St. George, Louisiana


St. George is a proposed city in Louisiana that was approved in a ballot initiative on October 12, 2019. Upon incorporation, it would become the fifth largest city in Louisiana and the second largest in East Baton Rouge Parish with a population of 86,316. The proposed city originates from a previously unincorporated area of East Baton Rouge Parish located southeast of the City of Baton Rouge. A legal action to challenge the incorporation of St. George was filed in 19th Judicial District Court in East Baton Rouge Parish on November 4, 2019. A trial date has not been set.

Background

Efforts to incorporate

In 2012 and again in 2013, St. George organizers sought approval of the state legislature to form a new school district but were unsuccessful. In June 2015, organizers attempted to form a new city but failed to collect enough signatures on the petition. Consequently, an election could not be called. The formation of a new city is seen as a pathway for forming a new school district. The formation of a new school district would require approval of the state legislature as well as approval of voters at the state level and approval of voters in East Baton Rouge Parish.
In October 2018, St. George organizers submitted a second petition to form a new city. This petition proposed a smaller city that included some of the same area as the original petition but reduced the minority representation within the proposed city from 23% to 12%.
In February 2019, the East Baton Rouge Parish Registrar of Voters declared that the petition had enough valid signatures to meet the requirements for eligibility. In March 2019, Louisiana Gov. John Bel Edwards authorized adding the petition to the October 12, 2019, ballot.
Of the more than 54,000 registered voters living in the St. George area, approximately 32,293 cast ballots, with 17,422 voting in favor of incorporation and 14,871 voting against.
However, before the Governor could appoint an interim mayor and interim city council, a legal action was filed to contest the incorporation.

The lawsuit

The process for municipal incorporation is codified in Louisiana state law. This law describes the process for incorporation and the process for contesting an incorporation. The law is composed of the following sections:
In accordance with Section 4, which allows for contesting an incorporation, a legal action was filed to challenge the incorporation on the following grounds:
Relief sought by the plaintiffs includes a favorable judgement denying the incorporation of St. George, or, alternatively, a parish-wide election to determine if Section 1.05 of the Plan of Government should be amended to allow for the formation of a new city. Plaintiffs also request that the court hold defendants responsible for the costs of litigation.
On December 2, 2019, defendants responded to the lawsuit on the following grounds:
In addition, defendants in the case filed a motion for an expedited hearing on the exceptions.
Relief sought by defendants includes dismissing the claims of the plaintiffs and holding the plaintiffs responsible for the costs of litigation.
At a March 2, 2020, hearing on the exceptions, 19th Judicial District Court Judge William Morvant held that one of the four plaintiffs lacked standing. The remaining exceptions to the lawsuit were dismissed. Defendants in the case have informed the court that they will continue to challenge the standing of two other plaintiffs by filing an appeal.
The case now enters the discovery process.
A trial date on the substance of the lawsuit has not yet been set.
Until the litigation is resolved and appeals exhausted, the Governor is unable to appoint a temporary governing authority for the proposed city. Consequently, the St. George incorporation effort is in "legal limbo".

Annexations

Any property owner in unincorporated areas adjacent to the Baton Rouge city limits can request to be annexed into the capital city. The request for annexation must be submitted to the Metro Council for approval.
During the first petition effort, several residents and business owners annexed into the Baton Rouge city limits.
Following the October 12, 2019, election, additional residents and business owners in the proposed St. George city limits requested annexation into the City of Baton Rouge. On January 8, 2020, the Metro Council approved all of these annexations.
On February 7, 2020, St. George organizers filed a lawsuit seeking to invalidate the annexations in the United Plaza area. The lawsuit claims that the legal requirements for these annexations were not followed. An attorney who represents the property owners claims that the lawsuit is without merit.
On February 26, 2020, the Metro Council approved additional annexations into the City of Baton Rouge.
Meanwhile, annexation into the proposed City of St. George is not possible while it lacks certification as a city and a governing authority.

