List of mayors of Key West, Florida


Mayors of Key West, Florida in the United States have reflected the city's cultural and ethnic heritage including Cuban and openly gay mayors.
  1. 1822-1828 - John H. Fleming, Mayor
  2. 1828–1828 — Edgar Macon, Mayor
  3. *A. 1828–1830 — Edgar Macon, President of the Town Council
  4. *B. 1831–1832 — D. C. Pinkham, President of the Town Council
  5. 1832–1833 — Oliver O'Hara, Mayor
  6. 1833–1834 — Fielding A. Browne
  7. 1834–1835 — Adam Gordon
  8. 1835–1837 — Fielding A. Browne
  9. 1837–1838 — William A. Whitehead
  10. 1838–1839 — Tomaso Saccheti
  11. 1839–1840 — Pardon C. Greene
  12. 1840–1841 — Philip J. Fontaine
  13. 1841–1842 — Alexander Patterson
  14. 1842–1844 — Philip J. Fontaine
  15. 1844–1846 — Benjamin Sawyer
  16. 1846–1848 — Walter C. Maloney
  17. 1848–1852 — Alexander Patterson
  18. 1852–1853 — Fernando J. Moreno
  19. 1853–1854 — John W. Porter
  20. 1854–1854 — John W. Porter
  21. 1854–1855 — William Curry
  22. 1855–1856 — Philip J. Fontaine
  23. 1856–1857 — Alexander Patterson
  24. 1857–1861 — John P. Baldwin
  25. 1861–1861 — William Marvin
  26. 1861–1864 — Alexander Patterson
  27. 1864–1865 — E. O. Gwynn
  28. 1865–1866 — Alexander Patterson
  29. 1866–1866 — William Marvin
  30. 1866–1867 — E. O. Gwynn
  31. 1867–1868 — Alexander Patterson
  32. 1868–1868 — Henry Mulrennan
  33. 1868–1868 — W. S. Allen
  34. 1868–1869 — Dr. D. W. Whitehurst
  35. 1869–1870 — uncertain
  36. 1870–1870 — Henry Mulrennan
  37. 1870–1871 — Joseph B. Browne
  38. 1871–1872 — William D. Cash
  39. 1872–1873 — Winer Bethel
  40. 1873–1874 — W. S. Allen
  41. 1874–1875 — E. O. Gwynn
  42. 1875–1876 — Carlos M. de Cespedes
  43. 1876–1880 — Livingston W. Bethel
  44. 1880–1881 — Robert Jasper Perry
  45. 1881–1882 — E. O. Gwynn
  46. 1882–1883 — William McClintock
  47. 1883–1885 — R. Alfred Monsalvatage
  48. 1885–1886 — James G. Jones
  49. 1886–1888 — J. W. V. R. Plummer
  50. 1888–1889 — James A. Waddell
  51. 1889–1891 — Walter C. Maloney, Jr.
  52. 1891–1895 — Robert Jasper Perry
  53. 1895–1897 — James A. Waddell
  54. 1897–1898 — John B. Maloney
  55. 1898–1903 — George L. Bartlum
  56. 1903–1905 — Benjamin D. Trevor
  57. 1905–1907 — George L. Babcock
  58. 1907–1915 — Dr. Joseph N. Fogarty
  59. 1915–1917 — Norberg Thompson
  60. 1917–1919 — Allen B. Cleare
  61. 1919–1921 — Louis E. Otto
  62. 1921–1925 — Frank H. Ladd
  63. 1925–1933 — Leslie A. Curry
  64. 1933–1935 — William H. Malone
  65. 1935–1937 — Henry C. Galey
  66. 1937–1945 — Willard Albury
  67. 1945–1945 — William W. Demeritt
  68. 1945–1945 — John Carbonell
  69. 1945–1947 — William W. Demeritt
  70. 1947–1949 — A. Maitland Adams
  71. 1949–1950 — Louis M. J. Eisner
  72. 1950–1951 — John Carbonell
  73. 1951–1951 — Louis M. J. Eisner
  74. 1951–1957 — C. B. Harvey
  75. 1957–1961 — Delio Cobo
  76. 1961–1963 — C. B. Harvey
  77. 1963–1969 — Kermit Lewin
  78. 1969–1971 — Delio Cobo
  79. 1971–1981 — Charles "Sonny" McCoy
  80. 1981–1983 — Dennis Wardlow
  81. 1983–1985 — Richard A. Heyman
  82. 1985–1987 — Tom Sawyer
  83. 1987–1989 — Richard A. Heyman
  84. 1989-1989 - John Ingahm
  85. 1989–1991 — Tony Tarracino
  86. 1991–1995 — Dennis Wardlow
  87. 1995–1995 — Tom Sawyer
  88. 1995–1997 — Dennis Wardlow
  89. 1997–1999 — Sheila Mullins
  90. 1999–2005 — Jimmy Weekley
  91. 2005–2009 — Morgan McPherson
  92. 2009-2018 — Craig Cates
  93. 2018-present — Teri Johnston