| Year | D I / AAA | D II / AA | D III / A | D IV |
| 2020 | Tournament canceled | Tournament canceled | Tournament canceled | Tournament canceled |
| 2019 | Cincinnati Archbishop Moeller | Trotwood-Madison | Canal Winchester Harvest Prep | Convoy Crestview |
| 2018 | Cincinnati Archbishop Moeller | Akron St. Vincent St. Mary | Cincinnati Deer Park | Maria Stein Marion Local |
| 2017 | Jackson | Akron St. Vincent St. Mary | Cleveland Villa Angela-St. Joseph | Cleveland Heights Lutheran East |
| 2016 | Westerville South | New Concord John Glenn | Lima Central Catholic | Willoughby Hills Cornerstone Christian |
| 2015 | Huber Heights Wayne | Defiance | Cleveland Villa Angela-St. Joseph | New Madison Tri-Village |
| 2014 | Lakewood St. Edward | Norwalk | Lima Central Catholic | Convoy Crestview |
| 2013 | Mentor | Columbus Bishop Watterson | Ottawa-Glandorf | Cleveland Villa Angela-St. Joseph |
| 2012 | Pickerington Central | Dayton Dunbar | Cincinnati Summit Country Day | Berlin Hiland |
| 2011 | Cincinnati La Salle | Akron St. Vincent St. Mary | Cincinnati Taft | Berlin Hiland |
| 2010 | Jackson | Dayton Dunbar | Lima Central Catholic | Dayton Jefferson Township |
| 2009 | Columbus Northland | Akron St. Vincent St. Mary | Cleveland Central Catholic | Oak Hill |
| 2008 | Newark | Chillicothe | Ottawa-Glandorf | New Knoxville |
| 2007 | Cincinnati Archbishop Moeller | Dayton Dunbar | Cincinnati North College Hill | Georgetown |
| 2006 | Canton McKinley | Dayton Dunbar | Cincinnati North College Hill | South Webster |
| 2005 | Canton McKinley | Upper Sandusky | Cincinnati North College Hill | Cleveland Heights Lutheran East * |
| 2004 | Hamilton | Ottawa-Glandorf | St. Henry | Holgate |
| 2003 | Cincinnati Archbishop Moeller | Akron St. Vincent St. Mary | Reading | Maria Stein Marion Local |
| 2002 | Columbus Brookhaven | St. Bernard Roger Bacon | Bellville Clear Fork | Delphos St. John's |
| 2001 | Cleveland St. Ignatius | Kettering Archbishop Alter | Akron St. Vincent St. Mary | Tipp City Bethel |
| 2000 | Cincinnati St. Xavier | Warrensville Heights | Akron St. Vincent St. Mary | Fort Jennings |
| 1999 | Cincinnati Archbishop Moeller | Kettering Archbishop Alter | Bedford St. Peter Chanel | Worthington Christian |
| 1998 | Lakewood St. Edward | Cleveland Benedictine | Sparta Highland | Dayton Jefferson Township |
| 1997 | Cleveland Heights | Cleveland Benedictine | Hamler Patrick Henry | Van Wert Lincolnview |
| 1996 | Cincinnati La Salle | Orrville | Casstown Miami East | Springfield Catholic Central |
| 1995 | Zanesville | Cleveland Villa-Angela/St. Joseph | Orrville | Findlay Liberty-Benton |
| 1994 | Westerville North | Cleveland Villa-Angela/St. Joseph | Youngstown Ursuline | McGuffey Upper Scioto Valley |
| 1993 | Cincinnati Elder | Girard | Campbell Memorial | Fort Loramie |
| 1992 | West Chester Lakota | Cleveland Villa-Angela/St. Joseph | Orrville | Berlin Hiland |
| 1991 | Cleveland Villa-Angela/St. Joseph | Lexington | Haviland Wayne Trace | St. Henry |
| 1990 | Toledo Scott | Dayton Colonel White | St. Henry | Columbus Wehrle |
| 1989 | Toledo Macomber | Lexington | Akron Archbishop Hoban | Columbus Wehrle |
| 1988 | Cincinnati Woodward | Portsmouth | Hamilton Badin | Columbus Wehrle |
| 1987 | Dayton Dunbar | Columbus St. Francis De Sales | Fort Loramie | |
| 1986 | Akron Central-Hower | Oberlin | Columbus Wehrle | |
| 1985 | Cincinnati Purcell Marian | Youngstown Rayen | Jackson Center | |
| 1984 | Canton McKinley | Akron St. Vincent St. Mary | Monroeville | |
