKitish, ESPN |
| Best Publication - Football CheatSheets | Best Publication - The Sporting News | College Writer of the Year - Brad Evans, Yahoo! Sports |
| | Hockey Writer of the Year - Janet Eagleson |
| | Newcomer of the Year - Lane Rizzardini |
| 2009 Award Winners | - | - |
| Football Awards | Baseball Awards | Other Awards |
| Writer of the Year - Ryan Bonini, KFFL | Writer of the Year - Scott White, CBSSports.com | Humor Article of the Year - Mike Gilbert, RotoExperts |
| Best Article on the Net - Derek VanRiper, RotoWire | Best Article on the Net - David Regan, RotoWire | Racing Writer of the Year - Mark Taylor, RotoWire |
| Best Article in Print - Ted Carlson, Fanball | Best Article in Print - Brent Hershey, USA Today Sports Weekly | Golf Writer of the Year - Scott Pianowski, Yahoo! Sports |
| Best Series - Adam Levitan, Rotoworld | Best Series - David Regan, RotoWire | Basketball Writer of the Year - Andre Snellings, RotoWire |
| Best Publication - Pro Football Weekly / Yahoo! Sports | Best Publication - RotoWire | College Writer of the Year - Brad Evans, Yahoo! Sports |
| | Hockey Writer of the Year - Sean Allen, ESPN |
| 2008 Award Winners | - | - |
| Football Awards | Baseball Awards | Other Awards |
| Writer of the Year - Jay Clemons, Sports Illustrated | Writer of the Year - Jeff Erickson, RotoWire | Humor Article of the Year - Jeremy Fisher, Fantasy Football Trader |
| Best Article on the Net - Chris Liss, RotoWire | Best Article on the Net - Eno Sarris, Baseball Guys | Racing Writer of the Year - Mark Taylor, RotoWire |
| Best Article in Print - Dan Grogan, Athlon | Best Article in Print - Andy Behrens, Yahoo | Golf Writer of the Year - John McNamara, RotoWire |
| Best Major Media Article - Dave Richard, CBS Sports | Best Major Media Article - Matt Lutovsky, Sporting News | Hockey Writer of the Year - Sean Allen, ESPN |
| Best Series - George Winkler, Sporting News | Best Series - Scott White, CBS Sports | Basketball Writer of the Year - Sergio Gonzalez, CBS Sports |
| Best Publication - Rotoworld | Best Publication - RotoWire | College Writer of the Year - Adam Mankuta, RotoWire |
| 2007 Award Winners | - | - |
| Football Awards | Baseball Awards | Other Awards |
| Writer of the Year - Gregg Rosenthal | Writer of the Year - Jeff Erickson | Humor Article of the Year - John Paulson |
| Best Article on the Net - Jason Powell | Best Article on the Net - Peter Becker | Racing Writer of the Year - Christopher Harris |
| Best Article in Print - Joe Levit | Best Article in Print - Will Carroll | Golf Writer of the Year - Ross Devonport |
| Best Major Media Article - Vinny Iyer | Best Major Media Article - Christopher Harris | Hockey Writer of the Year - Janet Eagleson |
| Best Series - John Rakowski | Best Series - Eric Karabell | Basketball Writer of the Year - Andre' Snellings |
| Best Publication - RotoWire | Best Publication - RotoWire | - |
| 2006 Award Winners | - | - |
| Football Awards | Baseball Awards | Other Awards |
| Writer of the Year - Scott Engel | Writer of the Year - Brendan Roberts | Racing Writer of the Year - Christopher Harris |
| Best Article on the Net - Matthew Berry | Best Article on the Net - Peter Schoenke | Golf Writer of the Year - Scott Coombs |
| Best Article in Print - Kirk Bouyelas | Best Article in Print - William Carroll | Hockey Writer of the Year - Janet Eagleson |
| Most Humorous Article - Garett Matheny | Most Humorous Article - Matthew Berry | Basketball Writer of the Year - Matthew Berry |
| Best Major Media Article - Christopher Harris | Best Major Media Article - Matthew Berry | - |
| Best Series - John Georgopoulos | Best Series - Brendan Roberts | - |
| 2005 Award Winners | - | - |
| Football Awards | Baseball Awards | Other Awards |
| Writer of the Year - Eric Karabell | Writer of the Year - Trace Wood | Racing Writer of the Year - Christopher Harris |
| Best Article on the Net - Lenny Pappano | Best Article on the Net - Brian McKitish | Golf Writer of the Year - Greg Vara |
| Best Article in Print - Micheal Fabiano | Best Article in Print - William Carroll | - |
| Most Humorous Article - John Nemo | Most Humorous Article - Matthew Berry | - |
| Best Major Media Article - Ken Daube | Best Magazine Advertising Campaign - RotoWire | - |
| Best Series - Michael Fabiano | - | - |
| All-Time Most Wins - Individual | - |
| Wins | Writer |
| 9 | Brad Evans |
| 6 | Christopher Harris, David Regan |
| 5 | Matthew Berry, Mark Taylor |
| 4 | Daniel Dobish, Janet Eagleson, Matt Lutovsky, Chris Liss |
| 3 | Will Carroll, Brian McKitish, Ladd Biro, Jesse Pantuosco, Derek VanRiper, Jeff Erickson, Jeff Zimmerman, Jeff Ratcliffe |
| All-Time Most Nominations - Individual | - |
| Nominations | Writer |
| 15 | Brad Evans |
| 14 | David Regan |
| 13 | Chris Liss, Chris Harris |
| 11 | Tristan Cockcroft, Patrick Mayo |
| 9 | Matthew Berry, Andy Behrens, John Georgopoulos, Ladd Biro, Daniel Dobish, Scott Engel |
| 8 | Heather Cocks, Matt Lutovsky, Jeff Erickson, Mark Taylor |
| 7 | Janet Eagleson, Alessandro Miglio, Jeff Zimmerman, Jeff Ratcliffe, Derek Van Riper, Scott Pianowski |
| 6 | Ray Flowers, Scott White, Greg Vara, Mike Rathburn, JJ Zachariason |
