F-X (Japan)
The F-X is a sixth-generation stealth fighter in development for the Japan Air Self-Defense Force. It is Japan's first domestically developed stealth fighter jet and will replace the Mitsubishi F-2 by the mid–2030s. Its development is to also bolster the nation's defense industry and potentially enter the international arms market amid Japan's change in defense posture.
The F-X has been nicknamed the "Godzilla" fighter owing to its large size, as well as a nod to the popular Kaiju.
Development
Origins
The F-X program began when the United States banned exports of the Lockheed Martin F-22 Raptor as part of the 1997 Obey amendment in order to safeguard its technology. With Japan no longer able to purchase the F-22, a domestically developed fighter was chosen instead to replace Japan's ageing fleet of fighter jets. Between December 2009 and August 2010, the Ministry of Defense conducted a study of developing a future fighter jet to replace the F-2. The research conducted called for a new fighter jet that would be a generation ahead of contemporary fifth-generation fighter. The concept fighter was named the i3 Fighter. Some technology and capabilities the concept fighter is to possess include advanced radar systems to counter stealth technology of other fighters, receiving targeting information from other platforms, use of fly-by-optics to process information faster, stealth technology, gallium nitride semiconductors to improve radar performance, and a new, more powerful engine.Mitsubishi X-2 demonstrator
Much of the development of the F-X program correlates with the development of the Mitsubishi X-2 Shinshin. The development of the X-2 demonstrator allows Japan to obtain new information and develop new technology related to their next generation fighter jet. The X-2 made its maiden flight on 22 April 2016. The X-2's testing concluded in March 2018.Continued development and procurement strategy
Aircraft components
Concurrent to the X-2's development and testing, evaluations were made on various researches related to the F-X. These researches and tests continue as Japan sought international collaboration on the F-X.| Evaluation period | Name of evaluation | Development time period | Total cost | Purpose |
| October 2009 | Study on advanced integrated sensor system | Prototype: 2010 - 2014 Testing: 2014 - 2016 | ¥500 million | Detect stealth aircraft using various sensors working in tandem with each other |
| October 2009 | Research on aerodynamic technology for weapon internalization | Prototype: 2010 - 2013 Testing: 2013 - 2014 | ¥1.3 billion | Simulate the separation of internal weapons from weapons bay to study aerodynamic phenomenon acting on the mounted object at transonic and supersonic speed |
| October 2009 | Research on main components of next-generation engine | Prototype: 2010 - 2014 Testing: 2014 - 2015 | ¥100 million | Achieve high thrust-to-weight ratio for next-generation engine by developing high-temperature combustor, high-temperature/high-pressure turbine and light-weight compressor |
| July 2011 - August 2011 | Research on integrated fire control technology for fighters | Prototype: 2012 - 2016 Testing: 2015 - 2017 | ¥9.1 billion | Develop a Network centered battlespace that connects to various assets for numerically inferior stealth aircraft |
| July 2012 - September 2012 | Study on engine elements for fighters | Prototype: 2013 - 2017 Testing: 2015 - 2017 | ¥172 billion | Design high power engine to be slim and possess high thrust |
| July 2012 - September 2012 | Research on weapon release/stealth | Prototype: 2013 - 2017 Testing: 2016 - 2017 | ¥3.8 billion | Develop internal weapons bay to reduce RCS and drag |
| July 2012 - September 2012 | Research on advanced RF self-defense simulation | Prototype: 2013 - 2016 Testing: 2015 - 2018 | ¥1.6 billion | Develop electronic warfare equipment to counter aircraft and missiles |
| July 2013 - August 2013 | Study on high power microwave technology | Prototype: 2014 - 2017 Testing: 2016 - 2018 | ¥1.8 billion | Develop high power microwave technology to neutralize incoming missile |
| July 2013 - August 2013 | Study on high resolution technology of infrared image | Prototype: 2014 - 2017 Testing: 2016 - 2019 | ¥3.8 billion | Enhance resolution of infrared imaging technology for various platforms, i.e. fighter jets |
| July 2013 - August 2013 | Research on airframe structure weight reduction technology | Prototype: 2014 - 2017 Testing: 2017 - 2018 | ¥5.7 billion | Utilize high-precision stress analysis technology to reduce weight of future fighter air-frame and analyze strength risk associated with weight reduction |
| July 2014 - August 2014 | Study on technical feasibility of future fighters | Prototype: 2015 - 2017 Testing: 2016 - 2017 | ¥5.4 billion | Develop virtual vehicle design to determine on whether to develop an F-2 successor |
| July 2014 - August 2014 | Study on engine system for fighter | Prototype: 2015 - 2018 Testing: 2017 - 2019 | ¥14.2 billion | Develop and trial the XF9 engine |
| July 2014 - August 2014 | Study on electric actuation technology | Prototype: 2015 - 2017 Testing: 2018 | ¥2.3 billion | Develop electric actuators to replace conventional hydraulic system |
| July 2014 - August 2014 | Study on radome for stealth fighter | Prototype: 2015 - 2019 Testing: 2018 - 2020 | ¥5.4 billion | Design a radome to protect radar and maximize aerodynamic, stealth and radar performance |
| July 2014 - August 2014 | Study on future HMD system | Prototype: 2015 - 2018 Testing: 2018 - 2019 | ¥3.5 billion | Develop future HMD system with wide field of vision and binocular, multi-color display |
| July 2015 - August 2015 | Study on thrust deflection nozzle | Prototype: 2016 - 2019 Testing: 2017 - 2020 | ¥2.3 billion | Develop thrust deflecting nozzle to achieve high maneuverability, reduce steering area and improve stealth |
| July 2015 - August 2015 | Study on small heat transfer system for future fighters | Prototype: 2016 - 2019 Testing: 2018 - 2020 | ¥1.9 billion | Develop cooling system based on vapor cycle |
In mid-September 2019, flight tests were conducted on integrated sensors to be used for the F-X. The sensors were tested on board an F-2 fighter and the results are said to be good.