Adverse Effects

Legal basis

Section 3 of Title 33 specifies that only voters within a proposed incorporated area can vote on approving a new municipality:
All qualified electors residing within the area proposed for incorporation shall be entitled to vote in the special election.
Under this provision, East Baton Rouge Parish voters living outside of the proposed City of St. George could not participate in the referendum on the new city. This includes voters in the communities of Baker, Baton Rouge, Central and Zachary as well as the remaining unincorporated areas of East Baton Rouge Parish.
Section 4 of Title 33, however, provides a remedy for individuals and municipalities that may be adversely affected by a proposed incorporation:
In determining whether the incorporation is reasonable, the court shall consider the possible adverse effects the incorporation may have on other municipalities in the vicinity.
Consequently, "adverse effects" is a major component of the legal action contesting the incorporation of St. George. As noted on page 9 of the lawsuit :
Approximately two-thirds of the voters in East Baton Rouge Parish were not allowed to vote because they do not live in the St. George area, even though the incorporation of St. George will adversely and financially affect them.

Estimated revenue and expenditures

In October 2017, St. George organizers commissioned an accounting firm to evaluate the revenue, expenditures and budget for the proposed city. In brief, the Carr, Riggs and Ingram, LLC report showed that the City of St. George would have an estimated budget surplus in Year 1:
Estimated Total Budgeted Revenues: $58,399,000
Estimated Total Budgeted Expenditures: $33,911,000
Estimated Total Budgeted Surplus: $24,488,000
Given the projected surplus and methods of governance, St. George organizers claim that the incorporation will not necessitate an increase in taxes.
In July 2018, economist James Richardson and public administration expert Jared Llorens released a report of their analysis of potential revenues and expenditures of the proposed city. Their study found that in Year 1 tax revenues would be about $12 million less than what organizers claim and that costs of city services would be about $17 million more:
Estimated Total Budgeted Revenues: $45,770,000
Estimated Total Budgeted Expenditures: $51,610,000
Estimated Total Budgeted Surplus: -$5,840,000
Given the projected deficit and other unbudgeted expenses, opponents of St. George incorporation claim that residents of the new city would see additional taxes or a reduction in public services.
In addition, the lawsuit questions the "reasonableness" and "capacity" of the new city to provide required public services.

Provision of public services

The petition approved by voters on October 12, 2019 describes the list of public services that the City of St. George proposes "to render to the area and a plan for the provision of these services":
1. Public Safety services through the continuation of services provided by St. George Fire Protection District, East Side Fire District, and the East Baton Rouge Parish Sheriff's Office.
2. Sanitation and garbage collection through the continuation of services provided by the consolidated garbage service district.
3. Sewerage by continuation of services through the East Baton Rouge consolidated sewer district.
4. Emergency Medical Services though continuation of served by the East Baton Rouge Parish Department of EMS.
5. 911 services through continuation of services provided by the East Baton Rouge Parish 911 District.
6. The City of St. George may provide the following services through contractor or municipal staff:
6a. Regulation of property use by adoption of planning and zoning ordinance.
6.b. Building Inspections.
6.c. Traffic signs and signals.
6.d. Maintenance and improvement of municipal public streets and roads.
6.e. Maintenance of right of way.
6.f. Maintenance and improvements of drainage system.
6.h. Animal control.
All services will be provided subject to the availability of funds derived from taxes, license fees, permits and other revenue which become available to the municipality and are authorized by state law.
According to the lawsuit, the petition does not fully meet the requirements of Title 33, Section 4:
St. George organizers counter that: "Our attorneys advised us to say because it gives us the flexibility to say ‘Hey, what's best for us?’ If the city-parish has a wonderful contract for trash collection that gets us pick up service two days a week, recycling, and it's cheaper than what we can get on our own, let's do that.  And if it's cheaper to run trash collection, or any other municipal service ourselves through a private service, we’re going to do that."
St. George organizers counter that: "Fire protection will be provided by the St. George Fire Department, which is already funded by 14 mills on its residents’ property tax bill, and by the East Side Fire Department, which already collects 22.5 mills from its citizens. Police protection will be provided by the East Baton Rouge Sheriff’s Office, which is also already funded by property taxes that residents of the new city already pay. Sewer, streets and garbage pick-up are already funded by a parish-wide half-cent sales tax. The new city will provide for the maintenance and upkeep of streets, bridges, medians, ditches, canals, and other public grounds and facilities in the new city."
The lawsuit contends that the lack of full compliance would require that the petition for incorporation should be disallowed:
 If the district court determines that the provisions of this Subpart have not been complied with, that the proposed municipality will not be able to provide the public services proposed in the petition within a reasonable period of time, or that the incorporation is unreasonable, the district court shall enter an order denying the incorporation.