| 1983 | Toledo St. Francis De Sales | Columbus Bexley | Delphos St. John's | |
| 1982 | St. Bernard Roger Bacon | Dayton Roth | Middletown Bishop Fenwick | |
| 1981 | Dayton Roth | Napoleon | Kalida | |
| 1980 | Akron Central-Hower | Hamilton Ross | Sandusky St. Mary Central Catholic | |
| 1979 | Columbus East | Dayton Jefferson Township | St. Henry | |
| 1978 | Kettering Archbishop Alter | Portsmouth | Mansfield St. Peter's | |
| 1977 | Columbus Linden McKinley | Cleveland Cathedral Latin | Fort Loramie | |
| 1976 | Barberton | Dayton Roth | Gnadenhutten Indian Valley | |
| 1975 | Columbus Linden McKinley | Warsaw River View | Maria Stein Marion Local | |
| 1974 | Cincinnati Elder | Manchester | Lorain Clearview | |
| 1973 | Cincinnati Elder | Columbus Bishop Ready | Marion Pleasant | |
| 1972 | Cleveland East Technical | Columbus Bishop Ready | Gnadenhutten Indian Valley | |
| 1971 | Columbus Walnut Ridge | Canton Lehman | Fort Recovery | |
| 1970 | | Dayton Chaminade-Julienne | Cincinnati Lincoln Heights | |
| 1969 | | Columbus East | Arcanum | |
| 1968 | | Columbus East | Mansfield St. Peter's | |
| 1967 | | Columbus Linden McKinley | Strasburg-Franklin | |
| 1966 | | Dayton Chaminade-Julienne | New Lebanon Dixie | |
| 1965 | | Columbus South | West Salem Northwestern | |
| 1964 | | Dayton Belmont | Dresden Jefferson | |
| 1963 | | Columbus East | Dresden Jefferson | |
| 1962 | | Hamilton Taft | New Lebanon Dixie | |
| 1961 | | Portsmouth | Defiance Ayersville | |
| 1960 | | Dayton Roosevelt | Salem Local | |
| 1959 | | Cleveland East Technical | Edgerton | |
| 1958 | | Cleveland East Technical | West Salem Northwestern | |
| 1957 | | Middletown | Defiance Ayersville | |
| 1956 | | Middletown | Arcanum | |
| 1955 | | Zanesville | Lockland Wayne | |
| 1954 | | Hamilton | New Lexington St. Aloysius | |
| 1953 | | Middletown | Cincinnati Mariemont | |
| 1952 | | Middletown | Lockland Wayne | |
| 1951 | | Columbus East | Grand Rapids | |
| 1950 | | Springfield | Miller City | |
| 1949 | | Hamilton | Delphos St. John's | |
| 1948 | | Findlay | Eaton | |
| 1947 | | Middletown | Columbiana | |
| 1946 | | Middletown | Farmer | |
| 1945 | | Bellevue | Dayton Northridge | |
| 1944 | | Middletown | Akron Ellet | |
| 1943 | | Newark | Yorkville | |
| 1942 | | Xenia | Somerset | |
| 1941 | | Martins Ferry | Glenford | |
| 1940 | | New Philadelphia | New Carlisle | |
| 1939 | | Akron North | North Canton | |
| 1938 | | Newark | Canal Fulton | |
| 1937 | | Hamilton | Upper Arlington | |
| 1936 | | Newark | Sandusky St. Mary Central Catholic | |
| 1935 | | Akron North | Waterloo High School | |
| 1934 | | Dayton Roosevelt | Waterloo High School | |
| 1933 | | Dover | Lawrenceville | |
| 1932 | | Akron West | Castalia Margaretta | |
| 1931 | | Portsmouth | Austintown-Fitch | |
| 1930 | | Dayton Stivers | Lancaster St. Mary's | |
| 1929 | | Dayton Stivers | Akron St. Mary | |
| 1928 | | Dayton Stivers | Marshall High School | |
| 1927 | | Dover | Kent State High | |
| 1926 | | Zanesville | Oberlin | |
| 1925 | | Richmond Springfield | Bellpoint | |
| 1924 | | Dayton Stivers | Bellpoint | |
| 1923 | | Lorain | Plattsburg | |
| Year | D I / AAA | D II / AA | D III / A | D IV |
| 2020 | Tournament canceled | Tournament canceled | Tournament canceled | Tournament canceled |
| 2019 | Cincinnati Mount Notre Dame | Toledo Rogers | Columbus Africentric | Minster |
| 2018 | Pickerington Central | Toledo Rogers | Columbus Africentric | Minster |
| 2017 | Cincinnati Mount Notre Dame | Kettering Archbishop Alter | Gates Mills Gilmour | Berlin Hiland |
