Nanticoke was born on the Six Nations Reservation in Ontario. From an early age, he was taught to play lacrosse by his brother, Chancey Hill, who is 10 years older than him. Hill taught Nanticoke many nontraditional moves and shots that Nantichoke incorporated into his game. Early on, he was scouted and recruited to the IMG Academy in Bradenton, Florida, where he became one of the team's standout players. In 2016 he committed to play for the University at Albany. Nanticoke was considered the number one recruit in 2017 for college lacrosse.
College career
Nanticoke initially did not consider going to college to play lacrosse, but after encouragement from his mother, Catherine, He chose to play at the University of Albany, as he was drawn to the attack minded playing style of coach Scott Marr. Nanticoke finished his first season at Albany with 49 goals and 32 assists in 2018. The following fall semester, Nanticoke did not take part in the lacrosse team, as he was not enrolled in the university. According to head coach Marr, Nanticoke had stayed home due to 'personal reasons', although he added that he expected Nanticoke to rejoin the team for the Spring 2019 season.
Nanticoke is known as an extremely skillful and talented player. He gained popularity online, even in his highschool days for his moves and trick shots. In 2017, he made ESPN's top ten plays for a one handed behind the back and between the legs goals while at IMG Academy. He is also known as an extremely physical player. He weighs more than 200 pounds and is often capable of outmuscling opposing defenses. At times, Nanticoke had been criticized for overly physical play and taking cheap shots at opponents, with his cross-checking penalty in the third period described as one of the turning points in UAlbany's quarterfinal defeat to Yale in the 2018 championship.
Personal life
He is a member of the Mohawk Nation. He was one of eight Native Americans on the Albany roster for the 2018 season. Nanticoke comes from a deeply political and cultural family with many of his grandparents being faith keepers, or stewards of culture, language, and tradition in Mohawk society. His grandfather took part in the protests at Wounded Knee, South Dakota. His mother spent a year of her childhood summer at the Occupation of Alcatraz. Nanticoke is profoundly influenced by his cultural heritage as he refuses to cut his hair, believes in the spiritual qualities of lacrosse or the "Medicine Game", is a practitioner of the Longhouse Religion, and is fluent in Mohawk.
