List of American Pie characters
This is a list of characters from the film series American Pie consisting of American Pie, American Pie 2, American Wedding, ', ', ', ', and American Reunion. Only one character, Noah Levenstein played by Eugene Levy, has appeared in all eight released films. Biggs, Hannigan, Scott, Nicholas, Thomas, Coolidge, Cho, Isfield, Cheek, and Owen all play their characters in four films each; other characters appear in fewer films.
Characters from ''American Pie">American Pie (film)">American Pie''
Noah Levenstein
- Portrayed by Eugene Levy
- Appeared in: American Pie, American Pie 2, American Wedding, American Pie Presents: Band Camp, American Pie Presents: The Naked Mile, American Pie Presents: Beta House, American Pie Presents: The Book of Love, and American Reunion
He first appears in American Pie where he attempts to offer sexual advice including purchasing and giving his son Jim pornography after finding him masturbating with a tube sock. He later finds Jim humping a pie after being previously told that third base feels like "warm apple pie". He later helps Jim cover the incident up and lies to his wife about the missing pie and where it has gone, telling her he ate it.
He reappears in the second film of the series where he takes Jim to the hospital after Jim decides to turn on a porn film that Stifler rented, but accidentally uses superglue instead of lubricant to masturbate, permanently gluing his entire hand to his penis and boxer shorts. He then supports Jim after he learns that he won't be able to have sex for at least a whole week, the same amount of time before the party he is attending with Nadia, who he plans on sleeping with, will be held.
In the third installment Noah arrives at the restaurant Jim is at to give him the wedding ring he was going to use to propose to girlfriend Michelle. Jim tries to hide the fact that he is being fellated. Not knowing Michelle is under the table, Jim's dad expresses his excitement at the proposal. Then, after Michelle bumps her head under the table in shock at hearing about the proposal, all chaos ensues as Jim ends up exposed and has to hike his pants up quickly. Saving face, he swallows what is left of his pride and asks Michelle to marry him and gets an erection. She readily agrees.
He reappears in the fourth film and the first spin off film from the main series, in which he is the camp's MACRO and recommends that Matt Stifler start trying to fit in and earn the band's trust.
He appears again in the fifth installment, in which he is presiding over the annual Naked Mile run.
He reappears in the sixth film in which he is the Beta alumni and the last-winning team captain of the Greek Olympiad. He helps to host the competition, which includes competing to remove girls' bras the fastest, a light saber duel and catching a greased pig. The final challenge being to hold off from ejaculation while receiving a lap dance. After the Betas win, Noah, as the officiate, hands over the golden hammer to Dwight.
In the seventh film he plays a significantly smaller role, as he is not seen until near the end of the movie. He is revealed to have created "The Bible" while at college. After the book is destroyed, Rob, Nathan and Lube track him down to help recreate it, in which he assists them with and helps the group to recreate the manual.
In American Reunion, it is revealed that his wife has died three years prior to the events portrayed in the film and that he is still grieving her loss. In the end, he finds love with Stifler's mom.
James "Jim" Levenstein
- Portrayed by Jason Biggs
- Appeared in: American Pie, American Pie 2, American Wedding, and American Reunion
Jim reappears in American Pie 2 where he and his friends rent a house at Lake Michigan in the summer break at the end of their freshman year. After keeping in contact with Nadia, who is traveling across the US, Nadia agrees to join Jim at his beach party. When Jim decides to turn on a porn movie that Stifler rented, he accidentally uses superglue instead of lubricant to masturbate, permanently gluing his entire hand to his penis and boxer shorts. Shocked and frightened, he takes out the porn cassette but ends up bonding the cassette to his other hand. Unable to open any doors, he climbs out of a window and stumbles onto the rooftop where he is caught by police officers. He is supported at the hospital by his father Noah, where he learns the news that he won't be able to have sex for at least a whole week, the same amount of time before the party is due to occur. When Nadia turns up earlier than expected, Michelle acts as his fake girlfriend so that he won't have to have sex with Nadia until his penis has healed. At the party Jim has an epiphany and realizes that it isn't Nadia he loves but Michelle. Nadia is upset that Jim chose a geek over her, but is happy for Jim and allows him to go and find Michelle, performing at band camp. He gatecrashes the performance with a trombone, just like he did before, but with much more style and confidence, and romantically makes out with Michelle in front of the cheering crowd.
In American Wedding, Jim plays a supporting role with much less screen time in comparison to the first two films and Reunion. In the opening scene, he proposes to Michelle after a few problems in attempting. She enthusiastically agrees. Jim is worried about dancing at the wedding, but salvation comes in the form of Steve Stifler, who promises to teach Jim in return of a wedding invite. Jim reluctantly agrees much to the rest of the guests disappointment. Stifler also takes charge of the bachelor party but unfortunately collides the dates with the day Jim was supposedly setting up a dinner to impress Michelle's parents. Although it appears all is ruined, Stifler and Finch cover for Jim and thankfully get the Flaherty's blessing. Scared on the days building toward the wedding, Jim shaves his pubic hair in an attempt to impress Michelle even further. However, disaster strikes as his pubes inadvertently fall into the air conditioning covering their wedding cake. A new one is made and Jim encounters another embarrassing heart-heart with his father. On the day of the wedding, Jim announces his appreciation and love for his friends Paul Finch, Kevin Myers and Steve Stifler and then happily marries Michelle.