F-X program and international collaboration
In March 2017, Japan and U.K. signed an agreement to explore the possibility on co-developing a future fighter jet. By March 2018, a MoD representative has stated that the Japanese government is deciding whether to develop the F-X domestically, through joint-development, or develop it based on an existing fighter design. At the time the Japanese government sent out proposals to the U.S. and U.K., seeking out their participation in the project. Boeing, Lockheed Martin, BAE Systems and Northrop Grumman have responded to the proposal. It is reported that Boeing offered an upgraded fighter based on their F-15, while similarly BAE systems offered their Eurofighter Typhoon. Lockheed Martin proposed a F-22/35 hybrid fighter while also offering Japan the majority of the work in developing and producing the fighter. Northrup Grumman has expressed interest in joining the project; with speculation that a modernized YF-23 might be offered to Japan. Japan and U.K. have also further explored the possibility on collaborating the F-X project with the Tempest project to some capacity.By October 2018, the MoD has begun to rule out the possibility of developing a fighter based on existing designs. Boeing's F-15 and BAE Systems' Eurofighter Typhoon reportedly failed to meet the ministry's requirements. Lockheed Martin's hybridized stealth fighter was also met with doubt due to its expensive price, as well as uncertainties that the U.S. would allow the sale given the export ban on the F-22. One report indicated that the hybrid fighter could cost as high as $177 million per aircraft.
In early February 2019, the MoD announced that a 'Japan-led' Future Fighter program will be initiated, with collaboration with foreign defense contractors still being an option. The announcement further enforces that plans to develop or locally produce existing foreign-made fighter jets has been ruled out. Furthermore, the program will prioritize domestic industries to develop and produce the stealth fighter. The program will occur between 2019–2023 in line with the MoD's Mid-Term Defense Program and will take 15 years to complete; around the time when the F-2 begins to retire. The MoD prioritized five key aspects for the program's development:
- Capability for future air superiority
- Potential to expand capability by incorporating next generation technologies
- Ability to modify and upgrade the new platform
- Participation of Japanese industry
- Affordable cost
On 27 March 2020, Japan rejected designs proposed by Lockheed Martin, Boeing and BAE Systems. The designs submitted by all three defense contractors include: a hybridized F-22/35 fighter, a design based on the Boeing F/A-18E/F Super Hornet, and another based on the Eurofighter Typhoon respectively. According to an official from the Acquisition, Technology & Logistics Agency the designs did not meet their requirements and that no decision has been reached on the air-frame design. The decision places Mitsubishi Heavy Industries at the forefront in developing the stealth fighter. However, the decision did not rule out the possibility of international collaboration; as Lockheed Martin, Boeing, Northrop Grumman and BAE Systems are still listed as potential partners. This decision was further confirmed by Jane's. An ATLA spokesperson has stated that "the option of 'developing derivatives of existing fighters' cannot be a candidate from the perspective of a Japan-led development, and the MoD has come to the conclusion that we will develop a new model". The spokesperson further elaborated the MoD has developed enough technology to possibly develop the F-X domestically, but the option of international collaboration still exists. On 1 April 2020, ATLA established a dedicated team to develop the F-X. The team is led by a major-general from the Japan Air Self-Defense Force and consists of 30 JASDF officers, engineering officials and others. Subaru Corporation also announced that it will establish a Technology Development Center to support the F-X's development.
, the MoD expects production of the first fighter prototype to begin in 2024, with flight tests starting in 2028. Full-scale production is expected to commence by 2031.
