BR Standard Class 9F
The British Railways BR Standard Class 9F 2-10-0 is a class of steam locomotive designed for British Railways by Robert Riddles. The Class 9F was the last in a series of standardised locomotive classes designed for British Railways during the 1950s, and was intended for use on fast, heavy freight trains over long distances. It was one of the most powerful steam locomotive types ever built for British Railways, and successfully performed its intended duties. The class was given the nickname of 'Spaceships', due to its size and shape. In profile, daylight can be seen between the frames and the boiler.
At various times during the 1950s, the 9Fs worked passenger trains with great success, indicating the versatility of the design, sometimes considered to represent the ultimate in British steam development. Several experimental variants were constructed in an effort to reduce costs and maintenance, although these met with varying degrees of success.
The total number built was 251, production being shared between Swindon and Crewe Works. The last of the class, 92220 Evening Star, was the final steam locomotive to be built by British Railways, in 1960. Withdrawals of the class began in 1964, with the final locomotives being withdrawn from service in 1968, the final year of steam traction on British Railways. Several examples have survived into the preservation era in varying states of repair, including Evening Star.
Background
The British Transport Commission had proposed that the existing steam locomotive fleet be replaced by both diesel and electric traction. However the board of British Railways, which wanted the railways to be completely electrified, ignored the BTC and ordered a new fleet of 'standard' steam locomotive designs as an interim motive power solution ahead of electrification. Freight was well catered for in terms of locomotive availability after nationalisation in 1948, with a number of heavy freight locomotives built to aid the war effort forming part of British Railways' inheritance. This consisted of 666 LMS 8F class 2-8-0 and numerous Robert Riddles designed WD Austerity 2-8-0s and WD Austerity 2-10-0s.It was the Eastern Region's Motive Power officer, L.P. Parker, who made the case for a new design of powerful freight locomotive, able to shift heavy loads at fast speeds in round trips between distant destinations within the eight-hour shift of the footplate crew. Riddles took up the challenge, initially designing a 2-8-2 locomotive, but settled upon the 2-10-0 wheel arrangement for the increased traction and lower axle load that five coupled axles can provide. The resultant design became one of the most successful, but shortest-lived, locomotive classes ever built in Britain.
Design features
The 9F was designed at both Derby and Brighton Works in 1951 to operate freight trains of up to 900 tons at 35 mph with maximum fuel efficiency. The original proposal was for a boiler from the BR Standard Class 7 Britannia 4-6-2, adapting it to a 2-8-2 wheel arrangement but Riddles eventually settled upon a 2-10-0 type because it had been used successfully on some of his previous Austerity locomotives. Distributing the adhesive weight over five axles gave a maximum axle load of only 15 tons, 10 cwt. The driving wheels were in diameter. However, in order to clear the rear coupled wheels, the grate had to be set higher, thus reducing firebox volume. There were many problems associated with locomotives of such a long wheelbase, but these were solved by the design team through a series of compromises. The centre driving wheels had no flanges, and those on the second and fourth coupled wheels were reduced in depth. This enabled the locomotive to round curves of only radius. As on all other BR standard steam locomotives, the leading wheels were in diameter.Construction history
Introduced in January 1954, the class comprised 251 locomotives, of which 53 were constructed at Swindon Works, and 198 at Crewe Works. The locomotives were numbered 92000-92250. The last member of the class was constructed at Swindon in 1960, the 999th "BR Standard" to be constructed, and the last steam locomotive to be built by British Railways. To mark the occasion, a competition was run within the Western Region of British Railways to choose an apt name, and the locomotive was given the name and number of 92220 Evening Star. Many of the class lasted only a few years in service before withdrawal when steam traction ended on the mainline in Britain. Withdrawals of the class from everyday service began in May 1964, and had been completed by June 1968.| Numbers | Year | Builder | Tender | Notes |