In Band Camp, Noah Levenstein informs Stifler's younger brother Matt of Michelle's pregnancy revealing that the character is to become a father. Jim is mentioned again as Noah attempts to comfort Matt, who was caught attempting to masturbate using an oboe, informing him that he caught his son engaging in sexual activity with a pie.
Naked Mile also alludes to Jim's paternity as Noah proudly informs Erik, Steve and Matt's younger cousin, that Michelle successfully gave birth.
Whilst absent from the film, The Book of Love shows Jim's signature in the East Great Falls Bible, referencing the events of the first film.
Jim returns in American Reunion, once again the protagonist, played by Jason Biggs. He and Michelle now have a 2-year-old son named Evan. The couple's sex life has been slowly deteriorating after the birth of their son. Throughout the film, they try to re-ignite their sexual flames. Also, Jim must avoid the advances of Kara, an 18-year-old girl he once babysat when she was young, who wants to lose her virginity to him. Seeing how her situation mirrors his own when he was her age in the original film, Jim teaches her that it is best if she waits for someone special.
Michelle Flaherty
- Portrayed by Alyson Hannigan
- Appeared in: American Pie, American Pie 2, American Wedding, and American Reunion
She reappears in American Pie 2 in a much larger role. Here, her friendship with Jim grows over the summer and eventually she begins to fall in love with him. She explains that she didn't ditch Jim the morning after prom intentionally. It was done out of fear of rejection as she thought the date was over and was worried that Jim would have done the same to her. She later pretends to be Jim's girlfriend so he won't have to have sex with Nadia until his sore penis has healed. She stages a break up in front of Nadia who later goes to the party with Jim. However, Michelle is upset about Jim's interest in Nadia as opposed to her. Jim later realizes his love for Michelle, and decides to just be friends with Nadia. He goes to find Michelle at band camp, and gatecrashes the performance with a trombone and confidently kisses Michelle in front of a supportive crowd, therefore beginning a relationship with her.
In American Wedding, she and Jim have continued dating and she accepts Jim's offer of marriage at the beginning of the film. Michelle settles on a dress but it is only made by one particular dressmaker so Jim and his friends set out to find him for her. Michelle and Jim's plans are almost ruined when Stifler turns up to the engagement party although they had planned to not invite him. After several misadventures, including one with the flowers being killed which Stifler later fixes, Michelle and Jim marry.
Band Camp revealed that after the events of American Wedding, Michelle became an annual MACRO at Tall Oaks Band Camp. However, she could not attend in the 2005 semester as she was heavily pregnant with Jim's baby. She requested that Noah, Jim's father, take her place, a request he received with much pride. In Naked Mile, Noah informs Erik Stifler that she had in fact given birth to a baby, to which he announced was a happy occasion.
She appeared in American Reunion.
Steve Stifler
- Portrayed by Seann William Scott
- Appeared in: American Pie, American Pie 2, American Wedding, and American Reunion
Stifler's second appearance was in the sequel, American Pie 2, with a much larger role this time. After returning from his first year at Michigan State University with Oz, Stifler attempts a reunion party at his home, which is shut down thanks to the neighbors calling the police. He helps chip in cash to rent a beach house on Lake Michigan with the rest of the group. During the summer, Stifler becomes interested in two attractive owners of a neighboring house that they were hired to paint: two females whom Stifler mistakenly regards as lesbians. As Stifler, Jim, and Finch sneak into their room, they respond to Stifler's attraction by offering to engage in varying degrees of lesbian sexual activities in front of Stifler, Jim and Finch, but only in exchange for the guys to engage in a corresponding degree of homoerotic acts that the girls enjoy watching. The first is Stifler grabbing Finch's buttocks, the second is Stifler and Jim french kissing, and the third one would have been for Stifler to receive a hand job from either Finch or Jim, which Stifler is the only one confident enough to do. However this freaks out Jim and Finch too much and they run off. This annoys Stifler, as the more the guys would have done, the more the girls would have done. At the main party at the beach house at the end of the film, the two girls arrive, telling Stifler they never said they were lesbians, and Stifler ends up in bed with them both.