Significance and issues
Domestic industry
Within Japan, the development of the X-2 and the F-X is seen as chance for Japan to revitalize its defense/aerospace industry and establish a foothold within the international arms market. In the aftermath following World War II, Japan's defense and aerospace sector was crushed, forcing the nation to enter a long period of rebuilding. As a result, Japan mostly build US made aircraft under license to sustain its industry, while historically struggled to produce their own domestically design aircraft, both civilian and military alike. The F-2 fighter in particular was widely controversial in Japan. First conceived as a 'pure' Japanese fighter, the F-2 was to incorporate the latest technology Japan had to offer and become a sort of spiritual successor to the famous Mitsubishi A6M Zero. However, the decision to joint-develop the aircraft with the US was later chosen due to a combination of US political pressure and the heavy undertaking a producing a fighter domestically. Combined with the delays and lack of profit and growth obtained for Japan's domestic industries, the F-2 went on to become an expensive, controversial fighter. As such, with the introduction of the F-X, Japanese lawmakers and defense officials are adamant in avoiding a repeat of the F-2's controversial development.Domestic development is generally favored the most by defense industry groups and lawmakers but the expected high cost and inexperience developing a domestic fighter are among the biggest challenges faced with domestic development. International collaboration is seen as another option with the benefit of easing the financial burden but can lead to difficulties in coordinating with the partner/s of the project. Furthermore, Japanese lawmakers are adamant that domestic companies should lead the project to secure profit and preserve the defense industry. Air Marshal B.K. Pandey, former Air Officer Commanding-in-Chief of Training Command of the Indian Air Force, noted that the F-X will likely face technological challenges as the technologies used in fighter jets have become more complex over the years.
US engagement
According to Gregg Rubinstein of Carnegie Endowment for International Peace, the US and Japan have differing approaches and priorities on joint-developing the stealth fighter. US defense officials emphasized that operational concepts and capability requirements should be the basis for fighter acquisition. In contrast, the Japanese officials have prioritized technology development and industrial base interest. In addition, the bitter legacy of the F-2 casts a shadow over discussions between the two countries. In light of the F-2, there is concerns that Japan will be unable to have control of its partnership with the US.UK factor
At the same time, military cooperation between the UK and Japan have expanded over the years. Discussions on joint-development between both countries have been described as 'open-minded and flexible'. Gregg Rubinstein has also noted that both countries have developed an interest in each other; noting that in a post-Brexit environment Britain will be looking beyond the EU for partners and Japan will desire to gain some independence from the US for its domestic industry. However, this increased cooperation has elicit some reactions from the US. In mid-April 2019, several reports indicated that the U.S. is willing to disclose portions of the F-35's software to Japan in exchange for joint development on the F-X fighter. These reports stated the offer was made in response to outdo 'rival' Britain in securing a deal with Japan. According to the Financial Times, there has been concerns among US officials that Japan would select BAE Systems as its international partner over US defense contractors. As a result, the Trump administration has reportedly exerted political pressure on Japan to joint-develop the F-X with the US. There is concerns that selecting a British fighter jet would increase interoperability difficulties between it and the US military and US made aircraft in Japan, thus complicating joint operations. Another is that selecting the UK will likely anger President Trump amidst a cost sharing dispute regarding stationing US forces in Japan. Nikkei Asian Review noted that between choosing the UK or US as a partner, the UK would offer greater flexibility for Japan in developing the F-X while Japan still heavily weighs its alliance with US. In early March 2020, a report from Nikkei Asian Review indicated that Japan has planned on selecting the US for collaboration despite the ongoing discussions between Japan and the US and UK at the time of the reporting. While ATLA has responded by stating that US and UK discussions were still ongoing, the report suggest that the US still has a strong influence over Japan because of their alliance.Geopolitical
The development of the F-X allows Japan to catch up and counter against with Russian and Chinese stealth fighters. Within East Asia, the F-X allows Japan to not lag behind China and South Korea's stealth fighter pursuit.The F-X was also designed primarily in response to concerns of Chinese, North Korean, and Russian military threats. Japan MoD considers China's rapid military buildup and disputes in the East and South China Sea are seen as a primary security concern; along with North Korea's nuclear weapons program and Russia's increased military activities. With regards to China, the F-X would likely be used to counter advanced Chinese fighter jets: Shenyang J-11, Chengdu J-20, and Shenyang FC-31. Experts believe that the stealth jet would likely unnerve China to Japan's increased militarization.
Japan's development of the F-X, along with China, India and South Korea's stealth fighter programs, are noted as an increase trend of Asian aerospace industries challenging against Western and Russian dominance in the global fighter jet industry. As of 2018, 90% of combat aircraft flown in all of the world's air forces comes from the US, USSR/Russia, Britain, France and Sweden. If the F-X is successfully designed then the focus of the fighter jet industry could shift from the Northern Atlantic closer to the Asia-Pacific. If it is exported then it could potentially become a serious challenge against the West's predominance in the fighter industry.
