The Crystals suffered three straight defeats to open the season. After this, they decided independently to merge with the Montreal Shamrocks. On February 2, this new team defeated Quebec 2–1. The game was protested by Quebec and the result was cancelled and not replayed. Another game involving Quebec was noteworthy, on February 23 against Ottawa, won by Ottawa 3–2. The game, played at Quebec, was very rough and the crowd became hostile towards the visitors. At the end of the match, the crowd pursued referee Hamilton and Umpire Findlay as they left the arena, and dragged them back to force them to declare the game a draw. Police were called to break up the demonstration. Subsequent to the match, the AHAC decided to suspend the Quebec hockey club for the rest of the season.
† Game void following protest by Quebec over Crystals use of ineligible players. †† Quebec team suspended after attack on officials after game of February 23. ††† Victorias clinch league championship.
Note: Although A. Mcdougall is recorded in most hockey sources as to playing goal for the Montreal Victorias on January 12, 1895, and allowing one goal only, primary sourcing can show that Hartland MacDougall actually played goal for the Vics between January 12 and January 26 before being replaced by Robert Jones.
Leading scorers
; Source: Coleman pp. 22–24.
Stanley Cup challenges
Montreal vs. Queen's
On March 8, 1895, the Montreal Victorias won the 1895 AHAC title, finishing the season with a 6–2 record. Under the Stanley Cup rules, the team would also be awarded the Stanley Cup as league champions. However, the trustees ruled that a challenge between the previous year's champion Montreal HC and the squad from Queen's University, the champions of the Ontario Hockey Association, would have to be played first to determine if the Cup remained with the AHAC. Thus, it was decided that if the Montreal HC won the challenge match, the Victorias would become the Stanley Cup champions. The Montreal HC would eventually win the game, 5–1, and their crosstown rivals were crowned the champions. Billy Barlow, the star player of Montreal was not able to play and Clarence McKerrow took his place. McKerrow had not played any games for Montreal, and could be considered a ringer, but there was no protest from Queen's. The Queen's team, although described as looking fast in their tiger jerseys, were no match for Montreal and the game proved uninteresting. R. McLennan of Queen's would later play for Dawson City in its 1905 challenge of Ottawa. Queen's U at Montreal
Queens U.
at
Montreal
R.C. Hiscock
G
Herbert Collins
Guy Curtis
P
Frank Bickerdike
Fen Taylor,
CP
Allan Cameron
A.B. Cunningham
F
Clarence Mussen
1
George McKay
1
F
Clarence McKerrow
1
Randy McLennan
F
Haviland Routh
2
G.F. Weatherhead
F
Archie Hodgson
1
;Source: Coleman pp. 24–25
Montreal Hockey Club Stanley Cup 1895 challenge champions
While the Montreal Hockey Club won its challenge 5–1, it was not presented with the Stanley Cup.
Montreal Victorias 1895 Stanley Cup champions
note: Jim Fenwick would leave the team at the end of the season.
Some sources say A. MacDougall, and Hartland MacDougall each played the one game in goal. There no official records of an A. MacDougall ever playing hockey for the Montreal Victorias. So it was most likely that Hartland played both games, and an H just looked like an A.