In American Wedding, Stifler is the main protagonist. He is revealed to have become a high school football assistant coach; he also drives the team's bus. He drops in on Jim and Michelle's engagement party, much to their dismay. He is also implicated in an unusual Jim-plus-two-dogs foursome. He competes with Finch for the heart of Cadence, Michelle's younger sister. He impersonates Finch's refined and polite personality in order to win Cadence over, but Finch continues the triangle by replicating Stifler's outrageous frat boy image, which Cadence surprisingly enjoys just as much, if not more. Nevertheless, Stifler manages to bond with Cadence's family, and is eventually charged with holding Michelle's wedding ring. However, the family dog manages to ingest the ring while it is in Stifler's care, and Stifler follows it until it defecates. Stifler picks up the ring which is encapsulated within the feces using a confection paper, which Cadence's mother sees and assumes it to be one of the truffles. She insists that Stifler let her have it, but knowing he could blow his chances with Cadence for good, he suddenly devours the dog dropping into his own mouth. This carries on the tradition of rather distasteful gags where Stifler ingests various bodily substances once in each movie. Before the wedding, Stifler accidentally destroys the massive flower arrangement Michelle's family had ordered, resulting in everyone turning against him. Jim tells him to leave, and seeing how no one is on his side, Stifler complies. However, Stifler redeems himself at the end of the film: using the football team as his minions, Stifler uses his own money to buy up the entire content of a nearby flower shop and has the football team successfully set up the flowers for the wedding hours before it is to occur. By doing this, Cadence eventually falls for him and invites him to have sex in the closet. Upon following this invitation, Stifler accidentally has sex with Jim's grandmother, who was put there by John and Justin because she was "being a bitch". When Finch and Kevin go to collect her from the closet, they catch Stifler having sex with Jim's grandmother. Horrified by this, Stifler asks them to close the door and screams out. At the wedding, Finch taunts Stifler by whispering "grandmother fucker". Stifler retorts with "Well, you're a mother fucker", to which Finch agrees "Yes. yes I am." At the reception, Stifler dances with Cadence and congratulates his friend, Jim.
In ', the audience are told that Stifler has become a pornographic movie director. This movie shows that although the jocks and other popular kids pretended to like Stifler he was not liked by anyone in high school, which led Matt to reform his ways. In ', he is mentioned in passing by his cousin Erik as one of the legendary Stifler boys. A picture of him can be seen on Erik's noticeboard.
In American Reunion, he is portrayed in a slightly lighter fashion and can be considered somewhat of a tragic character. He now works as a temp at an investment firm, having to put up with humiliating verbal abuse from his cold-hearted employer. He yearns for the days of his youth and has trouble coping with the fact that things will never be the way they were before. Throughout the film, he attempts to re-create his teenage years but fails each time as his friends and everyone else have outgrown this. When Stifler learns Finch was arrested for stealing his boss' motorcycle, he finds it hilarious and believed he got his revenge on Finch because he slept with Jeanine in the past. Meanwhile, Jim, Oz and Kevin are angered by Stifler's lack of tolerance towards their friend and rally to Finch's side. During a heated argument with the guys, Jim, Oz and Kevin reveal they don't like having Stiffer around because he always ruins their plans. Stifler is devastated and decides to skip the reunion. However, the guys soon realize how much they mean to Stifler, and how much he means to them, so they locate him at work and make amends with him. He regains his confidence and quits his job. The guys proceed to attend the reunion, finally embracing Stifler as one of their own. Stifler catches up with Chuck "Sherminator" Sherman, and feeling regretful for how he treated him in high school, Stifler wholeheartedly helps Sherman find a woman to score with. In a surprise turn of events, he meets Finch's gorgeous mother and finally has his revenge by having sex with her on the lacrosse field as the MILF Guys, John and Justin, happily watch. In the end, the five friends all promise to stay in touch and meet up at least once a year from now on to catch up.
Kevin Myers
- Portrayed by Thomas Ian Nicholas
- Appeared in: American Pie, American Pie 2, American Wedding, and American Reunion
Kevin reappears in American Pie 2 where he, Jim, Oz and Finch return to their hometown in East Great Falls, Michigan for the summer break after their first year of college. They attend a party hosted by Stifler, but not only does their new status as college students not give them any success with local girls, but the police also shut down the party. Kevin also has problems when he meets Vicky after their year away from each other; Vicky wants to be friends and Kevin is love-sick for her, but worried he will lose her completely. Desperately he calls his brother for advice, who tells him to move down to the beach and party hard. Together, they set off for a rented house by the beach in Grand Harbor, Michigan, where they intend to spend the whole summer, but Kevin is forced to invite Stifler along as well in order to successfully cover the costs. Kevin finds the boys jobs working as painters and decorators for a nearby house. The boys then plan to throw a huge summer party at the house, bigger than anything they've done before. The party begins at the beach house. Kevin sees his ex-girlfriend Vicky but is devastated when he sees her with a new boyfriend and leaves to go to the beach by himself. Oz, Finch and Jim follow him down, where he admits to them that he never got over Vicky and that with the party, he was hoping to relive his senior year prom night, in particular, sleeping with Vicky at the end of it. The others help Kevin realize that it will never happen, and the quartet return to the beach house to party hard.
In the third film he reappears in a much smaller role, with no significance to the plot, in contrast to the first two and latter films. As a groomsman, he aids Jim in finding the wedding dress Michelle finally settles on after long hours of searching which is made by only one designer working for one store, so Jim, Kevin and Finch, with Stifler tagging along sets out to find the dressmaker for her. They go to Chicago looking for her and end up in a gay bar. Stifler has a dance-off to make up for his meanness towards a man, Mr. Belvedere, who knows the dressmaker. In the meantime Stifler arranges a bachelor party for everyone at Jim's house except Jim who unknowingly has arranged a "special dinner" for Michelle's parents before the wedding. Kevin, Finch, and Stifler are then introduced to Fraulein Brandi and Officer Krystal by Mr. Belvedere and then play submissive and dominant roles with them respectively. While this is going on, Jim enters the house and Michelle's parents are badly embarrassed. Notably, he is absent from the wedding reception.
It is noted on the DVD commentary that most of Kevin's scenes were cut from the final edit, which implies he played a more relevant role than the one shown in the final cut.
