Maglie broke into the major leagues with the Giants in 1945, but jumped to the Mexican League prior to the 1946 season. For this, Maglie was banned from organized baseball by Commissioner Happy Chandler, and Maglie was unable to return to the Giants until 1950. The ban had been lifted in 1949, but Maglie chose to remain with the Drummondville Cubs, with whom he was playing at the time, and with whom he was making more money than he did with the Giants. After his return to the majors, Maglie was integral to the success of the New York Giants teams of the early 1950s. After a stint with Cleveland, Maglie was purchased by the Dodgers in May 1956. Maglie had a sterling comeback season for the Brooklyn Dodgers in 1956, going 13–5 with 2.89 ERA. On September 25 of that year, he no-hit the Philadelphia Phillies 5-0 at Ebbets Field. He finished second to Don Newcombe in the first balloting for the Cy Young Award, and was also second to Newcombe in MVP balloting. He was the Dodgers' pitcher opposing Don Larsen of the Yankees in the latter's famous perfect game in Game 5 of the 1956 World Series. Willie Mays told a story in his autobiography of hitting a home run against Maglie after Maglie went to the Dodgers. However, the only home run Maglie gave up to the Giants while wearing a Dodger uniform was to Ray Jablonski, not Mays. Hall of Fame pitcher Don Drysdale credited Maglie with teaching him the art of brushing back batters while the two were teammates in Brooklyn.
Coaching career
After one year as a scout for the Cardinals, and two stints with the Boston Red Sox as a pitching coach, Maglie was hired as a pitching coach for the expansion Seattle Pilots in 1969. He was profiled unflatteringly in Jim Bouton's book Ball Four, despite the fact that he was Bouton's boyhood hero. Bouton commented that Maglie rarely gave useful advice to the pitchers, and frequently second-guessed their choice of pitches, often contradicting his previous second guessing. In one such instance, Bouton related:
The man I love had quite an adventure tonight. Darrell Brandon pitching, and with Rod Carew on third base he's using a full wind-up. At the last moment he decides to take a look over at Carew, who's taking a pretty good lead. So he backs off the rubber and Sal yells at him, "For crissakes, get the hitter. The runner isn't going anyplace." So Darrell winds up and lets fly. And Carew steals home. When Darrell comes into the dugout at the end of the inning, Maglie lets him have it. "Dammit", he says. "You know you've got to pitch from the stretch in that situation."
Jim Lonborg, AL Cy Young Award winner in 1967, credited his effectiveness that year to Maglie's lessons on pitching inside while he was a pitching coach for the Red Sox.
Pitching Style
Though Maglie never shaved before games, his "Sal the Barber" came from his propensity to give close shaves—that is, pitched inside to hitters. Willie Mays summarized his reason for throwing inside: "He always liked to be in complete control of a game, and the way he did this, or thought he had to do it, was by pitching batters close. You always had to worry about a brushback pitch from him. You knew he would throw it, but you didn't know how close he would make it."
Legacy
During the 1950s, Maglie lived in Riverdale, The Bronx. Maglie appeared on the game show What's My Line?the night before he started Game 5 of the 1956 World Series, with former Yankee Phil Rizzuto as one of the panel members. Maglie died in 1992 due to complications from pneumonia. Sal Maglie Stadium, located in Hyde Park in his hometown of Niagara Falls, New York, was named after him in June 1983. The ceremony featured the world's shortest baseball bus excursion. left the Stadium Grill located about two hundred yards across the street and drove into Sal Maglie Stadium. The event was captured in a story done by Bob Koshinski and aired on ESPN. Sal Maglie Stadium is now the home to the Niagara Purple Eaglescollege baseball team, Niagara Falls Wolverines, Niagara Catholic Patriots, and Niagara Power of the NYCBL.