| 92000–09 | 1954 | Crewe | BR1G | 8 for WR, 2 for LMR |
| 92010–14 | 1954 | Crewe | BR1F | for ER |
| 92015–19 | 1954 | Crewe | BR1C | for LMR |
| 92020-29 | 1955 | Crewe | BR1B | Franco-Crosti boiler; for LMR |
| 92030–44 | 1954 | Crewe | BR1F | for ER |
| 92045–59 | 1955 | Crewe | BR1C | for LMR |
| 92060–66 | 1955 | Crewe | BR1B | for NER |
| 92067–76 | 1956 | Crewe | BR1F | for ER |
| 92077–86 | 1956 | Crewe | BR1C | for LMR |
| 92087–96 | 1957 | Crewe | BR1F | for ER |
| 92097–99 | 1956 | Crewe | BR1B | for NER |
| 92100–18 | 1956 | Crewe | BR1C | for LMR |
| 92119–39 | 1957 | Crewe | BR1C | for LMR |
| 92140–49 | 1957 | Crewe | BR1F | for ER |
| 92150–64 | 1958 | Crewe | BR1C | for LMR |
| 92165–67 | 1958 | Crewe | BR1K | for LMR; tenders later BR1C |
| 92168–77 | 1958 | Crewe | BR1F | for ER |
| 92178–83 | 1957 | Swindon | BR1F | for ER |
| 92184–202 | 1958 | Swindon | BR1F | for ER |
| 92203–17 | 1959 | Swindon | BR1G | for WR |
| 92218–20 | 1960 | Swindon | BR1G | for WR |
| 92221–50 | 1958 | Swindon | BR1G | for WR |
Variations
The 9F was used as a proving ground for a variety of technical innovations intended to provide improvements in efficiency, power or cost.Franco-Crosti boiler
Ten locomotives were built in 1955 with the Franco-Crosti boiler. which incorporated a combustion gas feed water preheater that recuperated low-grade residual heat. In the 9F version, this took the form of a single cylindrical water drum running along the underside of the main boiler barrel. The standard chimney on top of the smokebox was only used during lighting up. In normal working the gases went through firetubes inside the preheater drum that led to a second smokebox situated beneath the boiler from which there emerged a chimney on the right-hand side, just forward of the firebox. In the event, the experiment did not deliver the hoped-for benefits, and efficiency was not increased sufficiently to justify the cost and complexity. Moreover, conditions were unpleasant on the footplate in a cross-wind, this in spite of the later provision of a small deflector plate forward of the chimney. These problems led to the subsequent removal of the preheater drum, although the locomotives did retain the original main smokebox with its distinctive look.Mechanical stoker and blastpipe variation
Locomotive numbers 92165–92167 were built with a mechanical stoker, which was a helical screw that conveyed coal from the tender to the firebox, where it would be directed to the required part of the :wikt:grate|grate by high-pressure steam jets controlled by the fireman. The stoker made higher steaming rates possible, and it was hoped that mechanical stoking might enable the burning of low-grade coal. It was relatively inefficient, and the locomotives used in this trial were rebuilt to the normal configuration. Simply supplying more low grade coal than a fireman could do by hand did not provide efficient burning. Trials found that the maximum coal delivery rate of the mechanical stoker was slightly faster than firing by hand, and it could maintain that maximum for hours at a time when a fireman would tire. However, that was of little practical benefit in actual service, because even a long-distance freight train would frequently stop to allow faster trains to pass or would be held at signals. For the short periods when maximum firing rate was needed, a skilled fireman was more than sufficient. The success of mechanical stokers on North American railroads was mainly because the locomotives were significantly larger and many routes required hours of supplying coal at a rate beyond the physical limit of a single fireman.Number 92250 was equipped with a Giesl ejector, which divided the exhaust steam between seven nozzles arranged in a row on the locomotive's longitudinal axis, and directed into a narrow fan-shaped ejector that more intimately mixed it with the smokebox gases than is the case of an ordinary chimney. That offered the same level of draught for a reduced level of exhaust back-pressure or, alternatively, increased draught with no performance loss elsewhere. Again, great claims were made about the potential benefits, and 92250 retained the variant chimney until withdrawal, although no benefit was noticeable.
