The church is medieval but was heavily restored between 1855 and 1857 and given a stucco rendering in imitation of ashlar. The church had been described somewhat cryptically as "dove house topped", but obtained its present brick tower at the time of the church's restoration. It contains two bells, and a modern clock installed in 1969, in memory of William Noël and Hilda Grace Parr, formerly of the Old Rectory, who both died in 1967. Remains of medieval stonework can be seen inside on the south side of the nave, including the arches which originally divided it from a south aisle that was demolished. The chancel is narrower. The wooden altar rails are Jacobean. The stained glass in the window at the east end of the church shows St Paul preaching to the Athenians with an inscription: "WHOM THEREFORE YE IGNORANTLY WORSHIP HIM I DECLARE VNTO YVO / IN LOVING MEMORY OF ROBERT WEATHERELL RECTOR OF ELTON FROM 1863 TO 1883". There are arched panels over the chancel door bearing the words of the Ten Commandments and of the Lord's Prayer. These may antedate the restoration. The modern oak pews were a gift in the 1950s from W. G. Player of Whatton Manor, who is buried in the south-east corner of the churchyard. The oak panels were donated by W. Noël Parr. Hanging in the nave is a detailed architectural description of the church compiled or copied by a churchwarden in the 1960s. It reads, in part: There are other tablets in the church to Frances Launder, W. F. N. Norton, Ursula Norton, Sarah Norton and Langford Collin, all of Elton Manor; also to Amy, wife of R. F. Pinder of Elton Rectory, and to Charles Gordon Mackie and his wife Margaret Georgina of Elton Old Rectory. There are many interesting gravestones in the churchyard, including the Launder tomb, which has received a Grade II heritage listing. Others are described on the Elton on the Hill page.
Parish status
The rectory of Elton was held jointly with the vicarage of Granby from 1917, when Cecil Richard Storr, already vicar of Granby, became rector. The advowson of Elton was presented to the Bishop of Southwell by W. N. Parr when he left the village in 1957. On the retirement of Rev. J. Pickworth-Hutchinson, Elton parish was invited by the Bishop to join the Wiverton group of parishes, which comprises:
The vicar of the group parish was Rev. Colin Perkins initially, then Rev. Andrew Wigram from 1995, and from 15 January 2006 Rev. Bronwen Gamble, who lives with her family in Cropwell Bishop. The post is now vacant.
