Daugherty was released by the A's in January after only one season in their farm system. He played the 1984 season for the independent Helena Gold Sox of the Pioneer Baseball League before signing with the Montreal Expos in December.
Montreal Expos
Daugherty made his major league debut in as a first baseman with the Montreal Expos. He was 1 for 10 in 11 games with his only hit coming against Greg Maddux. After spending the entire season in the minors, batting.285 for the Indianapolis Indians, he was sent to the Texas Rangers to complete an earlier deal in which the Rangers sent Tom O'Malley to the Expos for a player to be named later.
Texas Rangers
In he was used as a pinch hitter, back-up first baseman, left fielder and occasional designated hitter for the 4th place Rangers. He posted solid hitting numbers, with a.302 average,.364 on-base percentage, and.406 slugging percentage, over 58 games. Daugherty's best season was, as he appeared in a career high 125 games, hit six home runs, drove in 47, and batted.300/.347/.435. He was the first Ranger to hit over.300 with 100 or more at-bats in back to back seasons since Al Oliver accomplished the feat in -. The best game of Daugherty's career came on Sunday, July 8, 1990 when he was 4 for 5 with two home runs and three RBIs. In fact, Daugherty hit 20% of his career home runs in that game and did so in back to back at-bats against pitchers Roger Clemens and Jeff Reardon. The home run against Clemens occurred in the 7th inning and the blast off of Reardon came in the bottom of the 9th to tie the game. The Rangers would go on to defeat the first placed Red Sox in 11 innings. Injuries limited Daugherty's season to only 58 games, for which he posted lackluster statistics of.194/.270/.264. Given a reprieve in, Daugherty nearly duplicated his '91 effort by hitting.205/.295/.276 over 59 games. The Rangers subsequently released him following the 1992 season.
Houston Astros and Cincinnati Reds
Daugherty signed with the Houston Astros as a free agent on January 5,. Assigned to the Astros' triple A affiliate the Tucson Toros, Daugherty responded by tearing up the Pacific Coast League by hitting.390/.488/.525 over 42 games. Despite these numbers, he found little playing time with the parent club, as perennial all-star Jeff Bagwell occupied first base and manager Art Howe seemed to prefer using Kevin Bass, Chris Donnels and Chris James as his primary pinch-hitters. Daugherty was 1 for 3 in just four games with Houston. His lone Astros hit came as a pinch-hitter against Bob Tewksbury of the St. Louis Cardinals in a 6-1 Astros loss at Busch Memorial Stadium on May 4, 1993. The Astros later traded Daugherty to the Cincinnati Reds on July 12, 1993 for Steve Carter. With Cincinnati, he played in 46 games while hitting.220/.338/.356.
In January, Daugherty signed with the Colorado Rockies, but did not make the major league roster that Spring. After two seasons in the Toronto Blue Jays' and San Francisco Giants' farm systems, Daugherty played in for the Chiba Lotte Marines. He played in 19 games, batting.119, before being released in June.
