At Princeton Trevor Tierney was awarded the 2001 Ensign C. Markland Kelly, Jr. Award as the best National Collegiate Athletic Association lacrosse goaltender. He was a first team USILA All-American Team selection in 2001 and honorable mention selection in 2000. Trevor was also a 2000 honorable mention All-Ivy League selection, 2001 first team All-Ivy selection, 2000 Academic All-Ivy selection, and a 2001 USILA Scholar All-American. He served as co-captain of the 2001 team. Tierney was the 2001 national statistical champion for goals against average and save percentage. He held NCAA the career and single season GAA record from 2001 until they were both surpassesd in 2006 by Navy'sMatt Russell. His career GAA continues to be a Princeton record. During his four-year career, Princeton went undefeated in Ivy League Conference play with consecutive 6-0 records. Princeton was invited to the 1999 tournament, was a finalist in the 2000 tournament and earned championships in both the 1998 and 2001 tournaments, bringing the schools consecutive tournament invitations streak to twelve. As a freshman playing for his father's team, Trevor Tierney was able to get playing time during the 1998 regular season because Princeton was winning their games by a large margin. In the 1998 NCAA championship quarterfinals, he came in as a substitute with his team behind by four goals and shut out Duke for 32 minutes as Princeton rallied for an 11- 9 victory. This led to a minor controversy over who would start for the remaining tournament games. Corey Popham ended up playing and earning NCAA TournamentMost Outstanding Player. In the semifinals of the 2000 NCAA championship, Trevor made 14 saves as his younger brother Brendan Tierney scored two fourth quarter goals to lead Princeton to a 12-11 victory over Virginia. In 2001, Trevor was one of five finalists for the Tewaaraton Trophy as the outstanding male player in college lacrosse. In the 2001 semifinal 12-11 victory over Towson State, he made game-saving last-minute point-blank saves to secure the victory.
Professional career
Tierney was drafted by the New Jersey Pride with the second overall selection in the 2001 MLL Draft. He played with the Pride from 2001 until 2004 when he was traded to the Boston Cannons. He also played in the NLL with the Colorado Mammoth in 2003. In MLL, he was traded to the Baltimore Bayhawks, where he earned his first Major League Lacrosse All-Star Game selection in 2005 and a MLL Championship. In 2006, Tierney was part of what is believed to have been the largest trade in professional sports, involving 6 teams and 24 players when he was traded from the Bayhawks to the Denver Outlaws. He earned two more All-Star selections in 2006 and 2007 with the Outlaws, before becoming their defensive coordinator in 2008. Tierney retired from active play due to a series of concussions. The final career-ending concussion occurred during warm-ups on June 16, 2007 against the Rochester Rattlers. Trevor Tierney represented Team USA at the 2002 and 2006 World Lacrosse Championships earning a gold and silver medal, respectively. On the 2006 team, he was one of four Princeton athletes. At the 2002 World Championship, he was selected as the tournament's All-World goaltender. In the semifinal match that year Trevor made seven first half saves as Team USA built a 9-2 lead over the Iroquois Nationals. He was nominated as a finalist for MLL's first All-decade team in celebration of the first ten years of the league. Trevor is the only goalie to have won a NCAA Men's Lacrosse Championship, an International Lacrosse FederationWorld Lacrosse Championship and a Major League Lacrosse Steinfeld Cup Championship. In 2010, Trevor Tierney joined his father's coaching staff for the Denver Pioneers as the defensive assistant coach and yoga instructor. He left his position with the Outlaws to concentrate on his role on his father's staff.
Personal
Trevor Tierney is the son of Helen and Bill Tierney and is the oldest of their four children. He is from an athletic family. In addition to his Hall of Fame father, all of his siblings are athletes and coaches. Brendan was a teammate on the 2001 championship team at Princeton. His sister Courtney Tierney, a former Franklin & Marshallbasketball player, is the head girls' basketball coach at Pennington Prep. Brianne Tierney, who played lacrosse at Loyola University Maryland and Colgate University, is the head women's lacrosse coach at Kent State University, which will begin varsity play in the 2019 season. In 2019, he received a masters degree from Harvard Extension School.