In 2009, the curriculum was revised under president William Fahey in an effort to improve its chronological approach to topics and strengthen the presentation of Catholic themes. Distinct majors in literature, political science, and philosophy were phased out in favor of a non-major liberal arts program. In the same year regional accrediting body the New England Association of Schools and Colleges placed the college on probation for two years on the ground that it was not meeting NEASC's standards for financial resources. The college improved its financial position, and the period of probation ended in 2011. In 2011, the college announced its intention to move to a larger tract of land in Groton, Massachusetts, keeping the campus in Merrimack as a site for future graduate programs. In late 2013, the college bought a 1908 mansion in the Nashville Historic District of Nashua. College president William Fahey indicated plans to use the historic house, originally built by shoe manufacturer Frank Anderson and later the home of Mount Saint Mary Seminary, a girls' high school, as an educational site and eventually also a dormitory. The relocation plan to Groton was consequently abandoned in August 2015, after the college acquired the Anderson House, due to concerns about the time and fundraising needed in order to develop the property in Groton.
Presidents
Peter V. Sampo, 1978-2006
Jeffrey Nelson, 2006-2009
William Fahey, 2009-current
Academics
The academic program at Thomas More College leads to a B.A. degree in Liberal Arts without a major concentration. The core curriculum is a Great Books program. Students read great works of Western literature, philosophy, and political science in their entirety rather than as a collection of excerpts. Students are also required to study a semester in Rome; this is done in the second semester of sophomore year. In 2010, the college started a program of teaching students practical skills in art and music, using the medieval guild system as a model. The college is accredited by the New England Association of Schools and Colleges. For admissions to the college, Thomas More College accepts the Classic Learning Test as alternatives to the SAT and ACT.
The college has sponsored the Centre for Faith and Culture at Oxford, England, publisher of Second Spring, a journal on faith and culture, since 2007. In April 2011, Thomas More College, together with Holy Spirit College in Atlanta, reached an agreement with the non-profit publisher Sophia Institute Press, which became the publishing division of the two colleges. The two colleges, in turn, appoint representatives to the board of directors of Sophia Institute.