When the Telarc label released the self-financed recording of Johann Sebastian Bach's Goldberg Variations, her career was "launched into the stratosphere", with the album outselling The White Stripes on Amazon.com. In its first week of commercial release, the recording was at No.1 on the Billboardclassical music CD sales chart. The disc appeared on a number of “Best of 2007” lists, including those of The New York Times, the Los Angeles Times, The New Yorker, Time Out New York, several radio stations, iTunes “Editor’s Choice Best Classical,” Amazon.com Best CDs of 2007, and Barnes & Noble's Top 5 Debut CDs of 2007.
In 2010, Simone Dinnerstein signed with Sony Classical and in January 2011, she released her first album on the label, entitled Bach: A Strange Beauty. In its first week of commercial release, the recording made its debut at No.1 on the Billboard Traditional Classical Chart. Bach: A Strange Beauty also spent time as the No.1 top selling album on Barnesandnoble.com and No.2 selling album on Amazon.com, in good company with The Decemberists, Cake, The Black Keys and Bruno Mars. Dinnerstein was also featured on CBS Sunday Morning. Her second Sony Classical album, Something Almost Being Said: Music of Bach and Schubert, was released in January 2012. In 2013, Dinnerstein released a Sony album with singer-songwriter Tift Merritt called Night. That year she also released on Sony an album called Bach Re-Invented, which interspersed Bach with new compositions based on Bach by Daniel Schnyder, Tom Trapp, and Gene Pritsker; on the album, the Absolute Ensemble was conducted by Kristjan Järvi. In 2014, Sony released Dinnerstein's recording of Bach's Inventions and Sinfonias. In February 2015, Sony released a recording featuring Dinnerstein as soloist, entitled Broadway-Lafayette. It includes three works: the Piano Concerto of Maurice Ravel; the Rhapsody in Blue of George Gershwin; and a new concerto composed for her in 2012 by Philip Lasser entitled The Circle and the Child: Concerto for Piano and Orchestra, which was inspired by a chorale of Johann Sebastian Bach, Ihr Gestirn, ihr hohen Lüfte. On the recording, Dinnerstein is accompanied by the MDR Leipzig Radio Symphony Orchestra conducted by Kristjan Järvi.
Personal life
A former piano teacher, Dinnerstein resides in the Park Slope section of Brooklyn, New York. Her husband, former British journalist Jeremy Greensmith, teaches fifth grade at the New York elementary school P.S. 321. Among the students at the school was Dinnerstein's and Greensmith's son Adrian. Dinnerstein's mother, Renee Dinnerstein, taught early childhood education at P.S. 321 for eighteen years and now runs the blog "Investigating Choice Time: Inquiry, Exploration and Play". Dinnerstein's father, Simon Dinnerstein, is an artist, as is her uncle, Harvey Dinnerstein.