Great refusal


The great refusal is the error attributed by Dante to one of the souls he found trapped aimlessly at the Vestibule of Hell. Though occasionally taken as referring to Esau, the phrase is normally related to Pope Celestine V, and to his laying down of the papacy on the grounds of age.

Dante

Behind Dante’s adverse judgement of Celestine stood the Thomist concept of recusatio tensionis, the unworthy refusal of a task within one’s natural powers. Petrarch, however, disagreed with Dante’s appraisal, seeing virtue in Celestine’s adoption instead of the contemplative life, an early modern instance of the tension between action and contemplation—the vita activa and the vita contemplativa.

Later elaborations