Nash and Reyna became friends, as Nash spent his off-seasons in New York City and regularly played pick-up soccer, and Reyna played for the New York Red Bulls of Major League Soccer. During the summer of 2007, Nash and Reyna attempted to play a pick-up game between one of Nash's teams and the Red Bulls in Central Park's Sheep Meadow, but park regulations prohibited ball playing on the field. The idea for the 2008 match came from Nash and Italian journalist and NBA TV analyst Simone Sandri, who asked Nash's friend Venanzio Ciampa, the president of the marketing firm The Promotion Factory, to organize the event. Ciampa said they chose Sara D. Roosevelt Park as the venue, because they "wanted a cool spot", and the park "shows the melting pot aspect of New York that Steve and I love."
Team Nash beat Team Reyna Team, on three goals from Robbie Fowler and two goals each from Henry and Nash. Team Nash started the match down 0-2, but Henry took control of the game with a shift to a more attacking 1-3-3 formation, assisting on a goal by McManaman and scoring the equalizer himself.
Admission for the match was free, and the all-star lineups attracted over a thousand spectators, what Stein described as "at least 2,500 people", and fans packed the field two-deep around the field and four-deep around the outside fences. Other fans climbed on top of cars, trees, fences and streetlights to get a view, and SLAM writer Lang Whitaker wrote, "it looked like the famous picture of Dr. J at Rucker." Reyna said of the crowd, "We had it completely wrong in terms of the excitement. We knew people were going to come out, but we just couldn’t believe it when we showed.", while Henry, who was mobbed by journalists and autograph seekers said, "I think it was great. I didn't know it was going to be like a lot of people around the Astroturf. But I guess they wanted to see Steve, Baron and the other guys there. I don't know, I think it was a great environment."
2009
Teams
Team Nash
Francesco Santoro
Steve Nash
Martin Nash
Thierry Henry
Mathieu Flamini
Simone Sandri
Ryan Babel
Edgar Davids
Grant Hill
Team Reyna
Mike Quarino
Claudio Reyna
Javier Zanetti
Iván Córdoba
Salomon Kalou
Adrian Mutu
Chris Bosh
Tony Parker
Marc Stein
Match Result
Team Reyna won 8-5
2010
and Claudio Reyna once again captained the two sides in the 2010 match. Several soccer players who had participated in the event in past years were unable to attend due to the 2010 World Cup in South Africa. Players in the 2010 match included ESPN reporter Marc Stein; NBA players Brandon Jennings, Tony Parker, Nate RobinsonJared Dudley and Raja Bell; and soccer players Giuseppe Rossi and Youri Djorkaeff. Robinson claimed it was his first ever time playing soccer, despite scoring a goal.
2011
Teams
Team Nash
Steve Nash
Martin Nash
Simone Sandri
Leandro Barbosa
Raja Bell
Giuseppe Rossi
Richie Williams
John Nash
Team Reyna
Claudio Reyna
Tony Parker
Marcin Gortat
Marc Stein
Brandon Jennings
Patrick Viera
Demba Ba
Grant Hill
Jared Dudley
Youri Djorkaeff
Match Result
Team Nash won 16-10, and Giuseppe Rossi won the Hublot MVP award.
2012
Teams
Team "World"
Steve Nash
Simone Sandri
Giuseppe Rossi
Salomon Kalou
Charly Ludi
Emmerson Boyce
Elton Brand
Alessandro Noselli
Enrico Zanus
Team "USA"
Robbie Rogers
Marc Stein
Maurice Edu
Stuart Holden
Jimmy Conrad
Danny Green
Mike Dunleavy, Jr.
Mehdi Ballouchy
Match Result
Team World won 9-7, and Salomon Kalou won the Gucci MVP award.