The only modification which did deliver any noticeable benefit was the fitting of 92178 with a double blastpipe and chimney during its construction. Following delivery in September 1957, it was subjected to extensive testing, both in the Rugby test plant and on service trains. After the completion of the tests in February 1958, it was decided to fit all 9Fs built subsequently with double blastpipes and chimneys — they were numbers 92183 onwards, as well as 92165–7. The modification was also installed on 92000/1/2/5 and 92006. That allowed the engines to steam slightly more freely and thus generate higher power ranges.
Operational details
The 9F turned out to be the best of the Standard classes, and one of the finest steam locomotives ever designed in Britain in terms of its capacity to haul heavy loads over long distances. It was highly effective at its designed purpose, hauling heavy, fast freight trains, and was used all over the British railway network. This was exemplified when in September 1982, preserved engine 92203 Black Prince set the record for the heaviest train ever hauled by a steam locomotive in Britain, when it started a 2,178-ton train at a Foster Yeoman quarry in Somerset, UK.The 9F also proved its worth as a passenger locomotive, adept at fast running despite its small driving wheels, and for a time was a frequent sight on the Somerset and Dorset Railway, where its power and high proportion of adhesive weight were well suited to coping with the 1 in 50 ruling gradient on the Bath extension. On one occasion, a 9F was set to haul an express passenger train, in place of the normal LNER pacific, from Grantham to King's Cross. An enthusiast aboard the train timed the run and noted that twice the speed exceeded 90 mph. The driver was afterwards told that he was only supposed to keep time, "not break the bloody sound barrier!". He replied that the engine had no speedometer, and that it ran so smoothly at high speeds that he just let it run as fast as felt safe. Nor was this the only instance of 9Fs reaching high speeds. However, concerns that the high rotational speeds involved in fast running could cause excessive wear and tear to the plain-bearing running gear prompted the British Railways management to stop using 9Fs on express passenger trains
In 1960, 9Fs from the Western Region's Cardiff Canton shed were also regularly made ready as 'standby' locomotives - in case of failure of the more usual Britannias - on the region's flagship Paddington-Cardiff/Swansea passenger express trains, the Red Dragon and Capitals United Express. Locomotives used on these duties included No. 92220 Evening Star, the only 9F to be given a name and to be painted in the express passenger livery of lined Brunswick green. On 8 September No. 92220 also hauled the last ever Pines Express in 1962.
Like other primarily goods locomotives, British Railways' fleet of 9Fs also saw extensive passenger service in hauling Saturday 'Holiday Specials', especially in the North East and Western regions.
| Year | Quantity in service at start of year | Quantity withdrawn | Locomotive numbers | Notes |
| 1964 | 251 | 16 | 92034/36, 92169–71/75–77/96/98–99, 92207/10/29/32/45. | Numbers 92207 and 92245 are preserved. |
| 1965 | 235 | 65 | 92000/03/05/07/33/37–42/44/57/66, 92140–44/47–49/68/74/78–81/84–95/97, 92200/02/09/14/16/19–22/25–26/30/35–38/40–44/46/48/50. | Evening Star was withdrawn this year. Numbers 92214, 92219, 92220, 92240 are preserved. |
| 1966 | 170 | 46 | 92010/13/28/35/43/53/58–64/67–68/72/75/81/85/92/95/97–99, 92115–16/24/30/34/36/45–46/55/58/61/64/72–73/82–83, 92201/13/17/31/39/47. | Number 92134 is preserved. |
| 1967 | 124 | 106 | 92001–02/06/08/11–12/14–27/29–32/45–52/55–56/65/70–71/73–74/76/78–80/82–84/86–87/89–90/93/96, 92100–14/17/19–23/25–29/31–33/35/37–39/50–52/54/56–57/59/62–63/66, 92203–06/08/11/15/24/27–28/34. | Number 92203 is preserved. |
| 1968 | 18 | 18 | 92004/09/54/69/77/88/91/94, 92118/53/60/65/67, 92212/18/23/33/49. | Number 92212 is preserved. |
Accidents and incidents
- On 19 November 1958, locomotive No. 92187 was hauling a freight train which overran signals and was in a rear-end collision with another at Hitchin, Hertfordshire. A third freight train ran into the wreckage.