History

Native American presence

After the French and Indian War ended in 1763, Bayou Manchac became an international border between the British and Spanish colonial territories. This bayou runs from the Mississippi River on the west to the Amite River on the east.
Native Americans, specifically Choctaw, were known to have lived in southeast Louisiana when Europeans first arrived. In 1764, after encroachment from European settlers, the Alabama-Coushatta and Pakana Muscogee Indians migrated into Louisiana, to just north of Bayou Manchac.

American Revolution

In 1765, the British built Fort Bute on the eastern bank of the Mississippi River at Bayou Manchac, not far from the present-day University Club Golf Course. The fort consisted of a blockhouse and stockade capable of holding 200 men.
On May 8, 1779, Spain officially entered the American Revolutionary War by declaring war against the British. With this news, Bernardo de Galvez, the colonial Governor of Spanish Louisiana, began assembling an ad hoc army of over 1400 Spanish regulars, Acadian militia, free men of color and native Americans. On August 27, 1779, they began advancing toward Baton Rouge. Trudging through muddy swamp at a rate of nine miles a day, they arrived at Fort Bute eleven days later. After a brief skirmish, they captured and demolished the fort in what would become the first Spanish action against the British during the American Revolutionary War. Galvez and his army remained at Fort Bute for six days before moving on to defeat the British garrison at Fort New Richmond in the Battle of Baton Rouge. Their victories at Fort Bute and Fort New Richmond helped to clear the Mississippi River of British forces and put the lower Mississippi River under Spanish control.

War of 1812

During the War of 1812, U.S. Gen. Andrew Jackson had the mouth of Bayou Manchac filled with earth to prevent the British from using it to launch a surprise attack on New Orleans. In 1828, American settlers reinforced that blockage with a large earthen dam to stifle flood waters from regularly inundating their properties. Although it was later suggested that reconnecting the two bodies of water might actually help alleviate flooding in the area, the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers declined to.

Historic sites

The National Register of Historic Places includes several sites in the St. George area. Among them are:
*
Other sites of historical interest in the St. George area include:
Between 1956 and 1968, the Village St. George subdivision was constructed near its namesake, later forming the nucleus of the census-designated place of the same name.
In 1966, the increased suburbanization of the area warranted the creation of the "Village St. George Volunteer Fire Department and Social Club", now called the St. George Fire Protection District. Its coverage area also overlapped with much of the proposed new city's boundaries.

Place names

Prominent place names in the St. George area include:

Area

The proposed city would cover approximately 60 square miles and be located entirely within the southeastern section of East Baton Rouge Parish, bordered on the west by the Mississippi River, on the south by Bayou Manchac, and on the east by the Amite River. Much of the northwestern boundary of the city would extend to the Baton Rouge city limits, although portions of St. George would border unincorporated parish land. affected much of East Baton Rouge Parish, including the St. George area.

