The mall's original anchors included JCPenney, Bergner's, and Carson Pirie Scott, all of which relocated from downtown Decatur. Kohl's was added in 1983 as a fourth anchor, and expanded in 2003. Carson Pirie Scott sold its store and another at College Hills Mall in Normal to Von Maur in 1989. MC Sports and Sears were added in 1998, with the latter relocating from a store in downtown Decatur. A year later, Gap Inc. announced plans to open Gap, GapKids, and Old Navy stores. In 2000, mall owners Copaken, White & Blitt renovated the interior. CBL & Associates Properties bought the mall in 2005. Steve & Barry's opened in late 2007, and closed less than a year later. MC Sports moved its store across the hallway in late 2008. Old Navy closed in 2010 and was re-tenanted by Cohn Furntiure later that same year. Shoe Show opened a Shoe Dept. Encore in the space vacated by Steve & Barry's. Some scenes from the 2009 filmThe Informant! were filmed at the mall. In January 2014, it was announced that JCPenney would be closing its store by May 2014, followed by Sears in November. In September 2014 the mall opened Ross Dress for Less and Ulta Beauty. In October 2014, CBL Properties announced that Hobby Lobby had executed a lease for 60,000 square feet in the space formerly occupied by JCPenney and that it would relocate into the mall from its former location on Pershing Street. The mall announced on October 21, 2016 that T.J. Maxx would be relocating to this mall. Hibbett Sports opened a store in the fall of 2017. Knockerball MAX, an affiliate of Knockerball USA, opened in October 2017. Knockerball MAX offers open play and private parties for Bubbleball in the United States, which is a recent growing trend nationwide. Taking over the spot previously held by the former Kirlin's Hallmark, Knockerball MAX boasts the largest arena of its kind in America. Wisconsin-based Book World closed its doors in 2017 after filing for bankruptcy and liquidating all stock. Its previous tenant was Waldenbooks. The company had 20 stores in Wisconsin and also had stores in Minnesota, Michigan, Missouri, Illinois, Iowa and North Dakota. On August 29, 2018 anchor tenant Bergner's permanently closed its doors after 40 years of business at Hickory Point. Bergner's parent companyBon-Ton Stores filed for bankruptcy and closed all Bon-Ton Stores including Bergner's and Carson's.
