editor Thom Jurek called it a "ubiquitous" hit. Jennifer Bowles from Associated Press described the song as a "more upbeat, mocking tune". Larry Flick from Billboard wrote that it is a "study in stylistic contrasts; retro-soul vocal musing glides atop a pristine, keyboard-and string-anchored modern-pop environment." He noted that it is a "sophisticated, complex respite from the color-by-numbers fare that crowds radio airwaves." Stephanie Zacharek from Entertainment Weekly said that "the jaunty, Caribbean-flavored "Walking on Broken Glass" is laden with sharp-edged metaphors for broken love affairs." HuffPost wrote that Lennox "rolls out its words Joan Armatrading-style, proclaiming, "Every one of us is made to suffer, every one of us is made to weep." Then, almost to prove the opposite point, she happily gavottes with the groove." Los Angeles Times said it was "the highlight of this solo debut album and one of the best tunes she’s ever had." Kjell Moe from Nordlys stated that the song has "clear Kate Bush-references". Pop Rescue noted it as a "pretty catchy track", adding that Lennox' vocals and the backing vocals all "shine perfectly".
Music video
Directed by Sophie Muller, the music video is based in part on the 1988 filmDangerous Liaisons, and on period films dealing with the late 18th century, such as Amadeus. John Malkovich, who starred in the former film, is joined by Hugh Laurie, in garb similar to the 18th century dress he wore to play Prince George, The Prince Regent from Blackadder the Third. The setting of the video is that of a salon evening at Prince George'sCarlton House, and is meant to represent an assembly of nobles and notables for an evening of society, gambling and dancing, the highlight of which is the arrival and feting of the newlyweds, the groom is played by Malkovich. Lennox's character is striking in her somewhat unusual dress, and in wearing a 'Turkish' headdress hat in an environment dominated by wigs of the period. Lennox's character displays significant pique, as she is emotionally wounded by the appearance of her former lover on the arm of his new bride. Throughout the video, she tries to communicate the conflicting emotions of jealousy, continued desire, and anger towards this man who still clearly holds her heart. In the process, she spurns the previously welcome advances of the Prince Regent, and repels him, to his embarrassment. Lennox's character consumes glass after glass of champagne and grows ever more agitated, until she finally throws herself at Malkovich's character, to the shock and amusement of the partygoers. Lennox's character, furious and realizing that she has made a fool of herself, flees the party, only to be swept into Malkovich's arms when she reaches the foot of the stairs.
Track listings
CD single Tracks 2-5 were recorded for MTV Unplugged in July 1992. UK CD single
