Fuller began competing in pageants at the age of 10. As a teen, Fuller was chosen as Massachusetts' Junior Miss 2010 and earned $3,600 in scholarship prizes. Competing for the national title, she was a top 10 finalist at the Distinguished Young Women of America 2010 program at the Mobile Civic Center in Mobile, Alabama. On March 10, 2013, Fuller won the Miss Plymouth County 2013 title. As one of 21 qualifiers, she competed in the 2013 Miss Massachusetts pageant with the platform "Knocking Out Dropping Out: Promising Youth Success in School" and a jazz dance performance in the talent portion of the competition. She was named was first runner-up to winner Amanda Narciso and earned $1,400 in scholarship prizes. As first runner-up, Fuller represented Massachusetts at the 2013 National Sweetheart pageant in Hoopeston, Illinois. She placed first runner-up for the national title. On February 16, 2014, Fuller won the Miss Boston 2014 title. She also won the top talent and photogenic awards. Fuller competed in the 2014 Miss Massachusetts pageant with the platform "Knocking Out Dropping Out: Promising Youth Success in School" and a dance performance in the talent portion of the competition. She was named was third runner-up to winner Lauren Kuhn and earned an $1,800 scholarship prize.
Miss Massachusetts 2015
In March 2015, Fuller was crowned Miss Collegiate Area 2015 and qualified for a third entry to the state pageant. She entered the Miss Massachusetts pageant at Worcester's Hanover Theatre for the Performing Arts in late June 2015 as one of 23 qualifiers for the state title. Fuller's competition talent was a jazz dance performance to Jennifer Hudson's cover of "Feeling Good". Her platform is "For the Common Good: Promoting Proactive Healthcare". Fuller won the competition on Sunday, June 28, 2015, when she received her crown from outgoing Miss Massachusetts titleholder Lauren Kuhn. She earned more than $11,250 in scholarship money and other prizes from the state pageant. As Miss Massachusetts, her activities include public appearances across the state of Massachusetts.
Fuller was Massachusetts's representative at the Miss America 2016 pageant in Atlantic City, New Jersey, in September 2015. In the televised finale on September 13, 2015, she placed outside the Top 15 semi-finalists and was eliminated from competition. She was awarded a $3,000 scholarship prize as her state's representative.
