Robbie Eagles made his professional wrestling debut in March 2008 for Australian promotion Professional Wrestling Alliance. In November 2008, Eagles defeated Rick Sterling and Troy The Boy to become the PWA A1GP champion for his first time. In February 2009, Eagles and KC Cassidy defeated Mike Valuable and Madison Eagles. In May 2009, Eagles defended his A1GP championship against his brother, Ryan, to a 30-minute time limit draw. Eagles successfully defended his title against Matt Silva. In October 2009, Eagles was defeated by William Kidd, losing the A1GP championship. In 2010, Eagles was defeated by Damian Slater. In 2018, at a PWA and Progress joint show, Eagles was defeated by Travis Banks. In 2018, Eagles lost his PWA heavyweight championship to Jonah Rock. In 2010, Eagles made his Melbourne City Wrestling debut as part of PWA Invades MCW, where he represented PWA. In Eagles second MCW match he defeated Ryan Rollins. Eagles and Adam Brooks defeated TMDK in the quarter final round of the MCW Tag Team Title Tournament in 2012 before being eliminated by Hard Way Inc. In 2011, Eagles made his Chikara debut taking part in the Young Lions Cup. In 2012, Eagles made his Pro Wrestling Zero1 debut as Robby Eagle. In his debut, Eagles and Marcus Bean defeated Craig Classic and Yoshikazu Yokoyama. In June, Eagle and Ikuto Hidaka defeated Bean and Classic. On 1 July Eagle, now again named Robbie Eagles and Hidaka defeated Jonathan Gresham and Classic. On 20 July Eagles, Gresham and Hikada defeated Mineo Fujita, Takuya Sugawara and Jonny Vandal.
Eagles made his New Japan Pro-Wrestling debut in 2018 during New Japan's Fallout Down Under tour. On day 2, Eagles and Mick Moretti were defeated by TMDK. On day 3, Eagles and Moretti were defeated by Evil and Sanada of Los Ingobernables de Japon. On day 4, Eagles and Will Ospreay were defeated by Cody. On 8 October 2018Bad Luck Fale announced that Eagles would be Taiji Ishimori's tag partner in the 2018 Super Jr. Tag Tournament, thus aligning himself with the Bullet Club. Ishimori and Eagles finished the tournament with a result of 3 wins and 4 losses. On 29 June 2019 at Southern Showdown, Eagles was unsuccessful in challenging Will Ospreay for the IWGP Junior Heavyweight Championship. The following night he turned on Bullet Club leader Jay White, leaving Bullet Club in the process and joined Chaos, turning face in the process. On 31 August 2019 at NJPW Royal Quest, Eagles teamed up with Ospreay as the “Birds Of Prey” to defeat IWGP Junior Heavyweight Tag Team ChampionsEl Phantasmo and Taiji Ishimori in a non-title match. On the 16th of September 2019, Ospreay and Eagles unsuccessfully challenged Phantasmo and Ishimori for the championships at Destruction in Kagoshima.
Pro Wrestling Guerrilla (2018–2019)
Eagles made his debut for Pro Wrestling Guerrilla during All Star Weekend 14, where he and Morgan Webster were defeated by Sammy Guevara. The next night he was defeated by Joey Janela. At PWG Bask in his Glory he was defeated by Bandido. He would later enter the 2018 Battle of Los Angeles, where he defeated DJZ in the first round, but lost to Shingo Takagi in the second round. Eagles returned to PWG on 18 January 2019 for their event Hand of Doom in Los Angeles, California where he defeated Jonathan Gresham at the event.