In American Reunion, Kevin has lost contact with all his former friends; apart from Jim. The two have a conversation about going to the reunion, with Kevin being very excited. He is working as an architect from home, and is married to a woman named Ellie. His life now consists of watching shows like Real Housewives and Desperate Housewives. Kevin and the others meet at a bar, where they browse through the yearbook and find Kevin's quote, "Kevin Myers hopes to still be living it up with the beautiful Vicky Lathum." The next day, they all go to the beach, and Kevin and Vicky run into each other. They're still friends, and there appears to be no romantic feelings between the two of them. They go to the falls and chat to each other, getting drunk. The next morning, Kevin wakes up beside Vicky, wearing nothing but his underwear. He worries and leaves, thinking the two of them engaged in sexual intercourse. At Stifler's party, Kevin rings his wife, but Vicky enters the room. He confronts Vicky, but she says they didn't have sex and that she took his clothes off because he fell in the lake. She is angry at Kevin that he would have such low expectations about her. He fights outside against A.J. and his friend, and puts up a decent fight. When Finch is taken by the police, Kevin passionately tries to stop them by saying Finch didn't steal the motorcycle. Kevin and Vicky reconcile at the reunion, and the two of them and Ellie dance together. He is last seen at Dog Days with the others, and they all agree to meet up at least once a year from now on.
Paul Finch
- Portrayed by Eddie Kaye Thomas
- Appeared in: American Pie, American Pie 2, American Wedding, and American Reunion
Paul reappears in American Pie 2, where he, Jim, Kevin, Oz, and Stifler return to their hometown in East Great Falls, Michigan for the summer break after their first year of college. They attend a party hosted by Stifler, but not only does their new status as college students not give them any success with local girls, but the police also shut down the party. After arriving in Grand Harbor, Kevin finds them work as painters and decorators for a house nearby. Stifler is intrigued by the two sexy female owners, who appear to be lesbians, and excitedly breaks into their house while they're away. Jim and Finch follow him, trying to get him out, but they are caught by the owners, who relent on calling the police. But after Stifler identifies his interest in their homosexuality, they insist on the boys performing "like for like" homosexual acts on each other in return for being able to watch the girls do the same thing. Oz and Kevin take turns watching up a ladder and listening on the walkie-talkie also in the room. The conversation is accidentally picked up and heard by many other people in the neighborhood. After this, the boys plan to throw a huge summer party at the house, bigger than anything they've done before. Finch has become involved in the sexual art of Tantra, and claims that through Tantric sex, he can "make an orgasm last for days". He is waiting patiently for Jeanine, hoping she will show up and be willing to have sex with him again. He thinks she arrives when a vehicle turns up after Stifler is talking on the phone, but it turns out to be Stifler's little brother Matt. Finally, the party begins at the beach house. Kevin sees his ex-girlfriend Vicky but is crushed when he sees her with a new boyfriend and leaves to go to the beach by himself. Oz, Finch and Jim follow him down, where he confides in them that he never got over Vicky and that with the party, he was hoping to relive his senior year prom night, in particular, sleeping with Vicky at the end of it. The others help Kevin realize that it will never happen, and the quartet return to the beach house to party hard. The morning after the party, a Mercedes coupe with darkened windows turns up at the house. Finch approaches to see Jeanine who has finally turned up. It doesn't take long before Finch gets into the car and drives off to the lakeside to have hard sex with her.
In the third film, Finch plays a larger role. He helps Jim find the wedding dress Michelle finally settles on after long hours of searching which is made by only one designer working for one store, so Jim, Kevin and Finch, with Stifler tagging along sets out to find the dressmaker for her. They go to Chicago looking for her and end up in a gay bar. Stifler has a dance-off to make up for his rudeness towards a man, Bear, who knows the dressmaker. In the meantime Stifler arranges a bachelor party for everyone at Jim's house except Jim who unknowingly has arranged a "special dinner" for Michelle's parents before the wedding. Kevin, Jim and Stifler are then introduced to Fraulein Brandi and Officer Krystal by Bear and then play submissive and dominant roles with them respectively. While this is going on, Jim enters the house and Michelle's parents are badly embarrassed. Michelle's sister Cadence attends the wedding, and Finch is quickly attracted to her. Stifler also becomes attracted to her. Upon hearing that Cadence is hoping to attract a decent guy, Stifler adopts a more meek attitude and acts like Finch, and avoids swearing and speaks of philosophy. But when Finch realizes that Cadence is beginning to tire of the intellectual Stifler, Finch acts immature, rude, and perverted: in other words, like Stifler. Stifler unintentionally kills the flowers the night before the wedding, and when arguing with Finch he is heard by Cadence, who realizes his true intentions. Later, Stifler realizes that he actually feels bad about his previous actions, prompting him to bring in the football team he coaches to set up the entire room with new flowers. Ultimately, Cadence chooses Stifler, and Finch admits that Stifler was probably better for her anyway. Due to a confusion, Stifler has sex with Jim's grandmother, who opposed the wedding but is so happily distracted by this to no longer argue. Michelle and Jim eventually get married. At the reception, Finch is sitting by himself when Stifler's mom arrives. They tell each other they are over each other but at the end of the movie it shows Stifler's mom and Finch in the tub having sex. The two MILF guys are watching in awe through the window as Finch goes under the bubbles to perform oral sex on her.
