In late 1999 All About Eve played three fully electric reunion concerts in support of The Mission. During this time Willson-Piper persuaded Regan to keep the group going and do a few acoustic gigs. The rationale for choosing acoustic gigs included Willson-Piper's previous experience of doing them himself, the lower cost and the fact that, at that point, the band had no drummer - Mark Price not being able to leave Del Amitri on a long-term basis. The very first Fairy Light Night was on 25 January 2000 at the Warwick Arts Centre in Regan's hometown of Coventry.
The first gigs were extremely well received by fans, with word-of-mouth and internet forums allowing renewed interest in the band to spread rapidly. Most of the gigs were very well attended, with many being full to capacity. Within six months, a CD entitled Fairy Light Nights was released, this being a recording of performances taken from various gigs. A year later, attendance at the gigs and sales of the CD were such that it was considered viable to release a second album, Fairy Light Nights 2, containing further songs which had been recorded at the same time but not included on the original album.
Ups and downs
In all there were nearly 100 gigs, at a frequency of more than one a week at the height of activity. The band played as far north as Aberdeen and as far south as Penzance. Most of the shows were held by both the fans and the band to be extremely successful, although the one in Worthing is often cited by all who were there as a low point in the tour: because Marty's amplifiers were too loud for the venue and created intolerable feedback for the first few songs, Willson-Piper was forced to sit out the rest of the gig without playing, putting him in a foul mood and causing him to berate the audience between songs.
End of the era
The last Fairy Light Night was in Crewe on 3 February 2002. This was also the last All About Eve concert to feature Willson-Piper, who would leave the band citing musical differences immediately afterwards. He was replaced in the spring of that year by a Finn, Toni Haimi, lately of bands such as Nozzle and Malluka. By the time they went back on tour again in May, they were a five-piece band and the subsequent gigs were fully electric.
Other activity during this period
All About Eve also played some fully electric dates during this time: these do not technically count as Fairy Light Nights but were equally well received by fans. These gigs included the 2000 Cropredy Festival where devoted fans sat through two hours of the Incredible String Band before All About Eve finally came on. These fully electric gigs included a concert at the Union Chapel in December 2000, which was recorded and later released as the albumLive and Electric at the Union Chapel. The success of this concert and the comparatively high sales of the album encouraged the band to hold another, equally successful, concert in the same venue a year later.
New songs during this time
No new All About Eve songs were premiered during any Fairy Light Night: however, three songs by Willson-Piper were performed, these being "Forever", "You Bring Your Love to Me" and "Will I Start To Bleed?" None of these has been performed as All About Eve songs since Willson-Piper's departure. "Miss World" was previously a Mice song but this has been performed as an All About Eve song since.
''Fairy Light Nights 1'' track listing
"What Kind of Fool?"
"In the Clouds"
"Forever"
"Share It With Me"
"Will I Start to Bleed?"
"Miss World"
"Martha's Harbour"
"Shelter from the Rain"
"Are You Lonely?"
"Appletree Man"
''Fairy Light Nights 2'' track listing
"Scarlet"
"The Mystery We Are"
"You Bring Your Love to Me"
"Freeze"
"Mine"
"More Than the Blues"
"Never Promise "
"Yesterday Goodbye"
"Wild Hearted Woman"
"Every Angel"
Re-releases
Almafame went bankrupt shortly after the issue of Fairy Light Nights 1. Since then two records of unclear legality have been released without the band's permission, entitled Unplugged and Martha's Harbour. A third version, All About Eve's What Kind of Fool, has also been released, available as download only through many mainstream download music sites. All three releases contain identical material to Fairy Light Nights 1. The second album, Fairy Light Nights 2, was released by JamTart, the band's own label and so not subjected to the same re-issuing conflicts.
''Acoustic Nights''
This is a JamTart repackaging of both Fairy Light Nights CDs into a double album. The band fully approved it, although they emphasis that it contains nothing not already included in the two single albums.