- On 7 April 1964, locomotive No. 92161 was hauling a freight train that was derailed at Howe & Co's Signalbox, Cumberland due to a combination of defects on a wagon, excessive speed and minor track defects.
Livery and numbering
Preservation
Nine 9F locomotives survived withdrawal from mainline service: Evening Star became part of the National Collection; eight others were bought directly from BR or from Woodham Brothers scrapyard in Barry, South Wales. Only six members of the class have been restored to running order.| Number & Name | Tender Attached | Builder | Built | Withdrawn | Service life | Location | Livery | Status | Image |
| 92134 | BR1G | Crewe Works | Jun 1957 | Dec 1966 | 9 years, 6 months | North Yorkshire Moors Railway | BR Black, Late Emblem | Operational. | |
| 92203 'Black Prince' | BR1G | Swindon Works | Apr 1959 | Nov 1967 | 8 years, 7 months | North Norfolk Railway | BR Black, Late Emblem | Operational | |
| 92207 | N/A | Swindon Works | Jun 1959 | Dec 1964 | 5 years, 6 months | Shillingstone Railway Project | N/A | Undergoing Restoration | |
| 92212 | BR1F | Swindon Works | Sep 1959 | Jan 1968 | 8 years, 4 months | Mid Hants Railway | BR Black, Late Emblem | Boiler Ticket Expired 31 December 2019 | |
| 92214 'Leicester City' | BR1G | Swindon Works | Oct 1959 | Sep 1965 | 5 years, 11 months | Great Central Railway | BR Lined Green, Late Emblem | Operational | |
| 92219 | N/A | Swindon Works | Jan 1960 | Sep 1965 | 5 years, 8 months | Wensleydale Railway | N/A | Stored, Awaiting Restoration | |
| 92220 'Evening Star' | BR1G | Swindon Works | Mar 1960 | Mar 1965 | 5 years | National Railway Museum | BR Lined Green, Late Emblem | Static Display | |
| 92240 | BR1B | Crewe Works | Oct 1958 | Sep 1965 | 6 years 11 months | Bluebell Railway | BR Black, Late Emblem | Awaiting Overhaul. Last ran in 2002. | |
| 92245 | N/A | Crewe Works | Nov 1958 | Dec 1964 | 6 years 1 month | Barry Island Railway | N/A | Scrapyard condition, awaiting restoration |
† In most cases, names are not historically accurate; i.e. they have all been applied in preservation except 92220 which, being the last steam locomotive to be built for BR, was named Evening Star during its unveiling in 1960. Some locomotives may also have names, but marked names indicate that the locomotive is not presently wearing them.
Of the nine surviving members of the class, two have run on the main line: nos. 92203 Black Prince & 92220 Evening Star. Due to the engines' flangeless centre driving wheels, there is a concern that the raised check rails on modern pointwork might cause a derailment, so the class is currently prohibited from operating on the main line; this includes the Esk Valley Line from Battersby to Whitby, which is used by the North Yorkshire Moors Railway on their Grosmont to Whitby trains alongside the regular passenger services on the route.
Models
OO gauge
The erstwhile Kitmaster company produced an unpowered polystyrene injection moulded model kit for 00 gauge. In late 1962, the Kitmaster brand was sold by its parent company to Airfix, who transferred the moulding tools to their own factory; they re-introduced some of the former Kitmaster range, including the BR Standard 9F class locomotive. In time, the moulding tools passed on to Dapol who have also produced the model kit. During the 1960s a cast white metal chassis kit in the Simplas range to motorise the model was made available by Wilro Models of Clarence Road, Hackney, London.In late 1971, introduced a 00 gauge Ready to Run model of this locomotive; it continued to be produced after the rebranding as Hornby Railways.
Currently both Hornby and Bachmann produce models of this class in OO Gauge, with the cheaper less detailed Hornby version being part of the budget "Railroad" range. Hornby also released a model of the Thomas & Friends character Murdoch in December 2011. In August 2015, a Franco-Crosti boilered variant was introduced into the Hornby RailRoad range. The Bachmann model covers most variations of the class.