In American Reunion, Finch is an assistant manager at Staples but is often disrespected by his boss. Having had enough, he steals his boss's motorcycle when he does not receive a raise that was promised to him and takes it out for a joy ride. Finch is arrested for the whole thing when the cops show up. Stifler finds the whole thing funny and believes he has gotten his revenge on him for having sex with his mother. Disgusted with his antagonistic attitude, Jim, Oz and Kevin rally to Finch's side and tell Stifler off. He meets and falls in love with Selena when he sees they have a lot in common. Finch makes amends with Selena for lying, and they have sex in the bathroom, which promises to lead to an ongoing relationship; in the process, Finch realizes that he has moved on from Stifler's mom. He decided to go see the world with Selena. Before leaving, Finch learns that Stifler had sex with his mom, Rachel, and feels a similar disgust towards his behavior.
Chris "Oz" Ostreicher
- Portrayed by Chris Klein
- Appeared in: American Pie, American Pie 2, and American Reunion
In American Pie 2 he reappears where he and his friends rent a house at Lake Michigan in the summer break at the end of their freshman year where they plan to have a party. Oz is lonely and missing his girlfriend Heather who is away in Spain. They start having erotic phone sex to vent some of their frustration, but keep getting interrupted by various people. Heather turns up to Oz's delight later at the party.
He does not reappear in the third film, American Wedding and his absence isn't explained. In a deleted scene, it is mentioned that he and Heather are in Spain.
Like the majority of the other characters, Oz does not appear in any of the spin-off films but his name can be seen on the check-out card for "The Bible" in .
He is re-introduced into the series in American Reunion. He is now a successful, wealthy sportscaster, but is best known for his embarrassing loss to Gilbert Gottfried on Celebrity Dance-Off. Despite his fame and fortune, he is still not truly happy, as he and Heather are no longer together, and he has yet to have a family of his own. He shows up for the reunion with the gang, and upon seeing Jim again, he acknowledges he may have missed his wedding but he'd never miss the reunion. In the meantime, he tries to rekindle his relationship with Heather.
Victoria "Vicky" Lathum
- Portrayed by Tara Reid
- Appeared in: American Pie, American Pie 2, and American Reunion
In American Pie 2, she appears to have moved on from Kevin, she tells Stifler and Oz and Kevin while they're playing pool, that she had sex with only one guy, which upsets Kevin, and before the last scene, Kevin admits to her that he hadn't moved on, and they agreed to be friends, then she dances with him at their lake party.
In American Reunion, she appears to have broken-up with her boyfriend and is living with her parents. She gets mad at Kevin for thinking they had sex after waking up in the bed with her and his clothes are off. In the last scene Kevin confesses his old feelings for her, and explains that he loves his wife but that she will always be his first love. He then introduces Vicky to his wife at the reunion where his wife insists that the three of them share a dance.
Heather
- Portrayed by Mena Suvari
- Appeared in: American Pie, American Pie 2, and American Reunion
Heather reappears in American Pie 2 where she is out of town and has phone sex with Oz until a foreigner and Stifler interrupt. She later surprises Oz at the party.
While absent from American Wedding, she appears in American Reunion where she has a slightly bigger role. She has broken up with Oz and dates a heart surgeon named Ron, who turns out to be a jerk, and they separate as Heather goes back to Oz.
Jessica
- Portrayed by Natasha Lyonne
- Appeared in: American Pie, American Pie 2, and American Reunion
Nadia
- Portrayed by Shannon Elizabeth
- Appeared in: American Pie, American Pie 2, and American Reunion
Nadia makes her second appearance in American Pie 2. Traveling across the US, Nadia agrees to join Jim at his beach party. When Nadia turns up earlier than expected, Michelle acts as his fake girlfriend so that he won't have to have sex with Nadia until his penis has healed. At the party, Jim realizes that it isn't Nadia he wants, but Michelle. Nadia is disappointed that Jim chose a geek over her, but is happy for Jim and allows him to go and find Michelle, performing at band camp. Meanwhile, the geeky Sherman mulls around at the party in a depressed mood, having abandoned his "Sherminator" mantra from the first film due to his abject failure with girls. By chance, he begins talking to the rejected Nadia, who is also depressed, and the two hit it off almost instantly. Nadia encourages Sherman to become the Sherminator once more, displaying a desire/fetish for geeks, and excitedly drags him into an upstairs bedroom where Sherman finally loses his virginity, to the shock of Stifler.
Though she does not appear in American Wedding, Jim has doubts about if he made the right decision in choosing Michelle over Nadia, after Stifler says that it was the biggest mistake Jim has ever made. This prompts Jim to have a chat with his father, Noah. Noah, who apparently has a minor attraction to Nadia, at first tries to brush off the idea of being with her but after Jim asks if he would sleep with her if he was her age and not married, Noah immediately answers "In a heartbeat". She is never mentioned again for the rest of the film afterwards.
She is mentioned briefly in The Book of Love as her cousin is currently attending East Great Falls High.
In American Reunion she briefly sees Jim and Michelle at the high school reunion, walking in on them having sex while showing off her boyfriend, who bears a striking resemblance to Jim.
