What Was I Thinking

Track listing

1. "Alone" – 4:59
2. "Felt" – 3:11
3. "Mothman" – 4:05
4. "Crawl Away" – 5:21
5. "One Drop" – 4:08
6. "Stronghold" – 4:38
7. "Praze You Lord" – 3:46
8. "Presence" - 1:11
9. "Sorry" – 4:37
10. "Take Me" – 4:11
11. "Why" – 4:32
12. "Jeckyl & Hyde" – 4:18
13. "Amazing Grace Blues" – 4:00
14. "Going Home" – 3:46
15. "Mercy" – 4:13

    Trivia

• The album begins with the song "Won't You Be My Neighbor?" made popular by Fred Rogers on his children's television show Mister Rogers' Neighborhood.