Design
Overview
The F-X is a twin engine stealth fighter that is designed for achieving air superiority. By the Japanese MoD's own terminology, the technology and capabilities the F-X possesses will classify it as a sixth generation fighter jet.The F-X is said to be bigger than the F-22, which has earned it the nickname "Godzilla" from Bradley Perrett at Aviation Week. The large size indicates the MoD desires the aircraft to possess very long range and large payload capacity. Technologies tested in the X-2 technology demonstrator will likely be incorporated into the F-X fighter. Defense Minister Taro Kono has stated that the F-X will possess strong network capabilities and will carry more missiles than the F-35.
Conceptual designing of the F-X were made through 3-D digital mock-up. Designing is based on the assumed function and performance of the F-X and is then installed in a research flight/battle simulator developed by the :ja:技術研究本部|Technical Research Division. Data on avionics, stealth and engine characteristics are inputted in the simulator and is then tested by JASDF pilots. Through air-to-air combat simulations the effectiveness and improvements to the mock-up design are gauged.
Compared to its predecessor, the F-X replaces the usage of conventional hydraulic systems with electric actuators. According to the MoD's evaluation, the reason for selecting electric actuators over hydraulic systems is because of the complexity of designing the interior of the stealth fighter. When designing the stealth shape of the aircraft the internal weapon bay and intake air-ducts must be accounted for. However, problems arose with installing hydraulic system piping because several design considerations; such as rigidity and length. The adoption of electric actuators eliminated the constraints because they're only connected via electric wiring. Through this the installation is simplified and the restrictions were reduced, allowing more flexibility in designing the body of the aircraft. Other advantages include weight reduction of body and improve mobility of the aircraft. The electric actuators are applied to the fighters control, power and leg/brake system.
To maintain a lightweight body structure the F-X implements several technologies and manufacture/design techniques in order achieve this. One method involves reducing or eliminate the use of fasteners by bonding composite materials together through adhesive molding. This method is dubbed the "integrated/fastenerless structure" technology. Around the engines heat shield technology is placed to allow aluminum alloys and carbon fiber reinforced polymer to be applied to reduce weight around the area. High-efficiency/high-accuracy structural analysis techniques used for the F-X involve creating finite element method models using computer-aided design to study and create stress analysis standards for the F-X. The F-X's predecessor, the F-2, introduced integrated molding and CFRP material to reduce its overall weight but the molding technique applied only on the bottom plates of the main wings; requiring fasteners to be placed through the upper plates in the main wing and other areas using fasteners on both plates. In comparison, the F-X expands the application of CFRP and adhesive molding to the entire fuselage. From the MoD's research it is shown that adopting the new design methods can reduce the structural mass of the F-X's air-frame by 11.6% and reduce working man-hours by 66% compared to conventional approaches.
To cope with the heat produced from avionics, a small but dedicated heat transfer system is installed in the F-X to assist its air cycle and liquid cooling system. The small heat transfer system is modeled off the vapor-compression refrigeration cycle.
Avionics
To improve detection against stealth aircraft, the F-X utilizes integrated sensors. The sensors include: an active electronically scanned array radar, passive radio frequency sensor, and an infrared camera. Both the AESA radar and RF sensor utilize Gallium nitride to improve its performance. The AESA radar is based on the J/APG-2 radar used on the F-2 fighter and is similar to the AN/APG-81 radar used in the F-35.The F-X possess a RF 'self-defense' system to counter aircraft, air-to-air missile and surface-to-air missile threats. The system performs both ESM and ECM by being alerted to the threat and disrupting its radio waves instantly and globally. Integrated ESM body antennas are placed along the wing and tail flap of the fighter jet.
Cockpit
The helmet-mounted display features a wide field of vision, binocular, multi-color display, voice recognition and 3-D sound.Stealth
To minimize its radar cross section, F-X physical design features serpentine air-ducts and internal weapon bay. Electromagnetic wave absorbers are applied to the air-ducts and engines to reduce the amount of radar reflection. The absorber is said to be of carbon-based material. According to results of tests conducted, the RCS reduction done from the absorbers has the equivalent affect of reducing detection range from radar threats by about half. Metamaterials are also used to reflect radio waves. The metamaterials consists of various materials including small pieces of metals and dielectric. The metamaterials are applied on the pulse doppler system as part of a radio wave reflection control technology on board the F-X.To avoid radar emission, the F-X maximizes its usage of passive detection. Its sensor programs also operates the emission in way that reduces the likelihood of counter detection during radar emissions.
The F-X uses plasma stealth antenna technology to deflect radio waves. The antenna operates by creating temporary plasma using characteristics of plasma that can change physical properties through electrical control. While activated the antenna is also capable of transmitting and receiving communication.