Chuck Sherman
- Portrayed by Chris Owen
- Appeared in: American Pie, American Pie 2, American Pie Presents Band Camp, and American Reunion
He reappears in the second film where he goes to the party hosted by Jim and his friends. Later he mulls around at the party in a depressed mood, having abandoned his "Sherminator" mantra from the first film due to his abject failure with girls. By chance, he begins talking to the rejected Nadia, who is also depressed, and the two hit it off almost instantly. Nadia encourages Sherman to become the Sherminator once more, displaying a desire/fetish for geeks, and excitedly drags him into an upstairs bedroom where Sherman finally loses his virginity, to the shock of Stifler.
He reappears in American Pie Presents: Band Camp when Matt Stifler plays a prank on the school band. Sherman, who is now the school's guidance counselor, decides that a worthwhile punishment would be for Stifler to attend band camp.
He has appeared at the East Great Falls High reunion in American Reunion. He told Stifler he got married, had a son named Furlong and later divorced. He moves on quickly when he sees the most popular girl in high school everyone had a crush on, and picks her up using his Sherminator persona.
Matt Stifler
- Portrayed by Eli Marienthal in American Pie and American Pie 2, and Tad Hilgenbrink in American Pie Presents Band Camp
- Appeared in: American Pie, American Pie 2 and American Pie Presents Band Camp
Matt was first introduced to the series alongside his elder brother watching Nadia, the foreign exchange student, strip-tease in Jim Levenstein's bed room. His next appearance was in American Pie 2, where he requested to stay along with his brother in their summer beach house. In this film, set a year after the first, Matt begun to show his interest in girls and even at his young age showed signs of the infamous Stifler Sex Drive. Although Steve teaches him several lessons on how to get girls, when it comes to the night of the party he simply puts Matt on watch-dog duty. Angered, Matt waits outside and begins to aimlessly work his walkie-talkie. Much to his surprise and pleasure, however, he accidentally comes across the signal of the girls across the street. After being asked who's speaking, an eager-to-impress Matt states they are in fact talking to "the Stiffmeister". He manages to impress the girls enough to meet up with him but his prize is cut short when his brother intervenes successfully wooing the girls into bed with him. Matt leaves the next day, his hands full of porn videos, bidding goodbye to Steve and his friends.
Matt's next appearance was as a starring role in Band Camp, which sees him eager to join the family business of making amateur porn films. On the day of the seniors graduation, he and his friends spray the bands instruments with pepper spray. The prank, however, is cut short after Matt accidentally left the pepper spray open and leaking in his pocket evidently burning his penis. The band, unable to see due to the spray, accidentally destroy the set inadvertently revealing Matt as the culprit. As punishment, he must endure his summer at Band Camp. Now classed by his old friends as a bandee, Matt tries to prove himself by filming his fellow band members sexual activities throughout the summer. However, as the summer progresses, Matt suddenly develops a friendship with his fellow campers and romantic feelings for the drum major Elyse, whom he had recently had an off screen relationship with prior. With the help of Mr Levenstein, Matt realizes that living in his brother's shadow and following in his footsteps isn't what he should be doing. By the end of the film, Matt reforms himself much like his older brother did in American Wedding. However, he is still content on insulting his peers and still has an active sex drive but appears far less selfish, nasty and bullying.
Matt's next appearance is a simple cameo in the second spin-off ', where he is introduced as a picture on his younger cousin, Erik's, wall as a "legendary Stifler Boy", implying that whilst he learnt his lesson in Band Camp, he still acts with Stifler traits. He is mentioned again later by Mr. Levenstein after Erik asks if he could ask for some advice.
He has another cameo in as a name written on the rent card of "The Bible", implying that he must have rented it out at some point during his school years.
Evidently, Matt looks up to his older brother as a role model, and initially hopes to be just like him. However, after the events of Band Camp, he realizes that this future isn't as good as it previously seemed. Matt is notable to be possibly the only member of the Stifler family, aside from his older brother in American Wedding, to realize that the "Stifler Legacy" isn't necessarily a good one. He is also different from other Stiflers as Mr. Levenstein notes that people actually want to like him but they find it difficult due to the way he acts.
John and Justin
- Portrayed by John Cho and Justin Isfield
- Appeared in: American Pie, American Pie 2, American Wedding, and American Reunion
Their next appearance is in American Pie 2 in a slightly larger role. They are first seen at Stifler's party, once again. They are waiting to get into the bathroom, when they come across Paul Finch, who slept with Stifler's Mom in the first film. John and Justin admire Finch and ask him how he did it. They are next seen when John, in a memorable scene, urinates off of a balcony and onto Stifler's head, unintentionally. Justin covers his back as he does so. The two walk off and are not seen again until the climatic party scene at the beach house. They are seen getting drunk and partying with various women. The last we see of them is the two of them walking off on the beach, with John saying "Am I gonna have a hangover? 'Cause I want one."
They reappear in American Wedding, where John's name is revealed for the first time. The two serve as two ushers at Jim and Michelle's wedding. They are tasked with looking after Jim's grandma, but end up putting her inside a broom closet instead. John and Justin are last scene outside of Stifler's Mom's room window, peering in to see her taking a bath, where they see Paul Finch emerge from the water, performing cunnilingus on her. They once again chant "MILF", before the window steams up and obscures their view as Finch goes back under the water.
