Spoon holds a background in wrestling. He and his identical twin brother, Jerod Spoon, both competed in college, having started in seventh grade. In their junior year, Jeremy was state champion at 130lbs, whilst Jerod was runner-up at 135lbs. Spoon was undefeated prior to joining Bellator. In that time, Spoon claimed a win over Jose Vega, a featherweight championship victory in the Bricktown Brawl promotion and also defeated Donald Sanchez for the King ofthe Cage bantamweight championship. In mid-2011, both Jeremy Spoon and Jerod Spoon tried out for The Ultimate Fighter 14, which was the first edition of the show to feature bantamweights and featherweights. They tried out with the hope of being the first siblings to compete on the show, though coincidentally, whilst the Spoon siblings were not selected, two other siblings were.
Bellator Fighting Championships
Spoon made his Bellator Fighting Championships debut against the then-unbeaten Jerrod Sanders. He was victorious via submission in the second round. Spoon returned to Bellator where he faced Adam Schindler. Spoon used his speed to his advantage, as he was able to land strikes on Schindler without response. In the final round, Schindler's face was bloodied, although the fight ultimately went to decision, where Spoon prevailed. With that win, Spoon was selected to be part of. His quarterfinal opponent was Daniel Mason-Straus. Straus was considered the favourite going into the fight, due to his previous Bellator tournament experience, where he was the runner up of the fourth season featherweight tournament. During the fight, Spoon appeared to be noticeably smaller in stature than his opponent and it showed, as Straus was able to control the clinch and use his greater reach effectively with leg kicks to keep Spoon on the outside. Straus successfully took Spoon down twice and controlled the fight to a decision. Straus won the fight via unanimous decision. Spoon then entered into the. His quarterfinal opponent was Mike Richman and he lost via a headkick KO in the first round. Spoon returned to the promotion in 2018 and faced Juan Archuleta on November 30, 2018 at Bellator 210. He lost the fight by unanimous decision.
