During the planning stages of development, EA Sports consulted with Marc Crawford on how to improve the realism and strategy of the gameplay. The Saturn version was developed by MBL Research.
Reception
In the United States, the game's Windows version sold 134,714 copies during 1997. The PlayStation version met with resoundingly positive reviews, with critics hailing it as a return to dominance for the NHL series after the '96 PlayStation edition was cancelled and the '97 edition was so-so. John Ricciardi of Electronic Gaming Monthly went so far as to call it "the greatest hockey game ever made." While IGN and GamePro both cautioned that NHL 98 could not be called the best hockey of the year until NHL FaceOff 98 was complete, they assessed it as " best hockey title since its 16-bit glory days" and "a board-battering good time", respectively. Next Generation stated that "NHL '98 is a very good game and just that much better than the rest of the competition." Reviews especially praised the advanced AI, fast gameplay, and the ability to change team strategies on the fly, without going to a pause menu. IGN pointed out that thanks to this last feature, "It only takes a little while for those who don't even care about strategy to experiment with new offenses and defenses that match their playing style. This changes the whole way hockey strategy is used." Glenn Rubenstein added in GameSpot, "Features like these make the game move faster than any other hockey title out there, and they also give the game a thrilling edge that others lack." Critics also praised the sound effects and the graphics, especially the player animations. While some criticized that the controls are a bit loose, most critics praised the controls, with Next Generation arguing that "since the players are on ice, EA's slippery control is actually quite accurate." Later console versions received comparatively little attention. Lee Nutter of Sega Saturn Magazine and Dan Hsu of Electronic Gaming Monthly both razed the Saturn port as a slipshod conversion which lacks the elements that made the PlayStation and PC versions so highly regarded. They noted that the high resolution textures, translucent and reflective effects, scoreboard, names on jerseys, goal celebrations, and referee were all cut from the Saturn version, which nonetheless runs at a frame rate so choppy that it is almost unplayable. With his sole praise being for the play-by-play commentary and sound effects, Nutter dubbed the port "A shambling mockery of its former self" and recommended Saturn owners get NHL All-Star Hockey '98 instead. However, Hsu's three co-reviewers, while acknowledging the port's faults, still felt NHL 98 to be by far the best hockey game for the Saturn, and even Hsu said it was not nearly as bad as NHL All-Star Hockey '98. NHL 98 was a runner-up for Computer Gaming Worlds 1997 "Sports Game of the Year" award, which ultimately went to Baseball Mogul and CART Precision Racing. The editors called NHL 98 "the latest and best in EA's awesome action-oriented" series. NHL 98 was a finalist for the Academy of Interactive Arts & Sciences' 1997 "Personal Computer: Sports Game of the Year" award, which ultimately went to . In 1998, PC Gamer declared it the 17th-best computer game ever released, and the editors called it "quite simply the most entertaining sports game around".