Their last appearance is in American Reunion. John has a much bigger role in this, and his character is expanded upon, while Justin only makes a brief cameo. John and Justin's names are never mentioned as they are credited as simply "MILF Guy #2" and "MILF Guy #1", respectively. John is first seen pulling up alongside Jim's car, as he has just crashed. He is panicking and asking if he is okay, until he realizes it is Jim. The two become reacquainted and talk to each other. John reveals he is organizing the reunion. He also mentions that he and his "MILF" buddy Justin are not on good terms right now, and would rather not speak of him. He sees Kara get out from Jim's lap, and, thinking it's Michelle, assumes she is performing fellatio on him. John laughs and gives a thumbs up to Jim before driving off. He is again seen at Stifler's party, where he almost blows Jim's cover by saying he saw Jim and Michelle last night, but then walks off before he can elaborate on it. He later watches Oz compete on the Celebrity Dance-Off video. He helps in the fight by throwing a weapon to Finch. When the cops arrive, John runs out of the house. At the reunion, John hands out name tags to all the class of '99. He is last seen in the bleachers, watching Stifler and Finch's Mom having sexual intercourse. He is drinking heavily and is depressed, due to Justin's absence. He hears "MILF" uttered to the side of him, and turns to see Justin. The two repeatedly say "MILF" softly to each other leading into their chant "MILF! MILF!" and then hug; the two continue to watch Stifler and Finch's Mom have sex as they gleefully chant.
Despite his effeminate behavior, according to the directors' commentary on American Reunion, John is a heterosexual.
Jeanine Stifler
- Portrayed by Jennifer Coolidge
- Appeared in: American Pie, American Pie 2, American Wedding, and American Reunion
Jeanine Stifler is the divorced mother of Steve and Matt Stifler. When Jim and his friends are at Stifler's house they see a picture of her. They are impressed and all want to have sex with her. Jeanine turns up at the end of the movie. She meets Paul Finch while he is exploring the house and enters the billiard room where she is sitting. Jeanine tries to seduce Paul and they have sex on the billiard table. They are caught by Steven.
In American Pie 2 there are many references to this incident. Jeanine is expected to be at the beach house where Jim, Paul, Steven and the others stay during their vacation. Paul, still in love with Jeanine, learned to control his sexual drifts via meditation and hopes to have sex with her once again. Stifler is certain this will not happen again. Just before the boys head home, a car turns up driven by Jeanine. She asks Paul if she can drive him home, to which he agrees. Stifler, who is still in the house, is told a lost tourist was asking the way and Paul decided to travel home on his own. However, Stifler is suspicious about the guys claims, demanding them to tell him who is that tourist in the car. In the next scene, Jeanine and Paul have sex in the car.
In American Wedding, Paul tells Steven he had sex twice with Jeanine, further fueling his anger. Once again, Jeanine turns up at the end of the movie. She tells Paul not to be interested in her anymore, to which he agrees. However, it is now revealed they had sex more than twice. They get excited and leave. In next scene, they have sex while taking a bath.
In American Reunion, Jeanine appears in a bigger role. She has grown tired of being looked upon as a sexual object and breaks up with a loser boyfriend. She later meets Jim's father Noah Levenstein, who is now a widower. Jeanine is smitten with Noah and they talk about their son's embarrassing moments in puberty while sharing a laugh. The two start a relationship by going to a movie, where she is touched at him for being a gentleman by treating her more like a woman.
Characters from ''[American Pie 2]''
Amber and Danielle
- Portrayed by Lisa Arturo and Denise Faye
- Appeared in: American Pie 2
Characters from ''[American Wedding]''
Cadence Flaherty
- Portrayed by January Jones
- Appeared in: American Wedding
Bear
- Portrayed by Eric Allan Kramer
- Appeared in: American Wedding
Grandma Levenstein
- Portrayed by Angela Paton
- Appeared in: American Wedding
Characters from ''[American Reunion]''
Past cast members including Jason Biggs, Seann William Scott, Eugene Levy, Alyson Hannigan, Chris Klein, Mena Suvari, Thomas Ian Nicholas, Tara Reid, Natasha Lyonne, Eddie Kaye Thomas, Shannon Elizabeth, Chris Owen, Jennifer Coolidge, and John Cho all appear in the film as their respective characters.Evan Levenstein
- Portrayed by George Christopher Bianchi
- Appeared in: American Reunion
Kara
- Portrayed by Ali Cobrin
- Appeared in: American Reunion
AJ
- Portrayed by Chuck Hittinger
- Appeared in: American Reunion
Dr. Ron
- Portrayed by Jay Harrington
- Appeared in: American Reunion
Mia
- Portrayed by Katrina Bowden
- Appeared in: American Reunion
Selena Vega
- Portrayed by Dania Ramirez
- Appeared in: American Reunion
Madison and Alexa
- Portrayed by Jennifer Bell and Autumn Dial
- Appeared in: American Reunion
When Stifler takes a call on his phone the two ditch him.
