The Upsides is a part of a trilogy that dealt with vocalist Dan Campbell's struggles of being scared, loneliness and feeling lost. As vocalist and lyricist Dan "Soupy" Campbell explains on the album's vinyl release, The Upsides is about fighting back. He began writing the album on early morning bike rides, compiling lines in a notebook for an album that was intended to be about how he had given up. Although it seemed the members of the band had been beaten into misery in their early 20s, as Campbell was riding his bike down past the fountain at "Logan Circle" one day he noticed it had been switched on. This triggered a realization for him, and he decided that it wasn't okay to be so defeated at 23. After a month of writing with the band living in his home, they emerged with a newly adopted 'we're not sad anymore' philosophy. Whilst the lyrics have been referred to as "more personal than ever", the band hasn't shied too far away from the humor on their previous releases, with topics mentioned including sexting, cock-blocking, and fist pumping. The lyrics also venture into different themes in each song, from the loneliness of tour life, to social awkwardness and persevering through bad times. Allmusic's review said The Upsides has a concept album-like feel and is filled with "post-college angst, busted hearts, big questions, hope, anger, humor, and life". Continuing to say the songs fit together like an intricate puzzle, flowing like it was an entire diary's worth of observations, feelings and events. Campbell said "when the record came out, I was not in the best spot." He had just broken up with his girlfriend of two years, but still felt "the prevailing theme kind of worked because while I was kind of down at the moment, it was a different down than I had been before. Like in the past, I’ve been depressed, and just kind of been complacent, and ok with it, but this was a different sad. This was a sad where I was mourning what I didn’t have anymore, with the girl I was dating and a couple other things, but it wasn’t hopeless. I knew things were going to get better, and it was just a matter of waiting it out." They later recorded bonus tracks for The Upsides, and one of the songs was about the situation he found himself in upon the album's release.
Release and promotion
The Upsides sold 1,845 units in its first week, charting at number nine on the BillboardTop Heatseekers and 42 on the Top Independent Albums charts. Following the success of the album's release, The Wonder Years announced in May 2010 that they had signed with Hopeless Records.
Deluxe edition re-release
The band released a deluxe reissue of The Upsides through their new label Hopeless Records. The reissue included four extra tracks, two of which had not been heard before. "I Was Scared and I'm Sorry" was written about a break-up and everything changing in Soupy's life. "We Won't Bury You" was written for a friend of the band who was in rehab, he died of an overdose before ever hearing the song. The first of the reworked songs was a fun take on "Dynamite Shovel"; "Recorded live in one room with a bunch of mics everywhere, this finds us stomping and clapping and yelling and laughing". The final track is a completely reworked "slowed down, piano-based version" of the song "Logan Circle", said to be "completely reminiscent of the song it actually is, but it's different lyrics different structure". In October 2015, the band announced another reissue of the album, due for release on December 18. This time it features new artwork and all of the bonus tracks made available with the previous deluxe edition of the album, in addition to "Leavenhouse. 11:30.".
Reception
said the "bleeding humanity" of the band and how Campbell "sounds like a regular guy, not a rock & roll frontman" help The Upsides bring "a time-honored sound" and "make it sound fresh and exciting by doing it seriously right". Reviewer Tim Sendra complimented the duelling riffs of guitarists Matt Brasch and Casey Cavaliere, Mike Kennedy's drum work and how Nick Steinborn adds the occasional unobtrusive keyboard part - "They simply take the best of each element of their conglomerated sound and let it rip." The album was included at number 24 on Rock Sounds "The 51 Most Essential Pop Punk Albums of All Time" list.
Guest vocals on "All My Friends Are in Bar Bands" — Shane Henderson, Dave Mackinder, Matty Arsenault, Jamie Rhoden, Nik Bruzzese, Charlie Saxton and Nick O'Neill
