Tuck played junior football at Beaconsfield in the suburbs of Melbourne, and played representative football with the Dandenong Stingrays in the TAC Cup. In his draft-age year in 1999, Tuck also played with the reserves side in the AFL reserves competition.
Playing career
Hawthorn (2001–2001)
After being overlooked by the club as a potential father–son rule selection at the 1999 national draft, Tuck was offered a rookie contract opportunity when selected by with the club's second selection and 24th pick overall in the 2000 rookie draft. He spent two seasons at Hawthorn without earning an AFL debut, instead playing reserves grade football with the club's VFL affiliate, the Box Hill Hawks. At the end of the 2001 AFL season, Tuck was delisted by Hawthorn.
Local and state-league football (2002–2003)
Tuck played local football in the Mornington Peninsula League in 2002, before moving to South Australia to play with West Adelaide in the SANFL in 2003, where he began attracting the attention of AFL scouts.
Richmond (2004–2013)
Tuck was drafted by with the club's six pick and the 73rd pick overall in the 2003 AFL Draft. After spending much of the year playing reserves football with the club's VFL-affiliate, Tuck made his AFL debut in round 14 of the 2004 AFL season. In 2005, Tuck had a stellar season and played all 22 games Richmond were involved in. He finished third in the club's best and fairest award that year. Tuck placed 10th in the club's best and fairest in 2006, third in 2007, and second in 2008. Tuck missed playing in round 17 2009, ending a 104-game streak of consecutive games since playing in round 1, 2005. He placed seventh in the club's best and fairest in 2009. In round 6 2010, Tuck collected a career-best 28 disposals in a match against. A month later he set a new club record with 14 tackles in a match against in round 10. That year he placed fifth in the club's best and fairest count. After the 2011 season, Tuck informed the club of his decision to retire, but was talked into recommitting to the club for at least one further season. In round 12 in 2012, he collected a club record 23 contested possessions, a feat which he equaled six weeks later in round 18. In 2012, Tuck placed fourth in the club's best and fairest count. He set new records that year for the most contested possessions and most tackles in a single season by any Richmond player in the club's history. Both records stood for five years until broken by former teammates Dustin Martin and Trent Cotchin, respectively, in 2017. At the end of the year he was awarded life membership at Richmond. Tuck suffered a fractured scapula in May 2013 that saw him miss two months of football. Following four weeks of reserves football, Tuck made a return to AFL football for the later part of the season, before announcing he would retire at season's end. Tuck featured in the club's first finals match in 12 years when Richmond earned an elimination final berth against in 2013. He was the substitute player for Richmond during that match, but played almost the full match when brought on to replace Reece Conca after the latter suffered a hamstring injury just 10 minutes into the game. Tuck retired following the 2013 season, after 173 games over 10 seasons with Richmond.
Shane was the son of footballer and former-VFL/AFL games record holder Michael Tuck and older brother of former footballer Travis Tuck. He was the nephew of great Gary Ablett Sr and former VFL footballers Geoff and Kevin Ablett. He was cousin to Geelong and players Gary Ablett Jr and Nathan Ablett. Tuck was married to wife Katherine and had two children, a boy and a girl. Tuck died by suicide on 20 July 2020 at the age of 38. Richmond wore black armbands to honour his memory in their Round 8 match against on 24 July 2020.