Characters from ''[American Pie Presents: Band Camp]''
Elyse Houston
- Portrayed by Arielle Kebbel
- Appeared in: American Pie Presents: Band Camp
Dialogue between Matt and Elyse suggest they were previously friends. This ended, however, after Elyse became tired with his frequent pranks and putdowns toward her for the appeasement of his brother. Despite this, they reconcile toward the end of the movie although their future is uncertain.
Brandon Vandecamp
- Portrayed by Matt Barr
- Appeared in: American Pie Presents: Band Camp
Ernie Kaplowitz
- Portrayed by Jason Earles
- Appeared in: American Pie Presents: Band Camp
James "Jimmy" Chong
- Portrayed by Jun Hee Lee
- Appeared in: American Pie Presents: Band Camp
He, along with his other fellow bandees turned against Matt after it was revealed he was secretly filming their raunchy misadventures to screen in front of the school at the start of the next semester. However, after Stifler redeemed himself he can be seen hanging around him leaving the presumption that they soon became friends after.
Characters from ''[American Pie Presents: The Naked Mile]''
Erik Stifler
- Portrayed by John White
- Appeared in: American Pie Presents: The Naked Mile and American Pie Presents: Beta House
In Naked Mile, Erik is ready to graduate high school. However, he is currently about to be the only one in his family to graduate a virgin. Deciding that he is clearly ready when she is not, Erik's girlfriend permits him a "hall pass" giving him the opportunity to do anything over the weekend without consequences. Ready to lose his virginity, he organizes a road trip with his two best friends Mike and Ryan to meet up with his elder cousin Dwight in college during The Naked Mile. Whilst he is presented with several opportunities to have sex, Erik decides he only truly wants to lose it with Tracy, his girlfriend, causing him to ride a horse back to her house and inform her that he doesn't care what happens as long as he's with her. They then reconcile and make love.
Erik returns in as he readies himself for his arrival at college. Tracy dumps Erik off-screen leaving him open for a relationship. Although he performed poorly at the opening party, his namesake causes him to become accepted in the Beta Fraternity due to Dwight's reasoning. The rest of the film then follows him, Mike Coozeman and his newly found friends and the tasks they perform to get into the frat. Erik also meets a girl called Ashley and begins dating her.
After they complete their final task to get into fraternity, which involves stealing something from the GEEK house, Edgar, the GEEK's president, challenges the BETAs to the Greek Olympiad. The loser will give up their charter and be evicted from their house. They win the tournament leaving Beta House a permanent fixture in the college.
Dwight Stifler
- Portrayed by Steve Talley
- Appeared in: American Pie Presents: The Naked Mile and American Pie Presents: Beta House
He first appears in Naked Mile, introduced by his younger cousin Erik as a "legendary Stifler boy" alongside his other cousins Matt and Steve.
Ryan Grimm
- Portrayed by Ross Thomas
- Appeared in: American Pie Presents: The Naked Mile
Mike "Cooze" Coozeman
- Portrayed by Jake Siegel
- Appeared in: American Pie Presents: The Naked Mile and American Pie Presents: Beta House
Tracy Sterling
- Portrayed by Jessy Schram
- Appeared in: American Pie Presents: The Naked Mile
Rock
- Portrayed by Jordan Prentice
- Appeared in: American Pie Presents: The Naked Mile and American Pie Presents: Beta House
Harry Stifler
- Portrayed by Christopher McDonald
- Appeared in: American Pie Presents: The Naked Mile and American Pie Presents: Beta House
Bull
- Portrayed by Dan Petronijevic
- Appeared in: American Pie Presents: The Naked Mile and American Pie Presents: Beta House
Jill
- Portrayed by Jaclyn A. Smith
- Appeared in: American Pie Presents: The Naked Mile and American Pie Presents: Beta House
Characters from ''[American Pie Presents: Beta House]''
Ashley Thomas
- Portrayed by Meghan Heffern
- Appeared in: American Pie Presents: Beta House
Edgar Willis
- Portrayed by Tyrone Savage
- Appeared in: American Pie Presents: Beta House
Characters from ''[American Pie Presents: The Book of Love]''
Rob Shearson
- Portrayed by Bug Hall
- Appeared in: American Pie Presents: The Book of Love
The story ends with Rob, Nathan and Lube returning the newly restored Bible to where Rob found it, after Rob has added his signature to it. As a finale, Rob's brother, Cody, enters his bedroom to find an online film of him putting a vacuum cleaner on his penis. To his horror it has been viewed almost 10 million times. Rob ends the film with the words "Gotchaaaaa, ha ha."
Scott Stifler
- Portrayed by John Patrick Jordan
- Appeared in: American Pie Presents: The Book of Love
Nathan Jenkyll
- Portrayed by Kevin M. Horton
- Appeared in: American Pie Presents: The Book of Love
Marshall "Lube" Lubetsky
- Portrayed by Brandon Hardesty
- Appeared in: American Pie Presents: The Book of Love
Heidi
- Portrayed by Beth Behrs
- Appeared in: American Pie Presents: The Book of Love
Dana
- Portrayed by Melanie Papalia
- Appeared in: American Pie Presents: The Book of Love
Ashley Lawrence
- Portrayed by Jennifer Holland
- Appeared in: American Pie Presents: The Book of Love
Imogen
- Portrayed by Louisa Lytton
- Appeared in: American Pie Presents: The Book of Love