| 2016 | Wadsworth | Kettering Archbishop Alter | Columbus Africentric | Waterford |
| 2015 | West Chester Lakota West | Kettering Archbishop Alter | Versailles | Fort Loramie |
| 2014 | Cincinnati Princeton | Millersburg West Holmes | Columbus Africentric | Reedsville Eastern |
| 2013 | Kettering Fairmont | Shaker Heights Hathaway Brown | Anna | Fort Loramie |
| 2012 | Twinsburg | Shaker Heights Hathaway Brown | Columbus Africentric | Arlington |
| 2011 | Twinsburg | Shaker Heights Hathaway Brown | Anna | Canal Winchester Harvest Preparatory |
| 2010 | Canton McKinley | Shaker Heights Hathaway Brown | Findlay Liberty-Benton | Canal Winchester Harvest Preparatory |
| 2009 | Cincinnati Mount Notre Dame | Shaker Heights Hathaway Brown | South Euclid Regina | Columbus Africentric |
| 2008 | Cincinnati Mount Notre Dame | Kettering Archbishop Alter | Versailles | Berlin Hiland |
| 2007 | Cincinnati Mount Notre Dame | Warsaw River View | Cleveland Central Catholic | Columbus Africentric |
| 2006 | Cincinnati Mount Notre Dame | Warsaw River View | Plain City Jonathan Alder | Berlin Hiland |
| 2005 | Dayton Chaminade-Julienne | Cuyahoga Falls Walsh Jesuit | South Euclid Regina | Berlin Hiland |
| 2004 | Cincinnati Mount Notre Dame | Beloit West Branch | Youngstown Ursuline | Minster |
| 2003 | Beavercreek | Dayton Chaminade-Julienne | South Euclid Regina | Maria Stein Marion Local |
| 2002 | North Canton Hoover | Cleveland East Technical | South Euclid Regina | Delphos St. John's |
| 2001 | Beavercreek | Cincinnati Archbishop McNicholas | South Euclid Regina | Jackson Center |
| 2000 | Mason | Columbus Bishop Hartley | South Euclid Regina | Berlin Hiland |
| 1999 | Pickerington | Dayton Chaminade-Julienne | Cleveland Villa-Angela St. Joseph | Bascom Hopewell-Loudon |
| 1998 | Pickerington | Hamilton Badin | Chagrin Falls | Minster |
| 1997 | Wadsworth | Elida | Wauseon | Kalida |
| 1996 | Columbus Brookhaven | Garfield Heights Trinity | Cincinnati Wyoming | South Charleston Southeastern Local |
| 1995 | Beavercreek | St. Bernard Roger Bacon | Akron St. Vincent-St. Mary | Jackson Center |
| 1994 | Garfield Heights Trinity | Avon Lake | Frankfort Adena | McGuffey Upper Scioto Valley |
| 1993 | Pickerington | Urbana | Baltimore Liberty Union | McGuffey Upper Scioto Valley |
| 1992 | Pickerington | Urbana | Coldwater | Zanesville Bishop Rosecrans |
| 1991 | Celina | Dayton Dunbar | Heath | Fort Recovery |
| 1990 | Pickerington | Garfield Heights Trinity | Coldwater | Fort Recovery |
| 1989 | GlenOak | Byesville Meadowbrook | Sherwood Fairview | Kalida |
| 1988 | Upper Arlington | Akron Archbishop Hoban | Vienna Mathews | Kalida |
| 1987 | Cincinnati Princeton | Lima Bath | Delphos St. John's | - |
| 1986 | Columbus South | Millersburg West Holmes | Tipp City Bethel | - |
| 1985 | Pickerington | Millersburg West Holmes | New Washington Buckeye Central | - |
| 1984 | Cincinnati Forest Park | Millersburg West Holmes | Newark Catholic | - |
| 1983 | Shelby | Huron | Zanesville Bishop Rosecrans | - |
| 1982 | Columbus Northland | Warsaw River View | Zanesville Bishop Rosecrans | - |
| 1981 | Toledo Libbey | Uhrichsville Claymont | Anna | - |
| 1980 | Akron St. Vincent-St. Mary | Delphos St. John's | Mansfield St. Peter's | - |
| 1979 | Akron St. Vincent-St. Mary | Delphos St. John's | Lore City Buckeye Trail | - |
| 1978 | Struthers | Columbus Bishop Hartley | Ada | - |
| 1977 | Springfield North | Warsaw River View | Delphos St. John's | - |
| 1976 | Toledo Woodward | Columbus Bishop Hartley | Frankfort Adena | - |
