Born in South Shields, Tyne and Wear, McReady joined Darlington's youth system as a 10-year-old. He was first involved in the first-team squad in the 2008–09 season. The following year he spent time on loan at Northern League Division One club Billingham Town, recording an assist on his debut against Esh Winning in January 2010. On his return to Darlington, McReady was named more frequently among the first-team substitutes, and he made his debut at the age of 17 on 24 April 2010 as a half-time substitute, as Darlington lost 2–0 at home to Grimsby Town in League Two. He became the 53rd player to be used by Darlington in 2009–10. McReady made four appearances as Darlington were relegated to the Conference Premier at the end of the season, and in May 2010 he signed a one-year professional contract with the club. McReady scored his first goal for Darlington on 25 September 2010, with a 93rd-minute winner in a 1–0 home victory over Southport. He joined Whitby Town of the Northern Premier League Premier Division on a one-month loan in November 2010 and debuted in a 2–2 draw with Burscough on 13 November. Despite the loan being extended for the rest of the season, he was recalled by Darlington in February 2011 after making nine appearances for Whitby. McReady was not part of the matchday squad for the club's 2011 FA Trophy victory. He finished 2010–11 with one goal in 15 appearances and signed a new two-year contract with the club in May 2011. When the club suffered financial difficulties, McReady's contract was terminated on 16 January 2012, along with those of the rest of the playing squad and caretaker managerCraig Liddle, though the club retained their registrations so they were eligible to play on a non-contract basis. He established himself as a first-team regular in 2011–12, making 38 appearances and scoring two goals. McReady stated he intended to remain at Darlington despite the club's relegation from the Conference Premier at the end of the season, but was expected to depart following their demotion to the Northern League.
York City
McReady signed a two-year contract with newly promoted League Two club York City on 29 June 2012. The club had tried to sign him in the January transfer window. York paid Darlington a small fee to sign him, with discussions being protracted as a result of Darlington's financial problems. After missing York's opening match of 2012–13 against Doncaster Rovers in the League Cup with glandular fever, McReady made his debut as a 69th-minute substitute in a 3–1 defeat at home to Wycombe Wanderers on 18 August 2012, which was the club's first Football League fixture since their promotion. He dislocated his shoulder after entering York's 0–0 home draw with Cheltenham Town on 22 September 2012 as a substitute, and following an operation he was expected to be out injured until the Christmas period. McReady returned from injury in a reserve-team match in the North Riding Senior Cup, scoring twice in a 3–0 home win over Northallerton Town on 8 January 2013. He made only one more first-team appearance that season, as a substitute in a 4–1 home defeat to Morecambe on 2 February 2013, thus finishing the season with four appearances for York.
Later career
Having failed to make the substitutes' bench for York under Nigel Worthington, McReady was told he had no future with the club, and signed for Conference Premier club FC Halifax Town on 30 August 2013. McReady made his debut the following day in a 3–1 away defeat to Salisbury City, entering the match as an 86th-minute substitute for Matty Pearson. He finished 2013–14 with 14 appearances for Halifax. McReady signed for newly promoted Northern Premier League Division One North club Spennymoor Town on 3 June 2014. He was released by the club at the end of 2015–16 before signing for Northern Football Alliance Division Two club Whitburn Athletic in July 2016.
Style of play
McReady is an attacking midfielder and has described his style of play as such: "I'm a ball player. I like to attack and get at players – try and create and score goals. I play out wide or in the middle, anywhere across midfield".