Flooding

The 2016 Louisiana floods had a profound effect upon East Baton Parish, particularly along the Comite River, the Amite River and Bayou Manchac. In response, East Baton Rouge Parish developed a Stormwater Master Plan Implementation Framework to mitigate flooding concerns.
In 2018, Congress authorized funding for the East Baton Rouge Parish Flood Risk Reduction Project to reduce flooding throughout the parish. Using $187 million in federal funds and $64 million in matching state and local funds, the project will provide for 66 miles of drainage improvements along five sub-basins in the parish. In the St. George area, the authorized four-year projects involve:
  1. Jones Creek and tributaries: clearing and snagging three miles and structurally lining 16 miles with reinforced concrete
  2. Ward Creek and tributaries: clearing and snagging 14 miles of channel and concrete lining
  3. Bayou Fountain: clearing and widening 11 miles of channel
Organizers of the proposed City of St. George have budgeted $2,247,000 in Year 1 for drainage and transportation.

Baton Rouge fault

The Baton Rouge fault is an active growth fault that runs across the southern part of East Baton Rouge Parish, including parts of the St. George area. It extends from the Mississippi River near downtown Baton Rouge to the Amite River. In the St. George area, it generally runs along Tiger Bend Road from Airline Highway to the Amite River. The height of the escarpment ranges from 4 to 7 meters. The average rate of vertical movement is about 3–5 mm/year. The fault has had a particularly pronounced effect near the Jones Creek Road-Tiger Bend Road intersection. Continuous structural repairs to Woodlawn High School buildings located at that intersection forced the abandonment of the property and the building of a new school complex in Old Jefferson—the first new campus that the school board built in the parish in more than thirty years. In 2017, several residents from the Tiger Bend area raised concerns about plans for an upscale subdivision located near the fault line.

Earthquakes

Although Louisiana is not seismically active, several low magnitude earthquakes have been felt in the Baton Rouge area. On November 19, 1958, residents of Baton Rouge, Baker and Denham Springs reportedly felt a 10-second, moderate magnitude earthquake with an epicenter near Baton Rouge.

Geomorphology

A Pleistocene prairie terrace, formed of alluvial deposits and wind-blown soil, underlies most of East Baton Rouge Parish. In the St. George area, long slopes along portions of Highland Road can be seen where the prairie terrace meets the Mississippi River floodplain. Visitors to the LSU Hilltop Arboretum, for example, must drive up the slope to enter the facility. Other notable examples of terracing can be observed in Baton Rouge at the Old Louisiana State Capitol and Magnolia Mound Plantation.

Demographics

St. George has a population of 86,316 within its proposed city limits. Whites make up more than 70% of that population, and African Americans make up 12%.
The proposed City of St. George would include several areas that have each been established as a Census Designated Place :
The St. George area is served by the Recreation and Park Commission for the Parish of East Baton Rouge. Park facilities in the St. George area include the Burbank Soccer Complex, the Highland Road Community Park, Highland Road Park Observatory and Airline Highway Park.
Through BREC's Capital Area Pathways Project, a network of connected trails and greenways is being developed throughout the parish. BREC's Blueways initiative provides paddling access to Bayou Fountain from Highland Road Community Park. Additional canoe-kayak launches are planned for Bayou Manchac and Ward Creek.
The LSU Hilltop Arboretum is a 14-acre museum showcasing an extensive collection of Louisiana native trees and shrubs. It includes a with an elevated wooden and through more than 150 species of Southern native trees, shrubs and wildflowers. A new feature is a wildflower meadow with an earthen amphitheater. A historic marker near the pond helps to identify the route of pioneering Philadelphia naturalist William Bartram through eight southern states, including Louisiana.

Education

Background

The area's population had increased enough by 1888 to merit a one-room schoolhouse that was named Rosedale School. A second school opened in 1910 called Jones Creek School. In 1911 the two schools were merged, forming Seventh Ward School—which was renamed Woodlawn High School in 1949 and then rebuilt under the same name in Old Jefferson in 2003.
In the St. George area, the East Baton Rouge Parish School System operates six public schools:
In addition, three private schools located in the St. George area provide secondary education through the twelfth grade:
The East Baton Rouge Parish Public School system is planning to spend up to $100 million to build as many as three new schools in the southern part of the parish. However, school officials indicate that a suitable school site in the St. George area may prove difficult to find.

