Sebastian earned a scholarship to the University of Pittsburgh, where he again starred in both football and track. He played football as a fullback and held the 1931 Pittsburgh Panthers football team to a shared national championship]. On November 5, 1932, Sebastian faked a pass, cut for the west sidelines, reversed his field, for a 45-yard touchdown run against a heavily favored Notre Dame. Pitt won the game 12–0 for the first victory in the rivalry. That same year Sebastian caught a ball for 52 yards in a 0–0 tie against Ohio State. Sportswriter John Dietrich of The Plain Dealer later called the game "one of the thrillers of a lifetime." Sebastian contributed to a hard-fought 19–12 Pitt victory over Penn by catching a 27-yard touchdown pass late in the game. On October 28, 1933, Sebastian's 75-yard touchdown run highlighted a 14–0 win over Duke. In 1930, and again in 1933, he played in the Rose Bowl, which resulted in a 47–14 and 35–0 losses to the USC Trojans. In 1934 Sebastian played, and was the starting running back, in the first College All-Star Game. The game which became a tradition from 1934 until 1974 was played between the NationalFootball League champions and a team of star college seniors from the previous year. That very first game, was played on August 31, 1934 before a crowd of 79,432 at Chicago's Soldier Field. The game resulted in a scoreless tie between the all-stars and the Chicago Bears. That year Sebastian also played in the second East–West Shrine Game in Chicago.
Professional career
After college, Sebastian went on to a pro football career. He began his career with Cincinnati Reds in 1934, where he is uncredit by most sources for playing with the team. However, he was signed by the team just prior to a game against the Chicago Cardinals. He split the 1935 season between three teams: the Boston Redskins, Philadelphia Eagles and the Pittsburgh Pirates. It is not known the order of the teams he played for in 1935. Some records show that he made his start with the Pirates, but there is also a signed original copy of his contract with the Chicago Cardinals, which offered Sebastian $120 per game ; however, there are no existing statistics to prove that he played for Chicago. In 1936 Sebastian played for the Passaic Red Devils of the minor leagueAmerican Association. The following year Sebastian returned to the NFL with the Cleveland Rams. The Rams were a charter member of the second American Football League in 1936. Although the NFL granted membership in 1937 to the same owner, the NFL considers it a separate entity since only four of the players and none of the team's management made the transfer to the Rams' NFL team. In 1937, Sebastian and Harry Newman were mainstays on the AFL's Rochester Tigers. In 1938, he served a player-coach for the St. Louis Gunners of the American Football League. Sebastian's career ended due to knee and hip problems which not only ended his career, but would eventually end his life.
Rushing stats
Receiving stats
Passing stats
Coaching career
Sebastian retired from playing in 1938 and went back to school to earn a master's degree. He was appointed assistant coach at Rochester Area High School in 1946, with his team going 9–1 that first season. When head coach Earl Ewing resigned, Sebastian was made head coach for the 1947 campaign and made an instant splash with an 8–0–1 team that featured Babe Parilli. He stayed with the Rams three more years, compiling an overall record of 23–12–4. In 1951, Ambridge High School hired Sebastian as their coach. His first team went 7–1–2 and in 1954 the Bridgers finished with an 8–0–1 record that started a four-year 31–5–2 run. His 1956 team was 9–0 and outscored their opponents 367 to 51. Sebastian continued to coach Ambridge through the 1961 season to an overall record of 64–38–4. Afterwards he moved on to New Castle, where he taught classes and coached football before retiring in 1974.
