The original Maggoty Gap was a wind gap in the Blue Ridge Mountains in the counties of Roanoke, Virginia and Franklin, Virginia. Over time, as roads were improved and relocated, the identified location of the gap moved with them. It is now mapped at a spot in Roanoke County.
Geography
"Maggoty Gap" is now named at a location approximately south of Roanoke, Virginia and north-northwest of Rocky Mount, Virginia at an elevation of. The present identified location of Maggoty Gap on topographic maps is at 37.156°N 79.972°W, which is actually inside the Back Creek watershed, not at the ridge line. But State Road 677 does pass through it to the highway leading to the true ridge line at "Murray Gap", which separates the Maggodee Creek watershed from the Back Creek watershed. This route connects Starkey, Virginia and Boone's Mill, Virginia. An alternate route is State Road 613 through the "Simmonds Gap". There are also two unimproved ridge line gaps between Simmonds Gap and Murray Gap that lead south to Maggodee Creek. These are reached from Starkey, Virginia via Starlight Road and Boone's Chapel Road. One is at the end of Boone's Chapel Road where a Jeep trail crosses the Franklin County line at a pipeline and descends to State Road 613 adjacent to the Maggodee Creek bridge. The other is at the end of Wild Turkey Road and passing just below and east of Milner Place, where it crosses the Franklin County line and descends to Maggodee Creek at the junction of State Road 852 and State Road 613.
History
"Maggoty Gap" describes a natural gateway of the Great Wagon Road that made it possible for wagons and livestock traffic to pass through the Blue Ridge Mountains at Roanoke, Virginia near Maggoty Creek. It carried enormous amounts of traffic in the late 18th century and much of the 19th century until a railroad was extended over the ridge in 1892. During the years from 1760 to 1776 it was said to be the heaviest traveled road in all of America. Morgan Bryan cut the path for the first wagon to cross the gap from Starkey, Virginia to Boone's Mill, Virginia in 1746. He reported that he had to disassemble his wagon and carry it piecemeal up the last slope. In 1753, the original 15 Moravians used Bryan's road to get a wagon to their Wachovia Tract located at present-day Winston-Salem, but took a wrong turn and missed Maggoty Gap; instead with great difficulty they traveled over nearby Windy Gap and rejoined Bryan's road at present-day Boone's Mill. In 1838, Claudius Crozet surveyed the road for its improvement as the Pittsylvania, Franklin, and Botetourt Turnpike, still made of dirt but with grades generally to be less than 4 percent and the carriageway to be a minimum of 18 feet wide. In his field notes, he had two sketches showing "Maggoty Creek" winding around in the vicinity of the present-day junction of State Roads 613 and 726, and also a road continuing up past the Jacob Naff homestead and John ArthurRoad to the "top of the Blue Ridge" where he labeled the present-day Simmonds Gap as "Maggoty Gap". His sketch showed the road continuing due north down to the cultivated fields of Starkey. He also noted that a nearby path was not "the lowest and best gap". The turnpike was built immediately afterward, following the route over Simmonds Gap that eventually has become State Road 613. It suffered deterioration during the Civil War years, however, and the turnpike was abandoned by its owners around 1865. Maggoty Gap lost its economic importance when the paved highway US-220 was completed directly from Roanoke through Murray Gap to Rocky Mount, Virginia around 1930.