Proposed school district

The incorporation effort for St. George began with a goal of creating a new school district independent of the East Baton Rouge Parish School System.
To form a new school district, however, the new city must first be established. So a new school district was not on the petition or ballot for the formation of the City of St. George.
The process for establishing a new school district in the St. George area would require several steps:
All of these steps would need to occur before a new school district could be formed.

Student population

A 2017 U.S. Census survey concluded that there were more than 16,300 children in St. George census tracts, 7,700 of whom attended private schools. Although the proposed school district boundaries and current city limits ultimately may not completely overlap, it appears that 44% of the public school students within the new school district would be black, 35% white, 10% Asian American, and 10% Hispanic under current trends.
Creating a new school district could potentially lead to the transfer of more than 3,000 students into or out of St. George.
As of March 2018, approximately 5,237 students live in the proposed school district. Of these, approximately 2,779 students attend schools in the proposed St. George school district. But some of the students in the proposed school district attend schools outside of St. George. They include 1,328 students who attend magnet schools and another 568 students who attend gifted and talented programs. Because they reside in St. George, these students would have to leave their current school and transfer to a school in St. George.
Conversely, approximately 1,374 students live outside of St. George but attend school there. These students would likewise have to leave their current school in St. George and attend school elsewhere.
A cooperative agreement between the East Baton Rouge Parish School System and the St. George school system could address this concern and allow students to attend school in either district.

Informal education

Facilities in the St. George area that provide opportunities for informal education include:
*
*
Community Press, LLC published the St. George Leader, a community newspaper edited by longtime journalist and former Louisiana state representative Woody Jenkins.
The St. George Leader began publication on October 2, 2019. Approximately 25,000 households in the proposed City of St. George were mailed the first edition of the paper and additional copies delivered to about 70 stores in the area. In November 2019, the publication claimed an online circulation of 30,000. The newspaper appears to have ceased publication with the November 2019 issue.
The production facilities and business offices of The Advocate, the state's largest daily newspaper, are located in the Census-Designated Place of St. George. The newspaper serves the southern part of the state, including Baton Rouge as well as Lafayette and the Acadiana area with a separate edition for New Orleans.
The broadcast studios of television stations WVLA NBC Channel 33 and WGMB Fox Channel 44 are also located in St. George

Transportation

There are no East-West roads that run through the entire duration of the proposed city limits. However, Interstate 10, U.S. Route 61, and the Old Jefferson Highway pass through the center of St. George in a North–South direction. The CDP of Old Jefferson is named for its proximity to the old Jefferson Highway.
The Capital Area Transit System has only a limited presence in the St. George area. Currently the new city has no intentions of expanding CATS' services within the new city limits.
The Canadian National Railway and the Kansas City Southern Railway pass through the eastern and western sections of St. George respectively, in a North–South direction.

Economy

In 1947, voters in East Baton Rouge Parish approved forming a single form of governance in which the City of Baton Rouge and the rural, unincorporated areas of parish would consolidate the functions of local government.
In 1982, voters approved the further consolidation of the City and Parish Councils into a single governing body commonly referred to as the Metro Council. The Mayor-President is thus the mayor of the City of Baton Rouge as well as the President of East Baton Rouge Parish.
In 1947, voters also approved the Plan of Government, which serves as the "Home Rule Charter" or constitution.
In 1950, the metropolitan area of Baton Rouge consisted of East Baton Rouge Parish. In 1973, three parishes were added to the Baton Rouge Metropolitan Statistical Area : Ascension, Livingston, and West Baton Rouge. In 2003, the Baton Rouge MSA was expanded to include five more parishes: East Feliciana, Iberville, Pointe Coupee, St. Helena, and West Feliciana.
The economy of the St. George area is thus an integral part of the Baton Rouge economy, the East Baton Rouge Parish economy and the Baton Rouge MSA.

Notable people

Living

Prominent living individuals associated with the community of St. George include:
Prominent deceased individuals associated with the community of St. George include:
Historical figures associated with the community of St. George include: