# | Wrestlers | Reign | Date | Days held | Location | Event | Notes | Ref |
| The Brutal Brigade
| | | | | | Brutal Brigade defeated Darkside in a tournament final to become the first PLW Tag Team Champions. Aired in November 1991 on tape delay. | |
| Darkside
| | | | | | | |
| The Lightning Express
| | | | | | | |
| Brian Flynn and The Shadow Warrior | | | | | | | |
| The Lightning Express | | | | | | | |
| Maniacal Mark and Scott Z. | | | | | | | |
| Vacated | | | | | | The championship is vacated after Scott Z. and Maniacal Mark won tournaments for the vacant Heavyweight and New England championships. | |
| The Lightning Express | | | | | | The Lightning Express defeated The Fall River Wrecking Crew in a tournament final to win the vacant title. | |
| Fall River Wrecking Crew
| | | | | | Blue Thunder substituted for Dutch Davidson. | |
| The S.W.A.T. Team
| | | | | | | |
| Deadly Alliance
| | | | | | | |
| Cain and Dave
| | | | | | | |
| Deadly Alliance
| | | | | | | |
| The S.W.A.T. Team | | | | | | Shane Simons was guest referee. | |
| Destruction Crew
| | | | | | | |
| Amazin' Jay and Exterminator | | | | | | | |
| The Flawless Foundation
| | | | | | | |
| The Pillars of Power
| | | | | | Exterminator defeated The Flawless Foundation in a handicap match with the help of The Defenseman. Exterminator was allowed keep the title if he chose a partner. He picked Sub-Zero. | |
| Crush Force
| | | | | | Awarded titles via forfeit. | |
| The Boston Bulldogs
| | | | | | Awarded titles via forfeit. | |
| The Pillars of Power | | | | | | The Pillars of Power won the tag titles outside the ring. The Flawless One, their manager, filed a protest claiming the titles were wrongly taken away. | |
| Knights of the Realm
| | | | | | This was a Triangle match also involving Fryght. | |
| The Pillars of Power | | | | | | This was a Triangle match also involving Fryght. | |
| Maniacal Mark and Don Juan de Santo | | | | | | | |
| The Pillars of Power | | | | | | Dr. Heresy substituted for Maniacal Mark. | |
| Maniacal Mark and Don Juan de Santo | | | | | | This was a Fatal Four-Way match also involving Knights of the Realm and Amazin' Jay and Vertabreaker. The team broke up when Don Juan de Santo won the PLW Heavyweight Championship. | |
| The Damned
| | | | | | The Damned were awarded the title after Draven traded the PLW New England Championship to Maniacal Mark in exchange for his half of the PLW Tag Team Championship. | |
| Elements of Suicide
| | | | | | This was a Triple Threat match also involving Frankie Armadillo and Damian Houston. | |
| Jason the Slasher and The Mighty Moco | | | | | | | |
| Elements of Suicide | | | | | | Paul Lauzon substituted for Jason the Slasher. | |
| Chris Blackheart and Don Vega | | | | | | | |
| Extreme Heat
| | | | | | The previous incarnation of Extreme Heat consisted of Kid Pyro and AK Fuego. This pairing defeated Blackheart and Don Vega to win the tag team title. | |
| Vacated | | | | | | When AK Fuego announced he was moving to Florida, Kid Pyro was allowed to replace Fuego with a partner of his choice. Pyro was asked to vacate the titles when he was unable to find a replacement. | |
| Matt Storm and Mr. Munroe | | | | | | This was a Fatal Four-Way match also involving The Air Devils, The Baker Boys and Impact Inc.. | |
| The McGraws
| | | | | | This was a 6-man tag team match also involving T.J. Richter. The championship is subsequently defended under the Freebird rule. | |
| Matt Storm and T.J. Richter | | | | | | | |
| Anthony Greene and Rob Araujo | | | | | | | |
| The Glamorous Express
| | | | | | Christian Casanova substituted for Anthony Greene. | |