The Allmusic review by Stephen Cook awarded the album 4½ stars and stated "J.J. Johnson's Blue Note sides from the first half of the '50s represent some of the best bop of the day. And for listeners interested in just picking up one of the trombonist's early dates, this second installment of his Eminent J.J. Johnson series is the one to get... a bop classic". The Penguin Guide to Jazz included both reissue volumes of The Eminent Jay Jay Johnson in its "Core Collection," and assigned its "crown" accolade, along with a four-star rating, to both albums.
Release history
This album was originally released as the second of three Jay Jay Johnson albums in Blue Note's 10-inch Modern Jazz5000 Series. The previous 10 inch LP release was BLP 5028, Jay Jay Johnson with Clifford Brown and the third 10-inch LP release was BLP 5070, The Eminent Jay Jay Johnson, Vol. 3. When reissued in 1955 as part of Blue Note's 12-inch 1500 series of LPs, the tracks from the three 10 inch releases were spread across two compilation albums, The Eminent Jay Jay Johnson, Volume 1 and The Eminent Jay Jay Johnson, Volume 2. The 12 inch...Volume 1 compilation included 10 of the original 12 tracks from the first two 10 inch albums while the 12 inch ...Volume 2 release included all 6 tracks from the 10 inch ...Vol. 3 album and one track each from the first two 10 inch albums - together with two 'alternate take' bonus tracks from the 1953 ...with Clifford Brownrecording session. The CD...Volume 1 and ...Volume 2 releases re-shuffled the previous material again and included additional 'alternate takes' as bonus tracks from the original 1953 and 1955 recording sessions.
Track listing
1954 BLP 5057 - The Eminent Jay Jay Johnson, Vol. 2:
"Jay" – 3:42
"Time After Time" – 4:13
"Old Devil Moon" – 3:52
"Too Marvelous for Words" – 3:35
"It's You or No One" – 4:06
"Coffee Pot" – 4:08
1955 BLP 1506 - The Eminent Jay Jay Johnson, Volume 2:
"'Daylie' Double" – 4:27
"Pennies from Heaven" – 4:18
"You're Mine, You" – 3:07
"Turnpike" – 4:10
"It Could Happen To You" – 4:42
"Groovin'" – 4:40
"Portrait of Jennie" – 2:56
"Viscosity" – 4:21
"Time After Time" – 4:13
"Capri" – 3:47
2001 UPC 724353214425 - The Eminent Jay Jay Johnson, Volume 2:
"Too Marvelous for Words" – 3:35
"Jay" – 3:42
"Old Devil Moon" – 3:52
"It's You or No One" – 4:06
"Time After Time" – 4:13
"Coffee Pot" – 4:08
"Pennies from Heaven – 4:18
"Viscosity" – 4:21
"You're Mine, You" – 3:07
"Daylie Double" – 4:27
"Groovin'" – 4:40
"Portrait of Jennie" – 2:56
"Pennies from Heaven" – 4:25
"Viscosity" – 4:21
"'Daylie Double'" – 4:38
The 1989/1997 Blue Note CD releases contain the same tracks as the 2001 CD, arranged chronologically by recording session date.