On April 1, 1983, he was traded to the Cleveland Indians in exchange for Jerry Dybzinski and became their starting first baseman. That year he hit.291 in 124 games. He became quickly known as a line drive hitter and continued to have modest success at the plate. His best season was in 1987 when he became an all-star, hitting.307 with 11 home runs and 86 runs batted in. Along with first base he was well suited for the designated hitter role he inherited from Andre Thornton in 1987. He gained attention for his amazing success in bases-loaded situations and was even recognized and nicknamed "Mr. Clutch" on his 1986 Donruss baseball card. He played in Cleveland until 1988, when he was traded to the Kansas City Royals for pitcher Bud Black.
Kansas City Royals
He played for Kansas City until the 1990 season, when he was traded to the New York Mets.
Tabler finished his career with the Toronto Blue Jays, winning a World Series championship with the club in his final year as a player. Tabler was also known as a remarkable clutch hitter and for his uncanny ability to hit with the bases loaded, batting just under.500 in such situations for his career. Twice in his career Tabler had 6 runs batted in in one game, on September 25, 1983 and June 8, 1985, both versus the Seattle Mariners.
Broadcasting career
After his retirement, Tabler joined TSN as a studio analyst for Toronto Blue Jays broadcasts in 1993. After the network's color commentator, former Blue Jays catcher Buck Martinez, was named the team's manager in 2001, Tabler replaced him in the broadcast booth alongside play-by-play announcerDan Shulman. He continued as the TSN color analyst when Rod Black replaced Shulman, who left for ESPN. Tabler took over as the main color commentator for TSN's main rival, Rogers Sportsnet in 2005 after the sudden death of their regular commentator, former pitcher John Cerutti, calling the majority of games for both networks from 2005 to 2009 alongside Jamie Campbell and Rod Black. Tabler now works exclusively for Sportsnet, which is the exclusive Toronto Blue Jays broadcaster. His partners are Martinez who returned to the Blue Jays broadcast booth as play-by-playannouncer in 2010, and Shulman, who returned as a part-time announcer in 2016. On September 25, 2014, Rogers announced Tabler had signed a five-year extension.
Personal
Tabler has mentioned on a few occasions he is a fan of the bandJethro Tull. He is married and has five children.